3 ms·
Intelligence implies vetting one’s sources well.
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
Intelligence implies vetting one’s sources well.
- deep-root 5y agoWould think "educated" implies this, as intelligence is a raw faculty.
- eevilspock 5y agono. it depends on your motives. if it's just building an audience to make money or fame, vetting sources doesn't matter, and may even be counterproductive. sad truths about our current culture.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI guess that is true if you do not care about the broader world.
- derefr 5y agoIntelligence just means spotting patterns faster. If you're intelligent but "detail oriented", that just means you'll end up coming up with a brilliant solution to the wrong problem. In a Dungeons and Dragons character, knowing to vet one's sources would be an example of "Wisdom". And I think that's probably the right word for it in conventional speech as well.
- nwiswell 5y agoHuh. Is "detail oriented" usually meant in such a pejorative sense? I had it figured as HR-speak for "willing to do boring stuff"
- GhettoComputers 5y agoI always thought of intelligence as adaptation to environments. You’re correct on the intelligent detailed person.
- Atlantium 5y agoThere is no academically or commonly accepted definition of intelligence. Your confident statement renders everything else you say suspect.
- derefr 5y agoI'm defining intelligence as "the thing we think people have when they have a high IQ" — similar to how depression is currently medically defined as "that which is measured by a forced swim test." Obviously, measured intelligence is not "real intelligence" ("g", whatever that is) — but at the same time, people increasingly use the term "intelligent" to refer to someone who has high measured intelligence (IQ), whether or not they have high "real intelligence." So the definitions sort of collapse into one-another over time. "The measure becomes the target", but for language.
- Atlantium 5y agoIQ testing is not how anyone measures intelligence and hasn't been for quite some time. I suspect the problem lies here: Intelligence requires a multi-part definition, to use your analogy, much like swimming. Swimming is defined as the action of moving oneself through water using your limbs. An intelligence definition should include the ability to extrapolate, comprehend and innovate information accurately as far as we can understand the world. The more precisely one can do this and the more depth of knowledge one has the more intelligent one is. A tricky thing to define.
- derefr 5y ago> An intelligence definition should include the ability to extrapolate, comprehend and innovate information accurately as far as we can understand the world. What? "Intelligence" is not a psychology jargon term; it's just a word, defined by the way lay-people put the term to use in conversation. Language is used to communicate; we define words (jargon excluded) as what the majority of people understand them to mean. When jargon and regular words collide, the lay-definition wins, and the jargon definition gets lost. (See e.g. "begging the question", which has become a lay-term for "something that has an obvious corollary or unstated flaw" rather than its meaning as a jargon term in logic.) That's why academics invent terms like "g" — to make sure that the jargon term has no lay-term it's colliding with.