13 ms·
DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrastructure bill
- Soul3000 5y agoWow. Read half this thread and had to make an account to reply. Love the deep philosophy tied to economics and crypto. Imo, I don't care about crypto being crypto, or about paying taxes. In fact, I prefer to pay taxes like income, and for the government to be able to track it, that way banks can more easily incorporate digital asset holdings which will increase the power of bitcoin and therefore the innovation bitcoin provides. That being said, I suppose it means I agree that you have to go "through the state first." Abolishing the state? I don't have that visionary capacity, however, certainly taking a step towards a utopia where there are less middle men, lowers the wealth gap therefore. Furthermore, technology is ultimately what will one day lead us to renewable energy sources, genomics which can help us understand anxiety and depression better, and oh yeah. Space travel :) So using the state to prop up bitcoin sounds like the much more efficient idea. The term "crypto" in itself is a slap in the face, therefore, imo. We want to take a step towards limiting the states power, but not so much of a step to arise heavy social movements against bitcoin via state supported propaganda. That being said, I loved the example of saying that I am not liable for knowing who held my cash before I did when going to a bank ATM. The bank, however, is required to verify incoming funds are not tied to illegal activities. That being said, the bank only has to verify the identify of the person sending funds to them directly, not investigate where the funds came prior. They then work with the IRS, simply to report any sums coming in over a certain dollar amount, and perhaps any funds that fail some sort of security verification tied to hacking. I read that identify verification of bitcoin users can be time consuming, so I have tried to find out which software would allow banks to easily track an identity. It could, come to pass that exchanges that do not disclose identities of funds when transferring funds, will not be able to interact with banks in the future, and/or, they will not be allowed to operate in the US at all. I would be more than fine with that. I am all for the protection of privacy in many areas, but I still believe in paying taxes, and so I don't expect privacy on the movements of my assets when they are tied to income. Now if I send 1M to someone. To me, it becomes the liability of the person receiving that amount and/or their exchange or bank to report it, not me, as I'm not the one making income. Now if I report it as a loss to avoid taxes, then yes, I would expect less privacy in that case. Now, when I buy from an exchange and bits come from everywhere, that makes the exchange liable not me, and yes they should have an accessible list of identities for any subpoenas looking for crime, however, without a crime, they should only have to actually report large amounts transferring from person to person, or report income made from selling an asset. That list would make it easy, if the IRS was investigating someone, to compare that number to a person's reported income. It should not be that difficult really, but trying to avoid it? That seems like a good way for exchanges to get investigated or barred from activity. Even still, some exchanges will comply, and investors can simply shift to them, or they can go to non US exchanges, but if they ever bring that money back into the US, then it would be reported over a certain dollar amount by that receiving exchange etc.. etc... So I don't really see a complex issue really, unless no exchange is operating in a way that would comply with normal income reporting tax code. I'd like to know which exchange is or is not. As far as feudalism and market makers who benefit more than "the common people." Ultimately that comes down to the ability to prosper, thrive, find freedom, life liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Having more control and more money, like jeff bezos, isn't going to yield enough happiness to say that is a worthy end goal, because it still falls short on several accounts: Spiral Dynamic Theory, Maslow's Heirarchy, and perhaps Map of Consciousness theory. A person benefiting more than the social environment around them, creates alienation and creates existential angst. Therefore, what bitcoin is to me... is the promise of expanded innovation. If the whole world can communicate better through fair global trade through blockchain, and advanced circuitry leads us one day to clean, renewable energy, the entire base line of global culture will rise, and everyone ends up benefiting equally. Having more money than someone else, ultimately is a minimal factor in comparison to the whole ecosystem improving, and that is what I believe bitcoin is bringing. So yeah. Crypto due to untrust of state. I get it, and I agree, but sometimes innovation is more about learning how we can all work together, and that ultimately is what decentralization is supposed to do. We just have to pay our taxes in the mean time, bc learning to decentralize, does not mean we will have the millions of advancements needed to tie in to that decentralization to effectively roll out a new culture. It may take 100 years... Like when we went into Iraq. Great idea to take out a dictator, but how to do reconstruction and build a new culture? Woops. NO IDEA. An initial great idea needs a long time to develop to truly understand its applications, and it seems much more beneficial to get the state behind bitcoin than to buck the system. But if for example I have to pay a higher short term gains rate than I do other income? Then I would not be happy. Oh, and the market makers, the nodes, have incentive to operate, so capitalism is built into the code. Decentralization combined with capitalism, seemed to be the right call for our current state in evolution per spiral dynamic theory.
