12 ms·
Fasting Improves Physiological and Molecular Markers of Aging (2019)
- xcambar 5y agoI used to skip lunch for years and it always felt great. I like to see studies on fasting but I have to ask: how do you deal with the hunger when fasting with 24h? How does that affect your mood?
- alecst 5y agoEveryone’s different, but I can go a while without food and not have it bother me. It’s not uncommon to go a day without it and not really notice. I hear people talking about getting “hangry” but I don’t personally relate to the that feeling at all. I don’t even know what that’s like, or how common it is to feel that way. If anything, I just get tired.
- sul_tasto 5y agoI wonder if feeling hangry is correlated with blood sugar level crashes when eating carb-heavy meals.
- chousuke 5y agoI've noticed that I get worse hunger if I eat more often, especially if I just eat bread to postpone the hunger. For some reason, the hunger I feel when on a lower-carb diet is much less pressing, and can be easily ignored for quite a while. Carbs are also addictive to me: I sometimes notice that I want to eat even when I know I'm not hungry, so I have to make sure I don't make snacks too available. Most days, I just eat once because it's an easy rule to stick to. I might have a snack if I've taxed my brain and feel like I need the extra fuel, but usually one meal is plenty.
- JohnWhigham 5y agoIdeally you need an electrolyte mixture after the first day e.g. potassium/magnesium/sodium or else you start to feel like shit.
- chasil 5y agoI fast for 36 hours every week, from Sunday evening until Tuesday morning. To admit it, sometimes I'm overly tempted and I don't make it. It has kept my A1C levels very low. My normal blood sugar is in the 120-140 range, but always below 100 on Tuesdays. I have read elsewhere that fasting can pull A1C down by .5 easily, and that it also triggers a cellular process called "autophagy" that is very helpful.
- solarmist 5y agoI was worried about this too, but I’ve been alternate day fasting ADF (eat dinner at the normal time, go to bed and don’t eat the entire day, eat normally the following day) for two weeks now (and down nearly 6 lbs so far to 215lbs), and it hasn’t actually been a problem. I get a bit hungry by the end of the day, and sometimes I’ll have a protein shake to tide me over. But mostly I’m just looking forward to my meals the next day. And by the next morning I’ve started to become indifferent to food. I’ll have breakfast, but I don’t feel deprived, food seeking or anything. Also studies on ADF actually allow participants to eat 25% of their daily calories (or up to 500 Cal) and still be on diet. I’ve taken advantage of this once and had a single McD cheeseburger for dinner. So it was nice having the option as backup if I got really hungry.
- can16358p 5y agoIt makes me great if I don't feel eat anything until the evening. I am much more energized, less sleepy, and productive. If I eat through the day, especially if I do breakfast, I feel tired, sleepy, and hard to focus on anything good. Thus, I've never understood the classic "breakfast is important" argument that old ones day, as it has always been the opposite for me. I sometimes fast 24h and it feels awesome, I literally feel that I'm much more healthier both physically and mentally.
- least 5y agoThe sleepiness you feel is probably your body's response to large intake of carbohydrates and the subsequent spike in insulin. Increasing the amount of protein and fiber in your meals will decrease this feeling, as will exercising after your meal. Breakfast is important if you are going to be physically active during the day since it provides the fuel to sustain it. The reason it's become less important is because many of us are extremely sedentary.
- can16358p 5y agoYeah the sleepiness usually comes from carbs; if I take fibers/protein it feels better. Maybe anectodal but still, even if I'm physically active the whole day (unless I'm snowboarding with a tshirt 9-17) I really feel better off eating nothing. I feel the urge to eat after physical activity, but not before. If I eat (and I'm not planning to burn 2000+ active calories) I'm still better off on not having any breakfast but just water and perform MUCH better on physical/mental activities.
- blastro 5y agoIME - hunger and mood start to separate. Hunger fades away into a shadow of its former self. There is less energy to be joyous in a fasted state, but there is also less energy to be upset. I find a certain bliss in that.
- echelon 5y agoMechanistically, one could hypothesize "of course". Cellular respiration and its various reactions take in highly oxidative oxygen and turn it into ATP. The more we run this engine, the more work it does. Active pathways have some probability of breaking, especially those that generate reactive molecular species. Higher probability of eventual disease state. DNA damage, intracellular buildup, etc. The more you drive a car, the more wear and tear it receives. Over time, all of those explosions in the combustion chamber will do damage. So too, our cellular physiology and molecular biology.
- alecst 5y agoBy that reasoning exercise should age us faster.
