3 ms·
Recently I researched a dozen or two of the events on the table, and there is a lot of uncertainty of fact, issues of definition, and interpretation involved. T
by wolverine876 5y ago
Recently I researched a dozen or two of the events on the table, and there is a lot of uncertainty of fact, issues of definition, and interpretation involved. That doesn't mean the author is wrong, but take each date as one interpretation of many.
For example, Ancient Greek, developed in ~8th or 10th century BCE (facts aren't 100% clear), is typically credited as the first phonetic alphabet, where characters represent sounds (and the only one - all others being derived from it). The OP says,
> 1850: earliest alphabetic script (Proto-Sinaitic, Sinai and Egypt)
They may mean something slightly different. Also an alphabet of sorts preceded Ancient Greek, maybe the one in the quote above, but lacked vowels among other things, so it depends on your definition of phonetic alphabet.
That's just on example, know there are many ambiguities of definition, fact, and interpretation.
- csomar 5y ago> as the first phonetic alphabet I thought the Phoenician are credited for the alphabet. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoenician_language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoenician_language > The Phoenician alphabet was spread to Greece during this period, where it became the source of all modern European scripts.
- wolverine876 5y agoThat was the precursor without vowels, IIRC. In my very limited experience, more experts seem to say the Greek alphabet was the first that qualified as such. But really, 'who was first' is a matter of definition, of course.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- erhk 5y agoMuch of homo erectus is similarly debated but OP treats factually
- pphysch 5y agoYeah, there is a strong cultural bias here. "Timeline of the Human Condition according to one Westerner's interpretation of a couple Western encyclopedias"
- wolverine876 5y agoI wouldn't be surprised, but in what entries do you see the Western bias? I wonder what I might be getting wrong myself.
- pphysch 5y agoChina has two (2) mentions within the last 900 years. The great famine and COVID-19. A third one (BRI 2013) is buried under a mention of the original Silk Roads in 100 BCE. People's Republic founding is omitted, despite being the first post-colonial/indigenous "superstate". It will certainly be at least as historically consequential as the founding of the USA. No mention of PRC eradicating extreme poverty nor surpassing the USA in GDP PPP. Reading the timeline, you get the sense that all recent human progress is occurring in the West and the West alone is positioned to address global issues. Which is a very distorted view.
- wolverine876 5y ago> China has two (2) mentions within the last 900 years. That is certainly absurd! I hadn't looked past about 5,000 yrs ago. > the first post-colonial/indigenous "superstate" I've read a good amount of Chinese history and other works, including by Chinese authors (translated), and I haven't heard that idea so I am interested in learning a bit: Who uses the term? Historians? Political scientists? The CCP? Is it new? What do you meant by "superstate"? A major power? Post-colonial: The US, Canada, etc. are post-colonial, former British colonies. If you mean, after the West's period of colonization post-Industrial Revolution, what about India, which was founded a few years before? Japan, which was itself a colonial power (with some horrible consequences)? The post-WWI Middle East? Finally, I'm not quite sure how 'indigenous' applies. China has been a collection of cultures, enough so that holding it together has always preoccupied whoever was in power. My impression is that it is more like Europe in that sense, including varying local languages, than the US (though different than both). All those questions don't make it wrong; they are merely what I don't understand. > It will certainly be at least as historically consequential as the founding of the USA. No mention of PRC eradicating extreme poverty nor surpassing the USA in GDP PPP. > Reading the timeline, you get the sense that all recent human progress is occurring in the West and the West alone is positioned to address global issues. Which is a very distorted view. Isn't this as Sino-centric as the timeline is Western-centric? If we know such approaches are factually distorting (you just made a good point about it), and we know also that nationalistic competition leads to catastrophe (WWII being a prominent example), why take them? Do you want to intentionally make the same mistakes as the timeline? I hope the people of China do great things - not only for themselves, but for the world, and that they have freedom to live their lives as they choose, with health and prosperity. Do better than the colonial powers.