3 ms·
Thanks. I think framing the question that way distracts us from the facts, at least for my purposes (but I want to say, it's a pleasure and very interesting to
by wolverine876 5y ago
Thanks. I think framing the question that way distracts us from the facts, at least for my purposes (but I want to say, it's a pleasure and very interesting to talk to someone who has similar level of interest in and has a fundamental understanding of international relations):
The US (and UK) could play significant or necessary roles, without playing the leading or primary roles. And of course defining primary role is complicated: Is it influence? Power? If person A bribes a head of state to enact a certain policy, who has the primary role? The head of state does most of the work and has most of the power, but the briber was most necessary to it. And it would never happen if other parties and circumstances didn't allow it. Back to Iran: Of course there were forces opposing Mosaddeq that the US/UK backed: There are always other forces, though of varying influence, and how else would the US/UK do it? They weren't going to invade with their own troops. Only a complete moron (or George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, and Don Rumsfeld, with help from Tony Blair) would topple a national power structure without another power structure to replace it.
Also, having read a lot of foreign policy, I would say that few Americans know the narrative of overthrowing Mosaddeq, and fewer believe it. I'd guess almost the entire right wing of the political spectrum disbelieves it, as do most centrists.
Which isn't to say I know the real story. I imagine there is a lot of nuance, and framing it around the amount of influence the US/UK had compared to the clerical parties seems misguided - it's not a competition, and it gets us into matters of definition (as discussed above). Perhaps my feelings would be different if I was Iranian. I do get that Western foreign policy tended to objectify everyone else.
-------
I read those Foreign Affairs articles at the time (there were several, about Iran, Chile, Congo/Zaire, and I think elsewhere). My memory: While they were valuable for their perspective and arguments, some were quite improbable. IIRC Zaire and Chile claimed ignorance of what was happening and naivete about the intentions of the dictators. I don't recall what I thought of the Iran article.