4 ms·
Every city on earth thinks their traffic is the most chaotic. Having driven around Manhattan a lot, I'd say it is probably the easiest use case for automation.
by paxys 5y ago
Every city on earth thinks their traffic is the most chaotic. Having driven around Manhattan a lot, I'd say it is probably the easiest use case for automation. Wide streets, perfect grid, slow traffic, flat, standard weather conditions, no two-way traffic lanes to cross. In fact I fail to see how this data would even be valuable to Waymo compared to what they are already getting from Phoenix and San Francisco.
- ethanbond 5y agoYes yes, never mind the pedestrians for whom crosswalks and walk indicators are mere suggestions, or the thousands of delivery guys going 30mph on e-bikes in every possible (different from legal!) direction of travel. And while there are lots of wide, slow, neatly gridded streets, there are tons of streets that are none of those things. NYC is certainly not the most chaotic, but it’s a billion times more so than Phoenix.
- whimsicalism 5y agoThis is just east coast cities.. Something that astonished me when I moved to SF was how little people jaywalk here.
- ethanbond 5y agoCorrect! Functional cities have rampant jaywalking.
- the-rc 5y agoIt's worse than that. Not only they don't jaywalk, they stand or wander randomly all over the sidewalk/corner, getting in the way of those who are trying to get somewhere. Downtown SJ might be the winner, though. Even at noon, in broad daylight, you might not see a car for a quarter or half mile (SF is never that deserted), yet pedestrians wait for the walk signal. Craziness. At least they don't give jaywalkers the stare of disapproval you'd get in Japan.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhere are these wonderful wide streets, beyond the avenues and major cross-town streets? Most are a lane or less, especially with double-parking.
- pchristensen 5y agoI think it's safe to say that Manhattan traffic is more complex than suburban Phoenix, without claiming Manhattan traffic is the most chaotic.
- pie42000 5y agoYou are either a troll, or have never driven a car in Manhattan. It is without a doubt the craziest, rudest, most agrrssive city I have ever driven in, and is 100% the hardest city to automate driving in. If Waymo can succeed in NYC, they can succeed anywhere in the first world. India and Thailand are a whole different ball game, but we will see.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dml2135 5y agoYea I don't know how one can look at NYC traffic and claim it's anything other than a total shitshow.
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoI found driving in Manhattan to be fairly civilized, honestly. Boston, on the other hand, is by far the worst city I've driven in on the surface street level. Atlanta the worst for highway driving.
- xadhominemx 5y agoDrivers in Boston are definitely more aggressive than those in NYC but the built environment in NYC is 5x more intense / insane.
- 1986 5y ago> perfect grid Only above 14th Street, and even then, that ignores e.g. Broadway which has a bunch of really frustrating-to-drive intersections with a ton of pedestrian traffic > standard weather conditions A year in Manhattan has significantly more variability in weather conditions than a year in Phoenix or San Francisco > no two-way traffic lanes to cross There are undoubtedly significantly more one-ways in Manhattan than many other cities but two-way streets absolutely still exist, most of the wider streets in the grid system are two-way, so's Houston
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoIt isn't a perfect grid and the streets aren't all wide. There is no shortage of two way streets where left turns are impossible without skirting the law.