3 ms·
It's a long article with an admirable examination of history. However, I feel Carr has made a mistake with his attempt to differentiate between private communi
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
It's a long article with an admirable examination of history.
However, I feel Carr has made a mistake with his attempt to differentiate between private communication and broadcasting based on "number of followers".
I think the better distinctions looks something like:
private communication is anything delivered ONLY to people to whom it is addressed or who have actively opted-in to receive communications from the sender. some authentication must be implied before they can read what I have delivered.
any other communication, regardless of the medium, number of followers, etc. is considered to be public.
So, if I tweet about something, since anyone could read my tweets, they are all public. If I DM someone on twitter, that's private.
If I post something on my own private blog that requires a subscription to read, that's private communication. If I post the same thing on a medium where it can be read by anyone, that's public.
If I email my family about something, that's private; if I post a comment on a tiny open wordpress site with less readers than I have cousines, that's public.
This differentiation says nothing about what the difference in regulation between public and private should be. There are good arguments for many different schemes, some of which involve zero regulation for either form. But to discuss the merits of them, we need a clear distinction between private & public communication, and I think Carr's is wrong and mine is (roughly) right.