- echelon 5y agoIn some ways it does! Exercise increases the presence of reactive species, which can negatively impact DNA and other molecules [1, 2]. We know exercise to be mostly beneficial, but you can't discount that it does damage too. It's just that the benefits exceedingly outweigh the downsides. Your body is going to die no matter what. Everything you do involves chemistry, and eventually entropy will win over your body's attempts to minimize it. There are behaviors that will optimize for longevity and health, though. [1] https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphys.2016.00249/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphys.2016.0024... [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11327321/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11327321/
- alecst 5y agoAnd just as exercise is more complex than just tearing your muscle fibers, fasting is more complex than just slowing your metabolic rate. You could make a similar (but wrong) “of course” argument that, while fasting, the body doesn’t have enough energy to repair itself, so it decays faster. All I’m getting at is that this is a really complicated topic, and that the benefits of fasting go beyond just temporarily lowering your metabolism.
- theNJR 5y agoI really urge people to do a multi-day fast a few times a year. I wrote a little guide about it that I shared previously [1]. You can wonder about these longterm positive effects, but it's sort of a Pascals wager. You lose absolutely nothing and it could have significant upside. Worst case, it makes you confront your relationship to food and offers a great mental challenge. One cool thing that you learn is that there is a maximum hungry you get. It doesn't ever go past that point (and you've felt it before without fasting). Even better, it ebbs and flows. You won't be in a state of "OMG I am starving!!" all day long. It hits at normal eating times, and then retreats to the background. Anyway, just try it. [1]https://www.nicholasjrobinson.com/blog/general/five-day-fasting-guide-freedom-from-food-people-and-technology https://www.nicholasjrobinson.com/blog/general/five-day-fast...
- solarmist 5y agoThe more studies pile up, the less it seems to matter the length of a given fast, but more the total time spent in a fasting state relative to a fed state. So as a taster, you can do multiple 24-hour fasts and get the same experience from a health point of view (everything else is different, though). That said, at some point, I’m interested in trying a multiple-day fast myself but haven’t taken the plunge yet.
- tejohnso 5y ago> The more studies pile up, the less it seems to matter the length of a given fast, but more the total time spent in a fasting state relative to a fed state. Yes, I've noticed this as well. Personally I fast for 17 hours every day and I've noticed I feel the benefits without negative consequences. Once in a while I'll go for a 3 day fast but aside from the personal challenge accomplishment I don't notice a major gain. My experience is all very non scientific. For the more rigorous science, I usually look to Peter Attia[1] [1]: https://peterattiamd.com/ https://peterattiamd.com/
- srik 5y ago> you can do multiple 24-hour fasts and get the same experience from a health point of view NO, that's incorrect. The length matters a lot. In fact, a major change occurs after the 2-3 day mark, when body glycogen stores are depleted and your body shifts to ketosis etc. Another major marker has to do with when a much coveted state called autophagy is activated.
- jniedrauer 5y agoWhen I see studies like this, I always wonder if you might get the exact same benefits and more by just going for a run. When I run for more than 90 minutes without taking in carbs, my body goes into a ketogenic state very similar to a multi-day fast. And exercise has additional benefits that simply fasting doesn't.
- solarmist 5y agoKinda, but only indirectly as I understand it. The more I read the more it seems to matter the time spent in a fasting state relative to a fed state. So a run could work if you’re not overeating, but if you’re regularly overeating it wouldn’t work because you might use up your food, but then immediately resupply or have eaten too much prior to it and it takes hours to finish nutrient delivery. Mostly though they’re complimentary processes neither directly involved with the other.
- xriddle 5y agoThe latest science in Rats says no. I don't have the exact article available but it's discussed at length in this podcast recently. https://www.foundmyfitness.com/episodes/mark-mattson https://www.foundmyfitness.com/episodes/mark-mattson
- solarmist 5y agoAs I’ve said in other comments what seems to matter is the ratio of time spent in a fed state (body delivering nurtrients) vs a fasting state (body using fat for energy, depleting stores of things and doing housekeeping). From that perspetive running could help, but only from the point of view of possibly getting you to the fasting state more quickly (a kind of kickstarter), but it would be easy too derail that by eating to soon or a hundred other things.
- runT1ME 5y agoI don't have time (nor the endurance) for a 90 minute run, so could you combine the two? I often do a 14 hour fast and then go for a 20 minute run combined with some calisthenics on my lunchbreak before eating. How can you tell your body is in a ketogenic state? I can definitely say the first few times I exerted a ton of energy after not eating for 12+ hours I felt like I had the flu for a few hours, but now I don't really get that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ar4420 5y agoI'm a huge proponent of intermittent fasting. After being skeptical at first, I felt I had more energy and was being more mindful about the type of foods I ate. The mindfulness alone may have been the catalyst, but even so, I'll chalk that up as a win. In case it helps anyone else, I signed up for the Intermittent Fasting guide at www.howtostartfasting.com for the accountability and guidance and thought that was definitely one of the reasons I was able to stick to it and see the benefits. It's designed for folks who are shift workers and have a changing schedule, but obviously still works and is easier if you have a regular schedule.
