4 ms·
Can someone, maybe even a nutritionist or doctor, recommend an authoritative textbook or course on nutrition? I would need something at the undergraduate or non
by wolverine876 5y ago
Can someone, maybe even a nutritionist or doctor, recommend an authoritative textbook or course on nutrition? I would need something at the undergraduate or non-specialist graduate level. Being a topic that directly affects every day of the rest of my life, I would like to gain as sophisticated an understanding as a can, given limits of time. I could work through one textbook or course.
I know there are not always authoritative answers about nutrition; there is much uncertainty. That's all the more reason to have the knowledge distilled by an expert (who would of course discuss uncertainties).
- zemvpferreira 5y agoWhat interests you specifically? I've never read a nutrition textbook front-to-back but I spend a good portion of my time reading research and opinions on nutrition. I think I've cobbled together a pretty good education on the topic over the past decade. I'm sad to say 99% of what I've read has been hack science, stupidly obvious or minute in importance. It's almost troubling to me how far you can go just following Michael Pollan's old chestnut: eat (real) food, not too much, mostly plants. Barring any intolerances that right there will get you to near-optimal nutrition for general health in 8 words. EDIT: Being guilty of not reading the article before posting, I just noticed my message ties nicely with the content. If you want to look good inside and out, eat food your grand-grandparents would recognise in amounts that wouldn't shock them.
- wolverine876 5y agoIn this case, I'm not interested in (further) gradual accumulation of knowledge; I want authoritative fundamentals of nutrition, probably starting with how the body processes food. In my experience, in many cases the latter more efficient (less time, much more knowledge, much more accurate) if I have time to do it. For something as central as nutrition, I will prioritize it.
- CuriousSkeptic 5y agoYou might enjoy the crash course youtube channel. I found the pace and depth just about right for my own taste. Episode on metabolism and nutrition: https://youtu.be/fR3NxCR9z2U https://youtu.be/fR3NxCR9z2U
- wolverine876 5y agoWhy do you trust them?
- CuriousSkeptic 5y agoI guess I trust that they have no particular agenda besides explaining rather non-controversial topics. So I trust them as much as I would trust, say, a high-school textbook
- wolverine876 5y agoOT: It's interesting to me why people trust things on the Internet, when everyone knows the Internet is drowning in BS. We know, yet we keep ingesting it. If you think about what goes into a high school textbook, including the expert reviews before one is recommended (IIRC, Richard Feynman served on a review panel for school textbooks), AFAIK there's no comparison. I feel like I live in a bizarro-world sometimes. I seem to be the only one who cares.
- CuriousSkeptic 5y agoThere is the context of the learner also. You asked about quickly getting up to speed in the basics. To me that means a level of understand where you just recognise the extent of your ignorance but have a decent enough mental model and vernacular to know how to ask the right questions. The model is going to be simplistic anyway, but as long as its recognised as such theres just so much damage particular misinformation can do. Compared to a group of enthusiasts who actually believe their simplistic model to be more or less complete enough. There is no shortage of such models when it comes to nutrition.
- barathr 5y agoThis is still a subject of ongoing debate, and little has stood the test of time. Take for example work by anthropologists such as Herman Pontzer that find that hunter gatherers do far more physical activity than Americans yet burn the same number of calories each day.
- naasking 5y agoYou're overcomplicating this. The fundamentals of nutrition are simple, and are as follows in decreasing priority order: 1. Calories: too few and you die, too many and you gain weight, get sick and die early. 2. Macronutrients: too few and you will get sick and possibly die, too much doesn't matter so much as long as calories are under control. 3. Micronutrients: too few and you will live, you just might be a bit sickly (brittle bones, scurvy, anemia, etc). Too much of some micronutrients can be toxic, but most you'll just excrete in various ways. That's it for the basics. There are some recommendations around fiber and other things to lower your risk of various age-related diseases, but if you just keep your calories in the right range and ensure you get the necessary macronutrients and micronutrients, then you know everything you'll likely ever need to know, barring any medical conditions that require specific diets.
- mft_ 5y agoYou’re almost asking the impossible. Nutrition is an area with a lot of dogma, a lot of pre-existing bias, and plenty of conflicting evidence that supports almost anyone to cherrypick things to suit their agenda. This is why you can buy books which (seek to) prove almost opposite positions. The best single source I’ve found is nutritionfacts.org - this is their YouTube channel: https://youtube.com/c/NutritionfactsOrgMD https://youtube.com/c/NutritionfactsOrgMD Dr Greger isn’t perfect, and of course has his own plant-based agenda to push… but aside from maybe missing the pleasure of some foods, I can’t see that there’s anything to lose from a health perspective in following his advice… while there may be a large amount to gain. As others have said, a home-cooked plant-based diet is a very solid base to start from.
- wolverine876 5y ago> You’re almost asking the impossible. Nutrition is an area with a lot of dogma, a lot of pre-existing bias, and plenty of conflicting evidence that supports almost anyone to cherrypick things to suit their agenda. This is why you can buy books which (seek to) prove almost opposite positions. That's one reason I'm looking for a textbook or academic course. I am not interested in the political battles; I don't want this month's new book (and I certainly don't agree with the proposition (which the parent didn't say) that everything is politicized).
- ikr678 5y agoI dont think there are many 'canon' texts in this space, because of all the conflicting evidence and continual improved understanding of how diets impact health (eg gut ecology, inflammation are recent big research areas). Looking at a university level course list on nutrition and reading into each of the subject areas might be a start (Pick the ones that apply to you - nutrition in infants is perhaps not relevant). The Oxford Handbook of Nutrition is a good summary reference text. https://www.booktopia.com.au/oxford-handbook-of-nutrition-and-dietetics-joan-webster-gandy/book/9780198800132.html https://www.booktopia.com.au/oxford-handbook-of-nutrition-an...
