4 ms·
A couple things I've wondered about: * The popular fake meats, such as Impossible burgers, seem like ultra-processed foods. Is that right? Are they healthier t
by wolverine876 5y ago
A couple things I've wondered about:
* The popular fake meats, such as Impossible burgers, seem like ultra-processed foods. Is that right? Are they healthier than meat (a question without a general answer, but worth considering)? They could help with climate change, regardless.
* A basic question, but I haven't found an authoritative answer: Warnings about carbohydrates talk about processed foods but are silent on whole grains. Are whole grains a more healthy way to consume carbs?
- friedman23 5y ago"Plant based meats" are carbohydrate heavy so they are really only meat-like in terms of taste and texture but fail as meat replacements due to the completely different nutritional profile.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoNot the case for the aforementioned Impossible Burger[1] which has about twice as much protein as carbs (and quite a bit of fat). But the question of how 'processed' they should be considered is interesting. 1: https://faq.impossiblefoods.com/hc/en-us/articles/360018939274-What-are-the-nutrition-facts-for-Impossible-Burger- https://faq.impossiblefoods.com/hc/en-us/articles/3600189392...
- code_duck 5y agoAlso you can discount the fiber portion of the total carbohydrates, since it’s indigestible, and with that it has 3x the protein vs carbs. Meat has zero carbs, though.
- tasty_freeze 5y agoEat the impossible burger for the ethics of it, not for reasons of health.
- throwamon 5y ago... Or just eat what vegetarians have been eating since forever and keep your ethics AND health?
- jhbadger 5y agoAlthough it is important to understand that fake meats are a part of traditional vegetarian culture, at least East Asian ones. There's a whole genre of Chinese food that is based on fake beef, fake pork, etc. Whether these are better or worse than the new "disruptive" versions from Impossible and Beyond is another issue, but the idea that "real vegetarians" don't eat fake meat is a narrow, Western misconception.
- wolverine876 5y ago> There's a whole genre of Chinese food that is based on fake beef, fake pork, etc. Very interesting - what are they called? What are they made of? Where do they come from?
- jhbadger 5y agoGenerally it is just called "vegetarian meat" (素肉) and is made from a mixture of potato-like tubers, beans, and wheat, with various spices to give it flavor. There are even a few restaurants in the US that serve it, for example Yuan Fu Vegetarian in Rockville, MD (Washington DC suburb) Here's an article from several years ago that talks about the tradition https://www.economist.com/1843/2018/07/02/china-the-birthplace-of-fake-meat https://www.economist.com/1843/2018/07/02/china-the-birthpla...
- wolverine876 5y agoThat's awesome, thank you! I somehow never encountered it (or maybe I did without knowing what I was eating).
- el_benhameen 5y ago
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> Are whole grains a more healthy way to consume carbs? Yes, more healthy. The less processed it is, the more fiber it has, and the more micronutrients remain. To the degree that you consider carbs to be the problem, though, it's still carbs.
- mike00632 5y agoBeef has trans fat, saturated fat, heme iron (impossible has this too but most other meat alternatives don't) and is often processed with cancer-causing chemicals that give harmful meaning to the word "processed".
- joshuahaglund 5y agoThe article barely mentions it but one big loss with processed foods is dietary fiber, which seems to help regulate carbohydrate absorption (iirc). I scaled the nutrition facts to match serving size grams, all number are grams except cal: calories. I hope formats ok... Serving size cal fat protein carbs fiber Impossible 113 240 14 19 9 3 Beans(pinto) 113 161.90 0.66 9.91 29.74 9.91 Refried beans 113 85.45 1.92 4.79 12.78 3.51 Ground Beef 113 308 20 31 0 0 Looks like impossible managed to keep the 3/1 ratio of carbs to fiber that beans have, while increasing the protein ratio and adding fat. Hummus is technically a processed food. But if it's not too high salt or filled with preservatives, it's not less healthy than eating garbanzo beans with sesame seeds, etc. From my perspective, impossible is a little healthier than a burger (a lot healthier if you count the environment) but it's not a salad. https://faq.impossiblefoods.com/hc/en-us/articles/360018939274-What-are-the-nutrition-facts-for-Impossible-Burger- https://faq.impossiblefoods.com/hc/en-us/articles/3600189392... https://www.nutritionix.com/food/pinto-beans/1-cup https://www.nutritionix.com/food/pinto-beans/1-cup https://www.nutritionix.com/food/refried-beans https://www.nutritionix.com/food/refried-beans https://www.nutritionix.com/food/ground-beef https://www.nutritionix.com/food/ground-beef
- wolverine876 5y agoThanks for doing all that work. > Hummus is technically a processed food. But if it's not too high salt or filled with preservatives, it's not less healthy than eating garbanzo beans with sesame seeds, etc. I'm not sure what the properties of hummus (or artichokes or beer) implies about the properties of Impossible burgers.
- joshuahaglund 5y agoThe hummus comment was to point out that there are foods which people might consider processed, but it doesn't mean it's less healthy than their unprocessed ingredients. Just depends on how it was processed. Maybe I'm misunderstanding "processed" tho But I guess it's kinda obvious that there are levels of processing and IDK what impossible is doing. But I'm curious.
- sleepysysadmin 5y ago>The popular fake meats, such as Impossible burgers, seem like ultra-processed foods. Is that right? Very highly processed, but 'what is processed' really anyway. That's not a proper metric to judge things. >Is that right? Are they healthier than meat (a question without a general answer, but worth considering)? If you believe the status quo, the impossible meats are tremendously unhealthy. Almost always being higher in saturated fats and such than any real meats. If you believe that political activists have wrongly accused fat of being a problem. Then these impossible meats are fantastic. >They could help with climate change, regardless. Most likely not. This is just another political activist move. Yes a cow farts, but if you properly assess carbon capture of animal agriculture... meat production is good for climate change. Those cow patties is practically all carbon that was taken out of the air and is being returned to the earth. The problem is that animal rights activists want to propose any idea to have animals no longer slaughtered. >A basic question, but I haven't found an authoritative answer: Warnings about carbohydrates talk about processed foods but are silent on whole grains. Are whole grains a more healthy way to consume carbs? Glycemic index is what you're looking for. The magic number is 30. Anything above 30, avoid. Regular white bread is ~69 Wholegrain is ~79 Rice ~72 So it's marginally worse, and that's because the process to make it white removes various parts of the grain and ends up adjusting for more protein and less carbs in ratio.