6 ms·
The HP Way: Dave Packard on How to Operate a Company (2016)
- rubyn00bie 5y agoWell… the real irony here is HP embodies zero of what this article talks about. It’s honestly hilarious to me, that Packard ever said any of this considering how absolutely shit HP is in my opinion. The bit about embracing this for the gateway merger shows how out of touch modern management is with reality. The only thing I’d really glean from this is that Packard and Hewlett were totally shit at establishing a good culture that can last the test of time.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoHewlett & Packard left the board in 1992. Until then, HP (mostly) had an excellent reputation both for its products and its working environment. Quite a few HP products - like its programmable pocket calculators, and some of the test equipment - were legendary for their engineering. HP Inc is a completely different outfit and seems to have none of the original spirit left. Whether it's even possible to create a broadly positive company culture that can survive contact with modern MBAs and investors is debatable.
- Tempest1981 5y ago> modern MBAs I wonder what the reaction is in MBA school when this topic comes up? Does the teacher say it's not applicable in today's world? It's obviously shunned by most. Can any of these ideas still work in 2021?
- parsimo2010 5y agoMost schools teach about successful leaders and companies like HP as case studies on how to do it right. But most schools have pretty low graduation standards and most MBAs end up misapplying the lessons they were taught. So their reaction would be positive, like "HP was such a good company! I love all of their business principles and I'd love to build a corporation known for good engineering, sound financial management, and promoting technically competent leaders." And then most promptly do none of that, focus on short term returns, and run a company into the ground.
- ghaff 5y agoMBA programs are also about more than business strategy, leadership, etc. In fact that's a fairly small part of an MBA program--at least as an explicit topic of study. Depending upon what people are concentrating on, there's also financial accounting, cost accounting, market research, forecasting, organizational behavior, pricing, economics, operations/operations research--to pick a few courses in a typical program off the top of my head. In general, my impression is there's also more focus on "experiential" learning than both case study and non-case study lecture.
- samstave 5y ago>>>Most schools teach about successful leaders and companies like HP as case studies on how to do it right. But most schools have pretty low graduation standards and most MBAs end up misapplying the lessons they were taught. Probably the most succinct setup for the MBA hate I have ever read. Classic.
- rrss 5y ago> It’s honestly hilarious to me, that Packard ever said any of this considering how absolutely shit HP is in my opinion. Are you talking about your opinion of the company “HP Inc” today? IMO it is not surprising that companies change a lot in 60 years (or 40). P.S. the original HP is now Keysight, they are still premier for test & measurement equipment.
- Tomte 5y agoThere is no one "original HP" anymore. It was picked apart into many different parts. For example, HP Medical was also highly regarded, then went with Agilent and was later sold to Philips.
- rrss 5y agoin my mind, keysight is the original HP in the sense that Hewlett and Packard started an electronics test & measurement company, and AFAIK keysight is the only electronics test & measurement company descended from HP. also, all the archives of the company for the first several decades went with keysight. I think HP probably didn’t start doing medical stuff until a few decades after its founding. but I agree hp was split into a lot of companies, with a lot of good parts scattered widely (except AFAICT no good parts scattered into “HP Inc”)
- gshubert17 5y agoFor the past couple of decades or so, you're right. HP was founded in 1939. In its first couple of decades the HP way described management practices that were unusual for their time. Bill and Dave were still visiting the varied HP divisions in the late 1970s (when I went to work for HP in Colorado). Hewlett was succeeded by John Young as CEO in 1978. Both Hewlett and Packard left the board of directors in 1993. It certainly is a very tough job to establish a good culture that can last the test of time. Compared to many other founders, though, I personally don't think they did that badly, though of course many others disagree. While HP itself lost its way in the 1990s, many of these ideals were adopted by other companies or taken to new companies by HP employees.
