8 ms·
At roughly 25W per Performance Core running at 5.2GHz on Intel 7nm High Performance Node, with a ST Geekbench score of ~1900. Compared to The Apple M1 Max runni
by ksec 5y ago
At roughly 25W per Performance Core running at 5.2GHz on Intel 7nm High Performance Node, with a ST Geekbench score of ~1900. Compared to The Apple M1 Max running at 3.2GHz on a TSMC 5nm Low Power node, at roughly 5W per core, with Geekbench score of ~1750.
The is 5x the power for a 8.5% of performance increase.
But I know there are many who just want to get the best ST performance regardless or power usage. And considering someone Overclock the thing past 8Ghz barrier. It is still pretty damn impressive.
- liuliu 5y agoSorry about my impulsive correction: It is Intel 7 (formerly known as Intel's 10nm process). There is also Intel 4 (formerly known as Intel's 7nm process).
- ksec 5y agoYes except I got asked again and again what is "Intel 7". So I am going to stick with a simple naming scheme that right now happens to be about the same across all three foundry working on leading node, Samsung, Intel and TSMC. And everyone can relate or understand.
- SahAssar 5y agoIf that is the case shouldn't you call it "Intel 10nm" since that is what it was called when Intel was still using the same units as everyone else (even if those units are becoming meaningless)? Not even Intel itself says that "Intel 7" means "7nm", right?
- SirMittens 5y agoEven if Intel was using "nm" like everyone else, Intel's naming was closer to reality then the rest of the industry. TSMC and Samsung's "nm" is more of a marketing term. Intel's 10nm is relatively close to TSMC's 7nm in term of density. That's why Intel renamed it to "Intel 7". Technically, even TSMC calls it N7, and not 7nm. But as you said, those units are more or less meaningless. Its just marketing.
- phire 5y agoIntel have a different process that used to documetned and marketed as 7nm. That process since has been renamed to Intel 4. Regardless of discussions about actual density and the meaningless, it's important to make the discussions between Intel 7 and 7nm (now Intel 4) to prevent confusion. Otherwise people might mistakenly think Alder Lake is on the process previously known as Intel 7nm. Fortunately, once we get to Intel 4, it becomes unambitious again.
- nly 5y agoImagine what Intel could accomplish on the TSMC node!
- marricks 5y agoOnly 2.5x the power usage? More seriously, there's always a few comments on threads like this claiming it's unfair to compare Intel to AMD or Apple because "they have a larger node size and are hamstrung by it." Which is Intel's choice, they were happy having a superior node all to themselves for decades and now it's a problem for them. I don't remember people saying AMD was just as good as Intel but was just on a worse node either, did it matter to anyone but AMD fanboys?
- ksec 5y agoYes. That is why I have been very explicit about node numbers and characteristics along with clock speed. Apple cant push to 5GHz without using another node and possibly some redesign. Intel using their own ultra low Power node or even TSMC 5nm low power node will not be able to reach 5Ghz either. And let people make their own judgement. Again this isn't for consumer review, just for those interested in tech and how it all fits together.
- gpderetta 5y agoFor those that do not care just about the faster CPUs on benchmark and tribal fights, and like instead to nerd out about architectures, it is still interesting to know whether Apple superiority is due the ARM architecture, the Apple microarchitecture improvements or TSMC process. It is likely a mix of all three and of course microarchitecture cant be easily disentangled from the process.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sroussey 5y agoThere are relatively large differences in performance between implementations of ARM X1, so yeah, there is more to it than microarchitecture.
- hnburnsy 5y agoI see this comparison all the time in articles about Intel, but until I can build a desktop with M1 Pro/Max, they are meaningless.
- ksec 5y agoThat is the difference between a consumer review and tech review. They may be meaningless to consumers, but they are meaningful for those of us only want to learn about tech. This it the same with Graviton 2 on Servers.
- dirkg 5y agothey are meaningless to oem's and manufacturers as well since they cant buy an M1 and build a system around it.
- oneplane 5y agoMost reviews are meaningless as a whole in the global context; most people can't afford any of the high performance parts of the electricity to power them anyway, and those that can now have the problem of shortages making it hard to get the parts at all. The only thing all of us get out of this is: context matters.
- oneplane 5y agoBummer, I made a typo. > parts of the electricity -> parts OR the electricity Quite the distinction there. I was referring to reviews in the global context where there are plenty of places on earth where even getting power is hard and you might be constrained to limited wattage or battery backups that drain very fast on high performance parts. All to build up an extra example context where there is no 'absolute' truth to some reviews out there.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> They may be meaningless to consumers, but they are meaningful for those of us only want to learn about tech. It's actually misleading to compare apples and oranges like this. CPU power efficiency is very non-linear. For example (made up numbers for example), it might require double the power to go from 3GHz to 4GHz and another doubling of power to go from 4GHz to 5GHz. If you're designing a low-power laptop chip, you take advantage of this fact and operate it at the lower frequencies. You may be able to cut the power consumption by 1/4 and still get 60-70% of the performance. If you're building a desktop for enthusiasts who are buying big liquid coolers, you go the other direction and push the CPU to the limit. That's what Intel did here. This factors in at the design stage, too. It's not as simple as taking the same design and scaling it up or down. You need to target your timings around a range of clock speeds and voltages. Drawing comparisons isn't as simple as dividing Geekbench scores by power consumption because the underlying math is very non-linear.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoThese biased sites will declare Intel the winner despite the higher cost in motherboard, CPU, power usage, cost to overclock, and heat creation. These tech sites are obviously nothing but product shilling sites with a cheap veneer that relies on their old reputation, but after seeing them all saying the opposite of reality with Ryzen, I won't give them clicks and I won't buy Intel again.
- nyxaiur 5y agolmao what?
- GhettoComputers 5y agoThese biased sites will declare Intel the winner despite the higher cost in motherboard, CPU, power usage, cost to overclock, and heat creation. These tech sites are obviously nothing but product shilling sites with a cheap veneer that relies on their old reputation, but after seeing them all saying the opposite of reality with Ryzen, I won't give them clicks and I won't buy Intel again.
- nyxaiur 5y agoOn pure performance metrics Intel will be the winner every cycle they bring one "enthusiast" CPU that tops the benchmark in gaming or creator CPU loads. they are expensive they are power hogs but they are the fastest. I don't get why you are so adjetated by it.
- GhettoComputers 5y ago>they are expensive they are power hogs but they are the fastest. That is absolutely false and a lie for multicore processes, real world usage, and programs that I use. This is an enormous lie, unless your workload only consists of synthetic benchmarks that are Intel optimized and ignore the gains from other hardware like premium DDR5 they use to set these sythetic benchmarks.
- vadfa 5y ago5x the power so you can run x86 32-bit and 64-bit code. I don't see the performance part as being that important
- threeseed 5y agoI run x86 code all the time on my M1 Mac. And surprisingly well given it's being transpiled.
- acomjean 5y agoApple ditched all the x86-32 code with Big Sur (one reason we can't upgrade at work..). So its a subset. They did the same with 32 bit iOS Apps. Apple is happy to leave old software behind.