4 ms·
Five of the top six countries by total land area are: Russia, Canada, China, United States, Australia So it's not particularly impressive to bring up absolute
by zamadatix 5y ago
Five of the top six countries by total land area are:
Russia, Canada, China, United States, Australia
So it's not particularly impressive to bring up absolute forest coverage as a gotcha considering that's not the argument made in the article. Nor is wanting a country with 85% forest cover acting as a ~5x carbon sink to not develop its land or use its resources but pay a developed country which has already developed over its land and is acting as a carbon generator (such as the US at about ~5x carbon generator) simply because it is larger is a reasonable response from reading the article.
That being said I'm not sure I buy this is the best way to combat CO2 levels or the most realistic but not because of "face value" reasons rather the actual argument presented.
- uberman 5y agoWho cares about relative coverage when the notion is to compensate for CO2 captured? The largest forests capture the most CO2. Global CO2 levels fluctuate in sync with the seasons in the northern hemisphere. The 4 of the 6 countries with the largest forests are in the northern hemisphere. Europe and North America and Australia account for about 1/2 of all forested land. Where are the "rich countries" that are going to step forward to pay Russia and Canada for holding more than 1/4 of all trees?
- zamadatix 5y ago> Who cares about relative coverage when the notion is to compensate for CO2 captured? The notion isn't absolute CO2 captured it's net CO2. If country A generates 1000 units and captures 200 units while country B generates 20 units and captures 100 units then clearly country B isn't indebted to country A simply because A's captured unit count is higher A is indebted to B for having taken some of the pollution out (assuming A wishes for B to continue doing so rather than clear the forests and develop). You have to accept country B would be indebted to country A in the above scenario before you can get to questions like who is going to pay Russia and Canada as while they are large and have large absolute capture numbers they are even larger polluters.
- uberman 5y agoThe article says nothing substantial about net co2. It is entirely about rich countries paying poor ones for trees.