- adrian_b 5y agoAs many others have already said, there is a huge difference between the original Hewlett-Packard company and the companies that still have today a "HP" in their name. I am an electronics engineer. I have learned much more electronics from the manuals of some Hewlett-Packard products than from most University courses. Besides their excellent product manuals, which explained everything needed to understand how their products operated and how they can be repaired or modified, the company also published "HP Journal", which explained in great detail why and how their more important products were designed. The kind of documentation that HP produced was invaluable training for generations of engineers. Looking at the garbage documentation generated now by almost everybody for their products, it seems almost unbelievable that such companies like the old HP ever existed.
- AnonC 5y agoEstablishing and retaining a culture over several decades is not easy, especially in publicly listed companies where CEOs and board members get replaced every few years or every decade, each bringing baggage from where they were before. The HP Way was still popular and well known/followed even during the waning years of Carly Fiorina and for sometime after her departure. I don’t understand why this would be a failure of the founders long after they moved out. Look at Google, which went as far as dethroning the “don’t be evil” mantra in its early teens. HP has probably kept its culture for several multiples of that before it was drowned out.
- ghaff 5y agoIt's complicated. The business climate changes. As you say, CEOs change and HP arguably went through particular tumult in that regard with a generally lackluster Platt and then all the Fiorina-associated drama. (Who lugged "the garage" around from stage to stage but didn't really walk the walk as much as talked the talk.) Times change in other ways as well. It's hard to compare how major computer companies operated and what the expectations were of employees in the 70s/80s compared to today. I expect if you average mid-level Google engineer were dropped into HP, IBM, Intel, or DEC ~1980, they'd probably find a lot to not like.
- dang 5y ago"Please don't fulminate." "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mgerdts 5y agoA chance lunchtime discussion with Packard helped set the direction of Moderna co-founder Noubar Afeyan's focus on making instruments(?) for the biotechnology industry. During this lunch, Afeyan learned that Packard started in the electronics industry at such an early time that the best opportunities were in inventing and building the tools (like the oscilloscope) that would be needed in the field. https://www.npr.org/2021/10/08/1044644976/moderna-and-flagship-pioneering-noubar-afeyan https://www.npr.org/2021/10/08/1044644976/moderna-and-flagsh...
- sizzzzlerz 5y agoI started my EE career in the bay area in 1978. Before retiring in September, I had worked for 3 companies. Each one modeled itself in the HP style. The culture of each made life at work tolerable if not actually pleasant. All 3 were very successful as businesses. Management in each was competent, cared about their employee, and cared (very much) about our customers. In my 3rd company, we were purchased by a large, multibillion dollar company who most definitely did not continue in our previous mode of operation and made going into work a whole lot less desireable. It was one of the reasons I decided to leave. In my opinion, HP was successful because of the HP way.
- cogman10 5y agoI worked at HP circa 2010ish and yeah, HP was initially successful because of the HP way. It was sunk because of standard corporate practices. They've not had a CEO since the founder that has rediscovered the HP way. It's funny because HP has become exactly the company Dave Packard said they didn't want to become. > In other words when we discuss supervision and management we are not talking about a military type organization where the man at the top issues an order and it is passed on down the line until the man at the bottom does as he is told without question (or reason). That is precisely the type of organization we do not want.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- samstave 5y agoI have had the best experience with HOP of late: I bought an Omen 15" laptop - and after a few months a USB port stopped working - I created a ticket and they sent me a new replacement that was better than the one I bought - it took longer to get shipped to me, so in the mean-time, HP sent me a loaner machine until the new one shipped directly to me from China. The new machine is great! and it was upgraded to an RTX 3070 and a terabyte ssd (from a 500gb) -- and it still had the second SSD slot - so I moved my storage drive into this machine. The support from HP was superb - and reminded me of days of yore when an HP tech would show up same day to fix a downed machine...
- Tijdreiziger 5y ago> The support from HP was superb - and reminded me of days of yore when an HP tech would show up same day to fix a downed machine... You can get that service today from either HP, Dell or Lenovo - if you're willing to pay for it...
