3 ms·
Here's the strange thing about Guy Fawkes. In 1984, the IRA managed to set off a bomb in an attempt to wipe out most of the then-Conservative Party government o
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Here's the strange thing about Guy Fawkes. In 1984, the IRA managed to set off a bomb in an attempt to wipe out most of the then-Conservative Party government of the UK. They got the timing wrong, and had almost no impact on governance although some people died and more were injured.
If Nov 5th is celebrated because Guy Fawkes failed, why do we not also celebrate October 12th?
If Nov 5th is celebrated because Guy Fawkes tried, why do we not also celebrate Oct 12th?
- bobsmooth 5y agoFawkes was captured, tortured and then publicly executed. Are there any infamous IRA agents?
- ben_w 5y agoYes, for various values of infamous, including at least one elected MP who was elected while in prison and who then died from a hunger strike while still in prison. I can’t speak to who likes/hates who and how much, but the murals in Belfast were hard to miss even as a tourist. https://www.mentalfloss.com/photos/555460/20-militant-murals-northern-ireland https://www.mentalfloss.com/photos/555460/20-militant-murals...
- klelatti 5y agoOne theory: Nov 5th was a failed coup and the state had an interest in reminding people of that failure and the consequences for the plotters. Oct 12th was a lapse in the security surrounding the government and so the state had no interest in reminding people of that failure.
- ogogmad 5y agoYour mistake is thinking that there's a because. People originally celebrated Nov 5th because they lived in a period in which such things were thought worthy of celebrating. It continues to be celebrated only because it's a long tradition now. Celebrating such a thing is considered to be in bad taste nowadays, but inertia is inertia.
- klelatti 5y agoThe (recent) justification for continuing to celebrate 5th Nov is simply that a plot to blow up parliament was defeated in a country that subsequently became a parliamentary democracy. I think we’re more sensitive to ‘both sides’ now. Even so blowing up Parliament is still generally seen as a bad thing. Obviously that’s not to condone either the persecution of any religious minority at the time or the treatment of the plotters.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> People originally celebrated Nov 5th because they lived in a period in which such things were thought worthy of celebrating. Could be. Or it could just have been in the interests of the powers of the day to encourage such a celebration, and people went along with it because well, who doesn't love a good bonfire?
- mrjangles 5y agoThat's really easy to answer. At the time of Guy Fawkes, the Protestant world was in a battle for survival. Catholics were in the process of burning over 100,000 people on the cross, and they would imminently launch the 30 year war which is regarded as one of the most destructive in human civilization. In the next 150 years, the UK would face multiple attempts from Catholics to take over the country. Guy Fawkes was a useful and pertinent symbol to remind people of the ongoing battle. By the year 1984 this had all been finished for more than a hundred years at least. Through the hegemony of England and then the US, Protestantism and the ideals of freedom of religion, freedom of thought, and national independence had won out over the world. The IRA was just a terrorist group of no real importance in the larger scheme of things.
- qwytw 5y agoEquating Protestantism with the freedom of religion or freedom of thought is a bit of a stretch, don't you think? Considering that protestants were generally just as keen on burning catholics, other protestants or generally people they didn’t like (much more so than the catholics in the case of witches) as the catholics. Of course the degree of extremism varied amongst different denominations (however the more liberal and pacifist groups were never in power in anywhere and were often oppressed and persecuted). For instance the closest modern equivalent of calvinism (as practiced by John Calvin himself in Geneva) would surely be Wahhabism (or the Taliban)? Religious freedom was a fringe idea in the UK until the late 18th/early 19th centuries.
- mrjangles 5y agoYes definitely not all Protestant sects believed in these values, they are all very different after all, but it was a common trend because they had all suffered persecution. Protestants fled to America and the spirit of freedom of religion was started there, particularly in Pennsylvanian under the Quakers (where all religions including Muslims, Jews and Hindus were welcome... but not Catholics). The witch burning were started, and continued to be carried out mostly by the Catholics, but there are exceptions such as the large number that took place in Scotland. Also during the chaos and slaughter wrought by the invading Catholics, there were many cases of revenge attacks as everyone struggled for survival, but I don't know where you get the idea that it was mostly carried out by protestants. As to your other point, pacifism and pacifist groups were a rarity but that has nothing to do with freedom of ideas. The whole basis of Protestantism is that human authority has no sway over man and each individual has to find god their own way through reading and through thought. It is very clear from history that these ideas were started by the Protestants and were spread everywhere that protestants went. Just look at where in the world all the scientific breakthroughs took place over time.