3 ms·
> This actually points at a central problem with modern democracy One explanation of why we should prefer democracy that I quite like goes like this: Democ
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
> This actually points at a central problem with modern democracy
One explanation of why we should prefer democracy that I quite like goes like this:
Democracy is rooted in the belief that more than half the people are right more than half the time
It doesn't have to rely on everyone being smart, or even thinking. It only has to rely on the statistical likelihood that, even with all the errors and noise and lack of thinking and even stupidity that might manifest in any individual, if more than half the voters agree on something, there's a better chance that it's the right choice than the wrong one.
THere are all kinds of holes that can be poked in this approach, and I sometimes do that, but fundamentally I stand by the basic conception that this describes.
- int_19h 5y agoNote that, in case of a representative democracy, it's actually "more than half of the voters can pick a person who is right more than half the time". And I'm not so sure that it's the case when information required to make the choice is lacking, and agitprop is substituted instead.
- VLM 5y agoWhat we have instead is identity politics, which is pretty toxic when mixed with democracy. Eventually we'll have to get rid of one or the other, and its not looking good for democracy at this point.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> What we have instead is identity politics, I'd say that this is a glib simplification that conveys almost no information about the actual state of US politics at any level.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoIdentity politics has been a thing longer than a century at this point though?