4 ms·
I still feel the same way now about this article that I did then: Popularity is a misguided goal for Emacs. Emacs is a hacker's editor. Back when I started usin
by bitwize 5y ago
I still feel the same way now about this article that I did then: Popularity is a misguided goal for Emacs. Emacs is a hacker's editor. Back when I started using it, the OS I ran it on -- Linux -- was niche, and the editor itself was niche of the niche. It seemed to come with "power users only" signs guarding it. It had its own diskset in Slackware because it was big and heavy and not the kind of thing every Linux user needed to have so you could easily exclude it. It's designed to be shaped into a custom tool that does what you need the way you need it done, as you work with it. Not everybody works this way, not every programmer works this way. Many enterprise shops aim for a software factory approach where there is one common, blessed workflow and you train people in that workflow and just plug them right into the assembly line. Those people make up the vast bulk of developers and most of them wouldn't know what to do with an Emacs if they had one. And that's fine.
When those people start crossing over onto Emacs mailing lists and going "What Emacs needs is to work exactly like my favorite IDE, else it will die in obscurity" I'm just like, psh. Go away. You've got your own great big ballfield to play in, why do you feel the need to come in and start trying to set rules for our little one?
In fact, this reminds me of a story. Back in the early 2000s there was a clown called Scott McCollum. An ultraconservative, he was fond of writing articles about how Linux and open source were communist cancer. McCollum had an acolyte named Joseph D. Wagner, who once trolled the gcc mailing list with a bug report about a TOTALLY CRITICAL SECURITY VULNERABILITY wherein gcc's optimizer would remove code to scrub sensitive data such as passwords from a buffer before reusing the buffer. When he was told "that's what 'volatile' is for" and to go fuck himself by the gcc maintainers, Wagner had an op-ed published on McCollum's site wherein he went "AHA! The open-source commies maintaining gcc don't care about your security! Use Microsoft Visual C++ if you want your software to be secure!"
Because of people like that, I don't trust entryists from outside a community. I have reason to believe there's a good chance they're not acting in good faith for the benefit of the project.