- solarmist 5y agoSame here. I’ve done both traditional calorie restriction with exercise and now alternate day fasting ADF. And I was extremely skeptical to begin with especially from an athletic point of view. But now I’ll say ADF wins hands down for its simiplty and effectiveness. It’s 10% of the work/effort and 90% of the benefits.
- xriddle 5y agoRecent podcast that goes in-depth on this subject: https://www.foundmyfitness.com/episodes/mark-mattson https://www.foundmyfitness.com/episodes/mark-mattson
- hourislate 5y agoMy experience with AF was different. After years of doing all kinds of Fasts (2-12 day, dry fasts, OMAD, 16-8 etc), I experimented with AF. For approximately 3-4 months I did AF with a 1800 Kcal refeed (1 meal). What I experienced was a lot of muscle loss and a messed up metabolism, always starving and feeling like complete shit. It took me about 8 months to fix. What I surmised is that with AF you don't enter a true fasted state but a gray zone, so it's more like starvation than fasting where a multi day fast (48 hours or more) seems to get you into a state that is muscle sparing.
- tibbar 5y agoA few years ago I realized that eating made me feel bad, or just took a long time to digest. So I started skipping breakfast. A year ago I cut out dinner too, so I just eat once a day - usually late afternoon, and usually a large meal, probably close to two normal meals. Overall I think it's a better lifestyle, but I do feel more tired than I used to.
- chrisbrandow 5y agoThis was true for me, but not really until I turned ~45. Confounding factors do include some changes to my consistency with working out due to some feet issues I started experiencing, but I just felt "full" all the time as well as foggy. I do ~16-18 fasted most days and feel much clearer/better.
- patall 5y agoPeople in the control group of this study start with an average BMI of 25.2, the ADF groups with 25.48. Common BMI ranges classify scores greater 25 as overweight. Are there any studies of effect of fasting on normal weight people? Anyone here with a BMI of 20 that has experiences to share?
- tibbar 5y agoMy BMI is 21.0 (6'3", 168lb), and I've done OMAD (one meal a day) intermittent fasting for about a year. Mostly I did it for digestion, which has improved significantly. I would say that it's also helped to control my weight, which would bump up about 10lb otherwise. Effects on energy/focus are mixed: there's less of a mid-day slump, but also I think overall energy levels have been somewhat lower.
- leetrout 5y agoWhats your waist to height ratio at that weight if you dont mind sharing. I am 6'3 300lb and .61 W:H and want to get down to .5
- patall 5y agoThanks for the insight. Losing 10 lb sounds actually like a negative to me since I don't aspire to have a BMI of 18. But I would like to test it for the energy level. Well, maybe I should try it a few Saturdays.
- solarmist 5y agoThey’re starting to study the effect in normal BMI people. But the takeaway I’ve had is that it should have similar benefits as long as you avoid going into ketosis (which is admittedly more difficult the further below BMI 20 you are). https://nutritionj.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1475-2891-12-146?__hstc=133243537.3f89949c75cda0bb2ae1552d2dda8458.1482969600064.1482969600065.1482969600066.1&__hssc=133243537.1.1482969600067&__hsfp=528229161 https://nutritionj.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1475-2...
- iosono88 5y agoWhat are the climate implications of global fasting?
- aerodog 5y agoAnother ancient wisdom rediscovered in modernity
- mrfusion 5y agoI’ve researched all over and no one seems to know. I think autophagy isn’t well understood yet: Does black coffee during a fast break autophagy? Flavored seltzer, tea? Are vitamins ok during a fast? Fish oil?
- rhinoceraptor 5y agoI don't think autophagy is a binary state. It fluctuates over the day, and increases when fasting. Many vitamins are fat soluble so taking them while fasting is pointless.
- jobigoud 5y agoI think no one knows because the exact threshold is different from person to person. I've seen it suggested (in relation to 16:8 or 18:6) to do water only for a while and then test each stuff independently to see what triggers a hunger pang half an hour later.
- amznbyebyebye 5y agoShhh why are they telling everyone about my secret weapon. I am so sharp when I’m fasted.. easily become a force multiplier. Maybe a little more agro. Also, I burn ~2000kcal without doing anything new? When a heavy workout burns what 500-1000 kcal. I don’t need to sleep as much either. I wish I had learned more about the connection between my diet, biology, etc and my productivity when I was younger. And yes, I’ve started to look younger too. Can’t wait to see the research evolve in this area.
