3 ms·
Apart from the anti-trust angles as to why such a merger is bad, I am also concerned about the increasing political biases among employees in the publishing wor
by throwawaysea 5y ago
Apart from the anti-trust angles as to why such a merger is bad, I am also concerned about the increasing political biases among employees in the publishing world. For example, employees at Penguin Random House protested the publishing of Jordan Peterson’s new book (https://reason.com/2020/11/25/jordan-peterson-12-rules-for-life-sequel-penguin-random-house/ https://reason.com/2020/11/25/jordan-peterson-12-rules-for-l...). Simon and Schuster employees protested the publishing of Mike Pence’s memoir (https://thehill.com/homenews/media/549311-simon-schuster-rejects-employees-call-to-drop-pence-book-deal https://thehill.com/homenews/media/549311-simon-schuster-rej...). There are numerous other examples that can be found via search, and the spike in political protests at publishers coincides with the rise of protests and calls for deplatforming elsewhere.
Something similar has been happening with booksellers as well. Industry groups like the American Booksellers Association have been bowing down to progressive activists’ pressure (https://apnews.com/article/lifestyle-entertainment-business-arts-and-entertainment-amazoncom-inc-26035c9ee8c2720d1bd2dc7983b035f3 https://apnews.com/article/lifestyle-entertainment-business-...). Leftist activists have pressured physical bookstores to remove books from their shelves (https://reason.com/2021/01/11/powells-books-antifa-andy-ngo-store-censorship/ https://reason.com/2021/01/11/powells-books-antifa-andy-ngo-...). Even new online independent bookstore Bookshop.org has joined the culture wars, asking customers to donate to send copies of “The 1619 Project” to schools (https://bookshop.org/1619 https://bookshop.org/1619).
Books are a really fundamental tool in our society for the exchange of information and ideas. The introduction of political and ideological wars into the world of book publishing and sales is scary, and out of touch with classically liberal enlightenment values. However, seeing as how many institutions have been taken over or caved to such pressures, I feel like choice and competition are the one thing protecting free expression on this medium. As such, I would not like to see the type of consolidation these publishers are pushing for.
- mcphage 5y ago> The introduction of political and ideological wars into the world of book publishing and sales is scary, and out of touch with classically liberal enlightenment values. You think the presence of political and ideological wars in book publishing is new?
- throwawaysea 5y agoI am not sure. It feels new to me. I think the level of coordination and organization by fringe activists is likely greater today than ever before thanks to the Internet. I also think that there has been a clear leftward swing in bias in colleges that may be fueling this shift against free exchange of ideas. Is it possible there were biases in the past, potentially in the other direction? Sure. But I wouldn’t be surprised if the level of such pressures is greater today than in the last 100 years. I’m curious if you see it differently or if you have data/evidence saying otherwise.