3 ms·
To be clear, I wasn't criticizing your suggestion; I appreciate it. I was just going off on a tangent. Back on that tangent: > have a decent enough mental mode
by wolverine876 5y ago
To be clear, I wasn't criticizing your suggestion; I appreciate it. I was just going off on a tangent. Back on that tangent:
> have a decent enough mental model and vernacular to know how to ask the right questions
I think people greatly overestimate themselves. A lack of expertise can result in very confused mental models and the wrong questions. IME in domains in which I have expertise, places like Reddit are filled with people with the wrong models, asking the wrong questions, and others answering based on the same wrong models. In their echo chamber, it looks right. Not different, I suspect, from any non-scientific theories, such as those before modern science.
My understanding of nutrition isn't much different than many in this thread (though others clearly know more than I do); I just evaluate our understanding as much less accurate than many others do.
- CuriousSkeptic 5y agoWith asking questions I meant simple things like just notice that particular statements are a bit too simple. I have consumed my fair share if theory from an array of sources hung up on their particular take. My take away so far is that we understand pretty little. Any particular prescription is more or less just extrapolated from rather naive statistical correlations. The current understanding is good enough to reproduce those correlation when treating particular deficiencies or diagnosing certain metabolic dysfunctions but besides that they mostly say “healthy people tend to eat such and such” I mean desperate measures like bariatric surgery a thing. One of the most effective treatments against obesity to be sure, but not really indicative of field with shit together.