4 ms·
The idea of end-to-end encrypted email is ridiculous (and ProtonMail's business model is effectively built on a marketing lie/false advertising), but come on:
by woodruffw 5y ago
The idea of end-to-end encrypted email is ridiculous (and ProtonMail's business model is effectively built on a marketing lie/false advertising), but come on:
> Protonmail has an Onion domain that allows users to visit their site using the TOR browser. Protonmail even has an SSL cert for that onion address even though it’s completely unnecessary. When a user makes a new account with Protonmail on TOR they are re-directed from Protonmail’s “.onion” to “.com” address. This breaks your secure encrypted connection to their onion address, enabling your identification. There are absolutely no technical reasons for this feature. In fact, the only other websites that operate like this are suspected NSA/CIA Honeypots.
Why in the world are you trusting them to host your email if your threat model doesn't include connecting to them over HTTPS? Your endpoint is still a globally identifiable email address that you're going to use their webmail UI to view. What privacy, exactly, is TOR providing in this use pattern?
- woodruffw 5y agoI should have read further, because there's this kicker: > Leaked documents at Wikileaks show that the CIA requires emails to be stored as an EML filetype. There are several ways to store emails, and Protonmail has selected the format that the CIA requires. Everybody uses the EML format! It's a raw dump of the RFC 822 message[1] that the protocol itself uses! [1]: https://www.loc.gov/preservation/digital/formats/fdd/fdd000388.shtml https://www.loc.gov/preservation/digital/formats/fdd/fdd0003...
- nimbius 5y agothe rest of the articles seem to have a rather sophmoric feel to them as well...perhaps someone is just beginning their journey into infosec? The author rails against Cloudflare originated SSH traffic assuming its immediately malicious, and decrying how carriers are ignoring his legitimate calls for their blacklist as well.
- willis936 5y agoIt's truly an absurd statement. There aren't even straws to grasp, it's just air. "Can you believe they're storing text files using ASCII? It's exactly what the CIA wants you to do!"
- davidjytang 5y agoObviously all EML-using corps are working under CIA oversight.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- catlikesshrimp 5y agoE2E encryption through a third party is not impossible if you use an out of band encryption key. Only the message body is encrypted E2E. The header isn't. I would still use Proton over gmail, because I don't want google to have ALL of my data. The article points 8 and 9 are ridiculous. Take away message from the article: if the USA, or the EU, is your enemy, you shouldn't use proton, or gmail, or any 3rd party email provider. If you live in a Russian backed dictatorship, proton is OK; you should be more worried about your hardware and your meatspace.
- nirui 5y agoWhile I agreed that ProtonMail is not completely truthful about their claims on encryption, they are one of the few vendors out there who don't completely block user registration when the user is using TOR. That means a ProtonMail account can be created completely anonymously. I call that an advantage over some other options if you want to create secondary/throwaway accounts (for example, you want to register a small forum and you don't truth their admin). I personally won't recommend ProtonMail as someones main email service. If I want to send anything secretive such as sharing a password, code etc, I'd rather send GPG encrypted email via Gmail.
- blendergeek 5y ago> The idea of end-to-end encrypted email is ridiculous How exactly is it ridiculous? I understand that email leaks metadata like a sieve, but the contents of emails can still be secured via encryption. > (and ProtonMail's business model is effectively built on a marketing lie/false advertising), No arguments here. They provide a web app to encrypt your emails, making the user trust the server for "end-to-end" encryption, this rendering it useless.