3 ms·
Security is not everything there is to want from a messenger. Due to its centralized approach, Signal is having a problem with financing and I doubt it can be e
by fsflover 5y ago
Security is not everything there is to want from a messenger. Due to its centralized approach, Signal is having a problem with financing and I doubt it can be easily solved. It had a large downtime recently. Also, it becomes an easy target for all kinds of bad actors, since it's the single server. I trust it less for those reasons, even if it's "secure" by your standards. I just don't see it being secure long-term, not enough to suggest it to my friends or use myself.
People who truly need privacy in the short term, should consult a professional and not trust random comments from strangers.
- tptacek 5y agoI agree that security isn't everything there is to want from a messenger. But when the question being asked is "which messengers are secure", it is the only question that matters.
- fsflover 5y agoNo, there is also a question "how long can this messenger stay secure?" In case of Signal, IMHO, the answer is "not very long".
- tptacek 5y agoNone of what you've said to support that argument sounded persuasive to me. I think it's a pretty transparent rhetorical sleight of hand to say "the only way things can actually be secure in the long run is for them to be federated the way I want them to be". I get it, you want to run federated systems that you can build your own clients for. The evidence for those kinds of systems being the most private runs strongly in the opposite direction. Would you like an example that's especially relevant to this thread? Because I can provide you with one.
- fsflover 5y ago> "the only way things can actually be secure in the long run is for them to be federated the way I want them to be" I never mentioned any particular kind of federation that I prefer. I also never mentioned word "private", which is mostly tangential to federation. My point is that, in the long run, only federated systems are sustainable, because nobody is able to fund huge servers with millions of users without infinite money. For example, Signal and Telegram are both struggling with that currently; the latter introduced advertisement recently. On the other hand, Mastodon does not seem to have such problem (you could argue that it's too early though). I do not want to build my own clients, I'm not even a programmer. I want a sustainable network, which could be achieved by a large number of self-hosted instances federated with (possibly) large servers. It has been working fine with email for decades. Also, the competition of various independent clients improves the user experience (like any other healthy competition elsewhere).
- growse 5y agoDismissing a platform that's solving real problems for real people right now because it might not exist in 5 years is a pretty weird thing to do. "Sustainability" is arbitrary. Everything burns eventually.
- fsflover 5y agoThe problem is that such security is unstable due to unstable funding and the single target. You never know when it stops being secure (without a warning) or even available. I am mostly talking about a use case, where you try to switch all your friends and relatives to a new IM system. If you have to ask them to switch again in a couple of years, you will loose their trust quickly.
- tptacek 5y agoYou keep alluding to the "instability" of Signal's security, but your argument for that is a non sequitur. Repeating it doesn't make it more compelling.
- tptacek 5y ago