- sharmin123 5y agoFacebook Safety Tips: Take Steps Now and Avoid Hacking: https://www.hackerslist.co/facebook-safety-tips-take-steps-now-and-avoid-hacking/ https://www.hackerslist.co/facebook-safety-tips-take-steps-n...
- WalterGR 5y ago“Hidden” may be a bit strong. At the very least, it’s not uncommon in US legislation: Rider (legislation) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rider_(legislation) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rider_(legislation)
- bradwood 5y agoThis will likely have to be tested in court if not fixed legislatively. What is more concerning is that legislators can come up with this clearly unworkable law without doing a modicum of research.
- elil17 5y agoWhy would this require a court test? It's clearly constitutional (commerce clause) and there are a ton of past legal cases where reporting requirements have been enforced. Any "DeFi" user/creator who tries to keep using those products after this law passes would be well advised to take a plea deal because they would really have no defense.
- malermeister 5y agoWhy would this law be unworkable? You are under the assumption that you have a god-given right to DeFi. You do not. If this law is incompatible with DeFi, it is DeFi that is unworkable, not the law.
- rasengan 5y ago> without doing a modicum of research I think they know exactly what they are doing.
- TheBill 5y agoThey do, and they very much view it as a threat to the centralized power of the USG.
- the_optimist 5y agoAt the very least, it's a legislative shake down opportunity. Form a team 'for' and a team 'against,' and each gets paid to 'fight' by their respective consitutency.
- mattnewton 5y agoOr rather, the lobbyists working with them know what they are doing
- gfodor 5y agoPerhaps the best way to deal with these laws is to let the ones that turn a few million innocent people into felons overnight pass, vs whittle them down so it’s just a few thousand (eg based on net worth or transaction size.) The former would never hold given the consequences, the latter would and eventually be ratcheted.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoI think it would be nice if we passed laws that made sense. If a law is going to turn millions of people into criminals overnight - then you probably need some kind of grandfather clause, or else it's just a bad law.
- malermeister 5y agoOr maybe millions of people are just doing bad things?
- nickff 5y ago>"Perhaps the best way to deal with these laws is to let the ones that turn a few million innocent people into felons overnight pass" There are already hundreds if not thousands of these; the average person commits a felony something like once a day. Nobody seems to want to tackle over-criminalization. Many books and articles have been written on the subject, and I invite you to read them.
- eindiran 5y agoA felony per day? That cannot possibly be true; maybe the average person commits 1+ "crimes" per day, but not felonies. The only felonies I can think of that an "average person" can plausibly have committed in their entire life: mail fraud, damaging mailboxes, election fraud, tax evasion (willful and intentional evasion of a federal tax), accidental violation of the NFA (on something like what counts as an SBR), obscenity (because who even knows what counts as obscenity anymore), selling/buying _large_ quantities of drugs, grand larceny, cyber crime, vandalism of federal property, and copyright infringement (for _significant_ profit). Most of those are seriously straining plausibility on the "average person" front. Am I missing something? I just can't see how a felony a day is even close to the correct order of magnitude.
- jimbob45 5y agoIs DeFi what we're officially calling cryptocurrencies now? A quick Google search looks like that's the case but I don't know if DeFi covers anything else that I haven't thought of.
- hammock 5y agoDeFi is not cryptocurrency, it's a specific use case of cryptocurrency.
- jimbob45 5y agoFeel free to expand on why that is. I'm genuinely asking - this is the first time I've heard that portmanteau.