- ChrisArchitect 5y agoAnything new here? Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20812636 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20812636
- headelf 5y agoIt's funny to me that the article doesn't mention the word "muscle" anywhere. It seems a diet like this would reduce muscle mass, which may be a large contributor to the decline in body weight mentioned in the study.
- xutopia 5y agoLots of evidence shows that if you fast you lose fat before you lose muscle. One exception to this is if you have a low caloric intake mostly from carbohydrates. I am not a doctor but what I understood was that when you eat carbs it puts your body in a mode of storing it as fat but if you remove the carbs it tells the body to pull from fat stores.
- Zababa 5y ago> I am not a doctor but what I understood was that when you eat carbs it puts your body in a mode of storing it as fat but if you remove the carbs it tells the body to pull from fat stores. Not a doctor too, but from what I've read it's due to insulin. Carbs usually raise insulin, proteins can raise it too.
- solarmist 5y agoIt's not that simple unfortunately. Basically, as I understand it, your body(liver) puts out a call for energy and whatever happens to pick up the signal first will respond. In the same way you can't spot reduce fat (can't choose where you want to lost fat from). So this means, unfortunately, you will lose muscle while losing fat. Fortunately it is significantly more difficult to extract protein from muscle, so it responds much more slowly than fat. The minimum seems to be about 40 g (~150 Cal) of protein per day (I don't remember where I got this number, sorry.), but can be as high as 10-30% of Calories supplied by the body. There are a lot of things you can do to counter and minimize most this though. Working out to signal to your body the muscle mass is still in use and protein shakes (no fat, no carbs) are the most obvious.
- rhinoceraptor 5y agoWithout diving too deep into a naturalistic fallacy, it would be a terrible design if the body started tearing down its muscle immediately upon fasting, when it has months of energy in the form of body fat.
- adamqureshi 5y agoI have history of diabetes in my family ( south asian) I took the 23andME test and the report said i have a pre-disposition to diabetes at around age 50. I am 50 now. I have been working out running most of my life but started doin less miles and i packed on a few pounds maybe i was like 188-192 and i am 5' 11" About 2 years ago i was diagnosed with pre-diabetes the doctor said you need to get you A1-C down. I was like i have been working out all my life and now this! ok so i started looking into IF ( found some good videos by Dr Jason Fung) so i tried it and started not having breakfast ( I was eating a chocolate croissant from trader joes typically) i went black coffee. Giving up breakfast was damn hard after 6 months i got used to it so the next jump was giving up lunch i got hunger pangs and it was very very painful NOT to eat lunch but to my surprise i got used to NOT eating lunch and fast forward 2 years today i fast all day and my first meal is 5pm and usually a big salad and i feel fantastic all the hunger pangs are gone now i don't know how to explain it but water is sweeter and even black coffee taste sweet to me i am down to like 170 now and have an unusual mental clarity from NOT eating i know it sounds funny but i just do. Headaches go away. IF worked for me and i tell all my friends to at least try it and if you don't feel better than stop. SO I eat around 5pm and last meal and maybe a snack around 9pm. I don't eat after 9pm until the next day 5pm. Next goal is to try a 48 hour fast wish me luck. I feel f-in fantastic! -2cents.
- solarmist 5y ago> Water is sweeter. This is something I've started noticing with IF too. Depending on where I am with my fast a glass of water can come across as very sweet, cloyingly. But not sweet like glucose/fructose (sugar). More like an impression of sweet or maybe like a diet soda. I hate when it happens because I don't like the flavor at all and need to force myself to finish my water at that point. For some reason it usually happens at the end of the day for me. It's usually gone by morning. And it can't be something in the water because I switched to reverse osmosis RO filtered water like a year ago because I'm quite sensitive to flavors in water.
- blastro 5y agoHaving a remote job was what initially helped me get over the breakfast and lunch humps you mention in this well written post. I'm not sure I would have gotten to my current IF stasis if not enabled by that. Thanks for taking the time to write this post.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoAfter trying partial fasting periodically for years, I hit in something earlier this year that works for me: eat only two periods each day, from 8am to 9am and from about 4pm to 5:30pm. This supposedly has two benefits: 1) by not eating for about five hours before going to bed I get much more deep sleep which starts soon after I fall asleep 2) avoids snacking between meals which is hard in the digestive system. I started a full time job last month and with a more busy schedule I have temporarily stopped this eating schedule but plan on getting back to it. A device like the Apple Watch can let you know when you are in deep sleep and the positive effect on sleep with this two big enjoyable meals a day plan are verified, at least for me.