6 ms·
The Overton window isn't individually defined. It might not be false to say that there's more than one, but there isn't one per person. Most of the outrage isn
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
The Overton window isn't individually defined. It might not be false to say that there's more than one, but there isn't one per person.
Most of the outrage isn't about democratization. It's about the gutter-level quality of the voices. I don't think many people at the time had much of a problem with someone like William Buckley being the mouthpiece for the views he expressed on national media, even if they strongly disagreed with those views. He may have been a racist bigot, but he was a thoughtful, literate, articulate racist bigot. Likewise, even the far right tends to have a little grudging respect for the ability of someone like Noam Chomsky to articulate a view of the world with which they fundamentally disagree.
But democratization hasn't resulted in lots more voices cleverly or playfully or insightfully or creatively expressing new (or existing) points of view.
It has resulted in a culture filled with endlessly repeating garbage, where the dumbest, most simplistic, least nuanced crap dominates by volume. Oh, and of course, endless snark, because people don't actually have the courage to say what they really mean, but instead just use snark to try to make other people seem less funny, less clued in and therefore "obviously" wrong.
You seem to be claiming an awfully deep level of insight into the psychology of "elites"
> "which is something they are not used to, indeed they are offended by needing to - it's a real shock to them"
are you a part of this elite, or perhaps study them? They don't seem to actually write a lot - that would be mostly middle class pundits - or appear on TV or other visual media - that would be said pundits and/or party officials or elected representatives. I'm not sure where this level of insight can come from?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The Overton window isn't individually defined. Sure, it is. > It might not be false to say that there's more than one, There is one for any group of people definable as a meaningful political context, down to and including individuals. > but there isn't one per person. Because each person is a coherent political unit and there are also coherent political units with more than one person, there is strictly greater than one Overton window per person.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI know, wikipedia's not the final arbiter, but: > The Overton window is the range of policies politically acceptable to the mainstream population at a given time. It is also known as the window of discourse. > The term is named after American policy analyst Joseph P. Overton, who stated that an idea's political viability depends mainly on whether it falls within this range, rather than on politicians' individual preferences. According to Overton, the window frames the range of policies that a politician can recommend without appearing too extreme to gain or keep public office given the climate of public opinion at that time. This definition does not really allow for the notion of an individual's "own" Overton Window, which would be something without any statistical properties, given it corresponds precisely with "what one person currently believes".
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This definition does not really allow for the notion an individual's "own" Overton Window, which would something without any statistical properties, given it corresponds precisely with "what one person currently believes". Sure, an individuals Overton window is “the range of policies that a politician can recommend without appearing too extreme” to a voter; in any context the Overton window is per dimension; an idea within the window on an individual sense is one which does not, on its own, rule the candidate out of consideration by that voter, its not the same as the single point the individal voter prefers; this is just exactly the usual sense of an Overton window where the polity has one viewpoint, not just of preferred policies but of which non-preferred ones are and are not deal breakers.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThe concept behind the overton window is fundamentally rooted in the statistical properties of large numbers of people. It's not about what might or might not appeal to a voter, it's about what might or might not appeal to a large number of voters, where the effects of statistics mask the noise inherent in their individual foibles, and things coalesce to give you a sort-of clear answer.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> He may have been a racist bigot, I sense an inner authoritarian coming out of their pupa here. > even the far right tends to have a little grudging respect for the ability of someone like Noam Chomsky The "far right" has about as much respect for Noam Chomsky as the "far left" has for John Birch. Which is to say, they view him as a peddler of hateful conspiracy theories that his low information followers unquestioningly believe. A dangerous person that should be silenced. If you think otherwise, you are fooling yourself about any supposed admiration there is for Chomsky. > It's about the gutter-level quality of the voices. Now are you talking about Chomsky again? Because you still think that the right is objectively worse than the left and that's just not the case. Some people are just natural authoritarians and any opposing views are "gutter discourse" whereas their own enlightened views have to be grudgingly admired. That's not how it works. And I would not recommend that anyone read Chomsky because the value of his political commentary really is the same as that of John Birch, IMO. There are some important nuggets of insight, but you have to be immunized against all the conspiracy theories and hate, and most readers don't have the appropriate background to handle it. They will come away with a feeling of faux-insight that is just a bubble of misinformation. And they tend to be very angry and militant. We need less of that. > but instead just use snark to try to make other people seem less funny There's no need to bring John Oliver into the discussion. There is lots of snark, but I agree it's not helpful to focus on it. > I'm not sure where this level of insight can come from? Yes, the snark is a real problem.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Yes, the snark is a real problem. How would you preferred that I put it? I have no idea of your relationship to the putative elites that you're describing; I see no way that a random HN commenter can possibly have the kind of insight that you're claiming in describing how "they" "feel" about the "voices of the masses". So I tried to ask as neutrally as I could, without doubting that you might in fact really have some authoritative knowledge of this, so that you could let us know whether this was just you pontificating about people you don't actually have any real knowledge of, or actually real information.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Some people are just natural authoritarians and any opposing views are "gutter discourse" whereas their own enlightened views have to be grudgingly admired. Oh FFS. I am sure that you read at least some social media. I limit myself to Twitter and don't follow many people, but even there, my exposure to stuff that is "gutter discourse" is still more than I'd like, and it comes from every direction and ideology. I'm not talking about right/left stuff, I'm talking about people who really don't know what they're talking about but still insist on talking.