- nprz 5y agoIt's a collection of protocols use to loan and trade cryptocurrencies. The goal of DeFi is to replicate all the services a bank could offer, but through decentralized apps running on the blockchain.
- newacc9 5y agoGenerally, its loans that are over-collateralized with crypto-assets. Use case being: I need cash now but I think ETH will go up and I don't want to sell mine, instead I borrow stablecoin against my ETH using a DeFi app (probably on ethereum).
- the_optimist 5y agoDo you have an example of collateral management in this context?
- newacc9 5y agoIts all automated, so it depends on the contract, I assume if the USD value of ETH drops too much, the borrower gets margin called.
- danny_codes 5y agoOn first read I don't see anything wrong with this bill. It appears to extend a reporting requirement already applying to cash transfers to other forms of monetary exchange. I don't see why transferring money via a cryptocurrency vs cash should be subject to different rules.
- I_am_tiberius 5y agoDid you read the "it imposes reporting requirements that, given the way DeFi works, would make it impossible to comply" part? If that's not wrong I'm not sure what you expect.
- Arcuru 5y agoUnfortunately, saying that something is "illegal by design" is not usually an effective defense. This is just the kind of thing that cryptocurrencies need to contend with if they want to be used everywhere. Either they need to comply with the existing financial regulations or become powerful enough that they can change the financial regulations.
- josho 5y agoOr where we are today raise enough attention (through articles like this) that this new requirement does not become law.
- BitwiseFool 5y ago>"saying that something is "illegal by design" is not usually an effective defense." Is it though? Putting onerous requirements on something is an excellent de-facto way to effectively outlaw something when there isn't enough political will to directly ban it. Edit: Look no further than what Texas is trying to do with abortion access. They can't directly outlaw abortion but they can add a bunch of inane requirements that make getting one prohibitive. Alabama continually passes laws that put additional requirements on the staff of abortion clinics and most of them are not reasonable, unless the reason is to make operation increasingly difficult. https://www.prochoiceamerica.org/state-law/alabama/ https://www.prochoiceamerica.org/state-law/alabama/
- ALittleLight 5y agoTangential, but it's preposterously stupid that our legal system works by legislators voting on a giant collection of laws bundled together, rather than separating these things into entities with specific concerns and voting on those. Shouldn't it be reasonable for someone to think the infrastructure bill is a good idea but this part is not?
- breadzeppelin__ 5y agoI often try to think of a rule that would require simplified bills without just having arbitrary limits. Like, wouldn't it be nice if each thing voted on had to be less than 8 pages (for example) in length instead of 3000. I'm sure there is some downside though like how will we fit all the pork in to this vote??!?
- louloulou 5y agoIt should be +1 day per page before it can be voted on. It's completely absurd that the people voting on these bills don't have the chance to read and understand them before having to give an opinion and change the laws governing >300M people. The whole thing makes a mockery of representative democracy.
- 5y ago
- narrator 5y agoThe biggest problem is that you could comply in that an ssn could be attached to each transaction, but ssns are both usernames and passwords that are used to authorize transactions and identify a person, so they can't be stored where everyone can read them. Perhaps if the government switched over to digital signatures instead of SSNs compliance would be possible. The requirement for secrets only shared with the government in each transaction is what breaks crypto in this instance. Perhaps someone could figure out a way to easily attach secret information that only the government could read to each transaction? One solution would be that each transaction would have an identity broker attached to it where you would store your verified identity that would send the tax records to the IRS for you on the person the transfer was going to on their behalf, so you wouldn't have to see the SSN of everyone you did business with and likewise. The key here is to separate custody of funds from knowledge of identity. Edit: downvotes? Why? Can someone tell me why I'm at least wrong?
- dogman144 5y ago> Perhaps someone could figure out a way to easily attach secret information that only the government could read to each transaction? attaching an SSN to every bitcoin transaction is nonsensical, in short.