- wolverine876 5y ago
- ericmcer 5y agoJust start playing with your diet. Not only is information around diet not guaranteed, it is also specific to each individual. Probably even specific to a time in a persons life. Try vegan for a few weeks, try keto for a month, see how you feel. I think shaking up your diet is as important as how you shake it up. I would lean towards some research and then diving in and tracking how you feel/perform versus trying to gain a deep academic textbook understanding.
- wolverine876 5y agoI agree about experimenting (and I do that). Feeling bad is a strong indicator, perhaps, but less so feeling good: People can spend decades eating things that make them feel good and lead to heart attacks. I could smoke cigarettes, which make people feel good.
- barathr 5y agoEat food. Not too much. Mostly plants. From Food Rules: https://michaelpollan.com/books/food-rules/ https://michaelpollan.com/books/food-rules/ And "Nutrition: the Emperor has no clothes": https://metarationality.com/nutrition https://metarationality.com/nutrition
- artificialLimbs 5y ago>> Mostly plants. Unless you're Mikhaila Peterson, who has found (after many types of diets) that eating beef and beef alone alleviates her myriad health problems.
- QuadmasterXLII 5y agoIn single variable calculus and newtonian physics, sufficiently talented researchers come to the same conclusion when they devote significant time to a question, with sufficiently talented researchers beginning to appear in high school. In chemistry, sufficiently talented researchers will come to the same conclusion, with sufficiently talented researchers appearing in college, or more likely graduate school / professional labs for organic chemistry. As humans, we don't have researchers who are so talented that if you ask them to answer nutritional questions, they will consistently and independently come to the same conclusions. This isn't because nutritionists are dumb, this is because nutrition is hard. However, it makes it much harder to suss out dumb nutritionists when the smart ones disagree. Notably, none of this stops anyone from writing books.
- mike00632 5y agoA diet that works for me is to simply eat only foods that the vast majority of experts agree are healthy, e.g.: greens, berries, nuts, beans, etc
- twofornone 5y agoIt's not that nutrition is harder than physics or chemistry, instead it is far less ideal, and more importantly, purely empirical (as opposed to experimental). This is they key distinction between hard and soft sciences and, incidentally, why it is dangerous to treat soft sciences like psychology and sociology (and nutrition) with the same certainty as hard science like physics.
- edanm 5y ago> As humans, we don't have researchers who are so talented that if you ask them to answer nutritional questions, they will consistently and independently come to the same conclusions. This isn't because nutritionists are dumb, this is because nutrition is hard. However, it makes it much harder to suss out dumb nutritionists when the smart ones disagree. AFAICT, that's not true, and only appears true because of the vast amount of attention one side is able to get, despite being an incredibly small minority. From what I understand (I'm not in the field and not an expert), except for the few researchers in this article, basically every scientist working in nutrition will say that the energy balance model is correct, and that there's nothing special about carbs. The media loves to amplify the contrarian and minority voices (see also things like climate change). But they really are outliers, and there really is a consensus, at least on this one big question.
- naasking 5y agoYou really don't need anything that sophisticated to understand what you need to know. People way overcomplicate this. Dr. Israetel's short TED talk covers everything almost anyone will need to know in their lifetime about what healthy eating means. Only people with specific health conditions that require restricted diets, and maybe elite athletes who have strict regimens may require more understanding of their nutrition: https://youtu.be/TYeZVfPxwKM https://youtu.be/TYeZVfPxwKM
- wolverine876 5y agoWhy do you trust this person? > You really don't need anything that sophisticated to understand what you need to know. I've heard that all my life, but usually not from people on HN! Knowledge is a powerful thing; it enables me to think for myself and not be prisoner of what others say (or don't say).
- naasking 5y ago> Why do you trust this person? He's a well known, non-nonsense researcher in exercise science. Take the 15 minutes to listen and judge for yourself. > Knowledge is a powerful thing; it enables me to think for myself and not be prisoner of what others say (or don't say). Signal to noise ratio matters. The SNR in nutrition is terrible, and will more than likely lead you to analysis paralysis. Save yourself some time and pain. Even if you decide to go deeper, Israetel points you in the right direction.
- wolverine876 5y agoThank you. As a tangential point: > Take the 15 minutes to listen and judge for yourself. I don't think that's possible without knowledge in the domain. Human beings are bad at judging trustworthiness, especially the trustworthiness of their own judgment on the issue. IMHO, that's exactly how mis/disinformation spreads; sophists can easily sound trustworthy. > Signal to noise ratio matters. The SNR in nutrition is terrible, and will more than likely lead you to analysis paralysis. Save yourself some time and pain. Agreed. And that was the context of my original question.
- CuriousSkeptic 5y agohttps://www.norden.org/en/publication/nordic-nutrition-recommendations-2012 https://www.norden.org/en/publication/nordic-nutrition-recom...
- scoot 5y agoEven though it has a climbing specific slant, the podcast at https://www.climbingnutrition.com/ https://www.climbingnutrition.com/ covers all the bases with a science led approach. The episodes can be frustrating long and rambling (I offered my services to edit down, but they declined), but the content is still incredibly valuable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- artificialLimbs 5y agoThe effects of different foods will be different based on the individual. Observing how you feel during and after eating various things will tell you more about that thing than anyone else can.
- GhettoComputers 5y agowww.raypeat.com has tons of useful information, and he will respond to emails if you have specific questions.