3 ms·
No.
by randomdata 5y ago
No.
- robertlagrant 5y agoThen I think you need to explain yourself better. Saying a 10s phrase that says I don't have anything to report would send everyone to sleep seems to imply that you don't think people should say that.
- randomdata 5y agoRegurgitating a, what is little more than gibberish, canned response when you have nothing to say is very different to speaking when you have something of value to say. That it only takes 10 seconds to utter that gibberish does not give it any more value. Assigning turns so that someone is forced to spit out that gibberish is nonsensical. Allowing someone the floor when they speak up when they have something to say is worthwhile, and something people do naturally. There is no need for an explicit turn where someone must say something.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> Same way humans have always figured it out? They say it. > Regurgitating a, what is little more than gibberish, canned response when you have nothing to say is very different to speaking when you have something of value to say. That it only takes 10 seconds to utter that gibberish does not give it any more value. I can't tell if there are two people on your account? Maybe you two should chat.
- randomdata 5y agoWhat you seem to not understand is that normal people don't speak up when they only have a canned response they were told to say, to say. They technically could, but usually they are smart enough to realize that it is stupid to do so and reserve the act for when they know they have something of value to contribute. If you are hiring stupid people, well, good luck. Someone uttering gibberish is likely the least of your worries, which no doubt explains why you haven't noticed the problem with it.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> What you seem to not understand is that normal people don't speak up when they only have a canned response they were told to say, to say. I never mentioned a canned response they were told to say. You've invented this.
- randomdata 5y agoYou didn't need to mention it. It was already baked into the discussion long before you ever replied. It is not like the subject would have magically changed beneath us. That you seem confused about the subject now is... strange.
- robertlagrant 5y agoIt wasn't baked into anything. I never said that. If you're inventing things, then I don't know what to tell you. Presumably you'll interpret anything I say in an arbitrary way, adding or subtracting to make what I say fit a stereotype.
- randomdata 5y agoSince the first comment, the thread has been about how "Yesterday I worked on X, today I will work on X" is pointless. That is the canned response. It is not something a thinking person would logically say on their own accord. It gets said because it is the answer to two of the three questions that the book on Scrum indicates should be asked in a standup. The third being the equally useless "Do you have any blockers?" Sure, you can say that in 10 seconds. More likely even less time. That doesn't mean you should. It provides nothing of value. Setting a specific turn aside so that someone has to say something useless is even crazier.
- robertlagrant 5y agoActually, most of the thread has been about whether or not you're saying people are allowed to indicate that they have no blockers. People don't say things because they're in a book. If you want to work as a team and quickly update your team on what you're doing, then leaving your day free to do or collaborate as needed, it's an efficient way to do it. You don't (seem to) say all this should not be communicated, nor that the team shouldn't be aware of it. You seem to only be concerned with the form of the communication; that it should be implied where possible, and where it must be explicit, should be done in point to point conversations throughout the day. That seems a) worse and b) bikeshedding.