4 ms·
I'm of two minds when it comes to reports like this. On the one hand, of course I love that people have the means to audit assumptions. Both the ability to do
by dijit 5y ago
I'm of two minds when it comes to reports like this.
On the one hand, of course I love that people have the means to audit assumptions.
Both the ability to do so w.r.t the project being transparent and open, but also through time and technical ability.
I am, however, a little upset when people poke at minor issues (that they themselves see as minor) and speak at length about them. *not* because those issues should not be addressed, but because it gives ammunition for people who recommend closed platforms, or more opportunity for people to think of the community as being more divided than it really is.
The more uncertainty a thing is surrounded by: the more people are likely to just say "fuck it" and choose any option as long as it works, and guess what works? Closed platforms, especially those with coherent messaging like facebook or whatsapp.
So, with that in mind: Kudos for such an analysis, but be mindful that such a lengthy document that discusses minor issues can actually harm the matrix project.
- rglullis 5y agoI know it is going to sound like an ad-hominem, but once I realized that this is from the same person behind the "Grid protocol", I immediately closed the tab. This guy seems to be on a quixotic vendetta against msxid. It is the third or fourth persona (first it was from a personal account, then from his company, now he has even a non-profit advocating for privacy) that he created to re-hash the same old, outdated and irrelevant argument. And the pathetic thing is, if he had spent more time working on his "Grid protocol" instead of pointless nitpicking, maybe he would have a lot more credibility on the matter.
- vorejdajo 5y agoIt is ad-hominem and bias
- junon 5y agoAd hom would be saying the author smells like moldy cheese and therefore we should disregard his opinion. The parent comment is not using ad hom. They're critiquing the author's work and assessing their credibility based off of that. It's perfectly fine, and a great viewpoint to consider.
- colordrops 5y agoIs pointing out conflict of interest and hominem?
- spurgu 5y agoI don't get this kind of thinking? How does the why of what he's saying influence the what? Or even worse, disqualify it? If it's factually correct then the reason behind writing it seems quite irrelevant, to me at least. And you're mentioning it's outdated, which would be natural given that the last commit was over two years ago.
- rglullis 5y agoIt was outdated two years ago already, people already back then assuming good intent and pointed out that the "issues" he complained about were being worked on, yet he adamantly continued to ignore it and claim that everyone using Matrix was being duped and that his implementation of the id server was the only way to go. That is why.
- spurgu 5y agoOh ok, I stand corrected. Wasn't clear to me from your original post, but it actually makes sense now that I re-read it.
- eximius 5y agoIt doesn't, but you can spend less effort engaging with someone acting in bad faith.
- capableweb 5y ago> So, with that in mind: Kudos for such an analysis, but be mindful that such a lengthy document that discusses minor issues can actually harm the matrix project. Under "Purpose and Scope": > This document is a research paper by Libre Monde ASBL, nonprofit dedicated to protecting people's privacy. We had the need to document privacy points for The Grid Protocol project, fork of the Matrix protocol. So seems that they probably won't have issues with that it might harm Matrix, as they are a direct competitor. In fact, that might be why they are focusing on the issues they find, minors one included.
- southerntofu 5y ago> So seems that they probably won't have issues with that it might harm Matrix, as they are a direct competitor. I was not aware of the Grid project, but they seem to make good points. Matrix is developed by a restricted group of people with a startup vibe and some cringy/questionable actions: - spitting on other protocols (or not even acknowledging their existence) without a technical reasoning (Matrix could have been a "simple" decentralized room extension of XMPP or any other established protocol) ; which takes us to the situation where Matrix has the exact same selling points which XMPP had 20 years ago... and keeps on reinventing the wheel - pushing for a broken state resolution algorithm (decentralized consensus) without a formal analysis, which means it's now reached its 5th or 6th version and Matrix clients are all incompatible with one another (because only Element implements them all) and once they have been upgraded rooms cannot be downgraded so in many places only Element can chat - requiring a web rendering engine for certain extensions (eg. Video chat) ; HTTP is a decent foundation for a protocol, but why is a Jitsi <iframe> considered a decent extension mechanism? it will just harm security/privacy (through potential XSS) and make it near-impossible for clients to be implemented without a Chrome-based engine, reinforcing Google's monopoly on the web - putting all of their $$$$ into a single web client with very bad performance, not caring for other platforms; beyond clients, investing in bridging with useless platforms like Microsoft Teams (though i did not find the code for that) while neglecting interop with open protocols like IRC/XMPP (relations with IRC/XMPP people are notoriously not very good though i hope it will improve over time) All in all, i'm very glad matrix exists because they have popularized bridging and they do care for UX concerns like Spaces. But claiming people who forked the project because of political and technical disagreements are biased because they are a "competitor" is itself a very biased position based on the idea that only one true protocol must remain and others are heretics trying to undermine our technical purity (for their economic gain). I wish we could have people from different protocols sitting across the table and working on interop so we can stop arguing about which network is best.