- samstave 5y agoYes, but this was free (included in my warranty) and for some reason I was setup with "Executive Level Support" on a consumer laptop I bought at freaking WALMART! I am now typing this on my shiny new Omen 15" that is a bad-ass machine (aside from the actual chassis, which is too plastic for my taste... but the guts are beautifully designed. Ill take some pics. and the support was absolutely wonderful.
- eitland 5y agoAround here and somewhere around 2008 I had HP come out next business day (which around here in practice always means not next day but the next after that) to fix the screen on my personal nc6320. I paid nothing except the original purchase price of the machine. Around the same time some friends of me had problems with a "family type" HP PC and it took a few months - before they got someone elses machine with someone elses photos and documents on it back. The lesson learned from talking to them on the phone was that business equipment and home equipment were served by to different departments, and the difference was not who owned it but what class of equipment it was. I haven't worked that close to hardware lately and my latest Dell and Lenovo laptops have worked well enough that I haven't really had an opportunity to test what it looks like today ( although that might be about to change since my latest Lenovo has activated "Microsoft Bake my Laptop" 4 times during the last month or so).
- dang 5y agoI expected to find lots of past threads on this, but couldn't. Others? The HP Way: How Bill Hewlett and I Built Our Company (1960) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20666371 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20666371 - Aug 2019 (20 comments) Is the HP Way still relevant today? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17581713 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17581713 - July 2018 (32 comments) Quotes From Bill Hewlett and David Packard - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2969816 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2969816 - Sept 2011 (12 comments) A little more loosely related The HP Garage (2009) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24982418 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24982418 - Nov 2020 (19 comments) Lucile Packard – Partner in Greatness - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16257332 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16257332 - Jan 2018 (3 comments) 12 Year Old Steve Jobs Meets Bill Hewlett (of HP) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2966132 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2966132 - Sept 2011 (2 comments) Losing the HP Way - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2905468 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2905468 - Aug 2011 (3 comments) Bill Hewlett & Dave Packard (HP) - Early Years - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13278 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13278 - April 2007 (1 comment)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- samstave 5y agoI was the technology implementation manager for the El Camino hospital new tower, built a few years ago, which was touted as the 'hospital of the future' The top floor was dedicated to LPCH (Lucele Packard's Childrens Hospital) Upon turn over of the top floor to LPCH, I took their then-director on a tour of her new facilities. As I walked her about, I asked exactly what LPCH was dedicated to helping, specifically in children... She told me something that amazed and shocked me at the same time. --- LPCH at ECH is a floor dedicated to (typically) female children of super wealthy power couples; the children often develop eating disorders - usually anorexia and their are literally starving themselves in order to gain attention from their high-net-parents... So... they have an entire hospital in Silicon Valley to treat the children for eating disorders that come from the lack of attention their high-power-couple-parent's give them. So take that in for a second: SIlicon Valley has an entire hospital dedicated to treating the eating disorders of super wealthy tech people in the bay area at the most technologically advanced hospital at the time that it was built... I was also on the design team of SFGH (San Francisco General Hospital) new tower.... Which Zuck paid to have named after himself... Lets find out if Zucks kids wind up in LPCH El Camino...
- scrubs 5y agoGood, good read. In contrast to persons I've run into over a long career in which money is seen as the measurement of all things, the HP is more nuanced, more integrated, more complex. And I think that's why it's more real. It reminds me of the 80-90s emphasis on total quality management and a broader emphasis on what companies ought to be doing.
- pm215 5y agoIf you're interested in reading the full text of the speech that this blog is commenting on, gzimodo seems to have a copy of it: https://gizmodo.com/the-hp-way-how-bill-hewlett-and-i-built-our-company-5634378 https://gizmodo.com/the-hp-way-how-bill-hewlett-and-i-built-...
- rramadass 5y agoMust read by everybody, well worth the time. I link to this everywhere and am quite surprised that the OP did not link to this in his blog post !
- fuzzfactor 5y agoKeep in mind the HP Way was well established for decades before this was documented, by Hewlett & Packard setting a strong personal example and proving it in practice as it radiated outward through their inner circle.