- josho 5y agoYou are thinking of this like a technologist. Think about it on how we handle reporting requirements on a cash transaction. There is nothing inherent in a cash purchase that facilitates reporting of the transaction to the government. All of that _paperwork_ is handled outside of the transaction itself. With crypto the same manual reporting would apply. If however we want to supplement crypto with new extensions to help facilitate the reporting that's certainly possible.
- bob229 5y agoGood. Crypto pish should be illegal
- serverholic 5y agoI don't understand why people talk about crypto with such venom in their tone. Yes there are scams but there is legitimately interesting innovation happening too. Interesting mathematic, economic, and computer science ideas are being explored and tested. In the future it may be possible to have a global financial system where the users are in control of their own funds. Isn't that something worth exploring?
- malermeister 5y ago"The users are in control of their own funds" just means "Jeff Bezos owns everything with no viable way to get it back". State control of funds is the only thing that can bring us back from the brink of neofeudalism. The venom is against the people trying to accelerate our decline by taking that away.
- deputydoofy 5y agoAh yes, The State will certainly save us from neofeudalism, all hail The State, it will solve all problems and absolve us of innovation or independent thought.
- serverholic 5y agoThe state is there to enforce corporate interests. Competition is what these companies are afraid of.
- malermeister 5y agoThat's just the current form the state is taking in the US. As a counterexample, there was a lot you could accuse the USSR of, but enforcing corporate interests was not one of them.
- serverholic 5y agoIn that case just replace "corporate interests" with "the interests of powerful elites" in my statement.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 5y agoTbh the ETH community should probably work with regulators to get a standard for what logs to produce. As it currently stands anyone could generate the reports needed for DeFi on ETH, but it'd take understanding each contact to do it. If there was a standard eth log to emit then contacts could choose to emit it and then as long as one actor in the environment coalesces all of those logs and reports it then they'd all be in compliance
- coleca 5y agoExcept we aren't tracking names, addresses, and SSNs of the holder of each ETH wallet, which is required for the IRS reporting under this proposed amendment to the statute.
- malermeister 5y agoWell maybe they should? The whole argument seems to be "we want to do questionable stuff, why doesn't the government let us?"
- numtel 5y agoIMO, governments should provide a service for linking identity to cryptocurrency account addresses. Let me present my passport and link my account using a web service or at the post office. This way, DeFi protocols don't have to worry about anything to be compliant and if the government provides an attribute on-chain, it can be used to build democratic DAOs with "One person, One vote" instead of the plutocratic operation of today's DAOs. Gist with details about implementation: https://gist.github.com/numtel/c2030ec401959a45825ee3efc6f3bb74 https://gist.github.com/numtel/c2030ec401959a45825ee3efc6f3b...
- X6S1x6Okd1st 5y agoDeFi protocols (that want to) should still conform to a spec that gives the three letter agencies insight into what kind of action was performed, e.g. it's pretty unclear what exactly AAVE's debt tracking is unless you read the docs, multiply that by every single DeFi app & protocol and it's really intensive.
- legutierr 5y agoHmm. The article talks about the question of DeFi, where the sender might be a smart contract, making it difficult or impossible to identify any human beings to include in a report. The issue would seem to be much broader than that, however. What about miner or validator rewards? Is it an implication of the bill that the receipt of digital assets as part of a miner or validator reward would also trigger a reporting requirement, if the block reward exceeds $10,000 in value? Who would one be able to identify as the person responsible for sending the portion of the reward that is generated by cryptocurrency inflation? And what about miner fees? Would every user that pays miner fees need to be identified? Even a simple transfer would require a sender to identify themselves both to their recipient and to the miner who mines the block. But how would the miner and the sender even have the physical ability to connect with each other to share this information, even if they wanted to? It's one thing to make DeFi illegal, or to make participating in DeFi in a compliant manner impractical, it's an entirely different thing to make operating a miner illegal or impractical. Somehow I doubt this would have been Congress's intent, but might it be the effect of the bill?
- smitty1e 5y agoWhy are we not demanding Congress put pending legislation in a suitably architected public git repo, and then hitting it with AI to find out how our "aristocracy" is burning us ahead of the flame application?