4 ms·
Wait, who publishes this information, and why? Address/phone is somewhat standard phonebook stuff (or at least, used to be; less so now I guess) but job and sal
by arp242 5y ago
Wait, who publishes this information, and why? Address/phone is somewhat standard phonebook stuff (or at least, used to be; less so now I guess) but job and salary?!
- alisonkisk 5y agoAnd in the US the value of real property you own is public record! Do you think whatever your locality does is the obvious correct standard?
- Loughla 5y agoIn the US, in almost every publicly funded position, your job, salary and benefits are available for everyone to see. I am employed by a publicly funded institution now, and everything I earn is available for consumption, along with extra-duty pay, benefits, and historical data. Why would it be crazy for that to be available for everyone? I genuinely don't get what the big idea is.
- arp242 5y agoFor publicly funded positions salary is just a matter of transparent government. Address and phone? Probably not so much. However, the previous post talked about "everyone" and "company", not publicly funded positions.
- ghaff 5y agoIf you own a home in the US, your address is public record at least unless you take steps through shell companies etc. to hide it. And while it's less relevant with the decline of land lines, so was your phone number unless you paid to make it unlisted.
- kalleboo 5y agoIt could be argued that the basis of taxes paid are also a matter of transparent government
- ghaff 5y agoThe logic with the public sector is that "the people" are paying for it so it's their business where the money is going. I'm not personally much of a fan of private sector salaries, income tax paid, etc. being a matter of public record but it's also not obviously "crazy" either. There are reasonable debates about transparency at the margins and this is a margin.
- Loughla 5y agoI genuinely do not see a downside of publicly available salary information. What am I missing and/or not thinking about?
- ghaff 5y agoSo I make $50K more than you. And, in your opinion, you're a harder worker than me, are more valuable, etc. On the one hand, yes, that is perhaps fodder for you to have a conversation with your manager. On the other hand, it's also fodder to go home and grumble about how underappreciated you are because your coworker who doesn't do crap as far as you're concerned but makes a bunch more than you do. Not saying either approach is necessarily wrong. But it probably works better in public sector which tends to be very seniority based. In the US, it would breed a lot of resentment towards people who you thought were overpaid relative to yourself for many people.
- Loughla 5y agoI still don't see a downside. If I know I am a better employee than you, and you make that much more, if I am unwilling to do anything about it but grumble, that's a personal problem. I would argue that anyone who is willing to stay in a shit situation without trying to remedy said situation (being underpaid and knowing it for a fact) sort of brought those problems on themselves. It's a problem to complain about only if you have tried to fix it and couldn't. Systematically, it would allow people to see which businesses pay best, where their particular skills would be best reimbursed. Therefore, anyone in that shit situation who wants to grumble would have even more information available to them to be able to shop for jobs. I still don't see a downside.
- Hikikomori 5y agohttps://www.regeringen.se/4a76f3/contentassets/2c767a1ae4e8469fbfd0fc044998ab78/public-access-to-information-and-secrecy.pdf https://www.regeringen.se/4a76f3/contentassets/2c767a1ae4e84... This principle is why most of the information that our government has is public, but not everything is in a database accessible by anyone on the Internet, but some information is. If I want to know what a private person makes I can call Skatteverket and ask, but this info is not available on the Internet, though some companies provide services for this. If you have a registration number for a car you can get information about it using the link below, but owner info requires me to login with my bankid (online identity service that most government and banks, etc, use). I just did this and got an email with the owner and owner history within a few minutes. I did it for a Tesla that has BITCOIN as reg number that I've seen before, you can also try it. https://fu-regnr.transportstyrelsen.se/extweb/UppgifterAnnatFordon https://fu-regnr.transportstyrelsen.se/extweb/UppgifterAnnat...
- wingerlang 5y agoWhere is job and salary noted? I don't think it is, just taxes paid. At least that's what I understand ratsit has (never ACTUALLY looked at it though).
- ftrobro 5y agoIn paper: https://www.ratsit.se/ratsitkatalogen https://www.ratsit.se/ratsitkatalogen