3 ms·
Your question shows the limits from reductio analysis. You have to look at it systemically. Shifting the burden to the landlord, especially at a time of trans
by gumby 5y ago
Your question shows the limits from reductio analysis. You have to look at it systemically.
Shifting the burden to the landlord, especially at a time of transient shock, is not only a direct tax, it's a tax when they may be themselves suffering a revenue shock just as their tenants are. Even replacing a tenant isn't automatic; there are transient costs and it can take time. While subsidizing the tenants takes cash from a large base (including debt, borrowed at a much lower rate than a landlord can get). That's the surface difference.
But you may ask "who cares? Why do the landlords a favor?" Well there's a systemic issue in such a shock (think of swimming in the ocean when a wave drops you then lifts you independent of your swimming). Keeping the tenants in situ means the landlords can continue economic activity (doing repairs, buying lunch, going on vacation, etc). The tenants can too -- if nothing else they can look for a job rather than looking for a job AND looking for a place to live. Or they may not have actually lost their job, but just suffered from transient reduced demand (e.g. fewer haircuts) which might end up being complete job loss if they lose housing. Essentially you are preventing a liquidity crisis.
And there are second order consequences as well: as the paper shows homelessness increases; this is a general tax on everyone not just in social programs but in all the followon consequences of having a lot of people on the streets.
It's the same argument for subsidising farmers, even if most of them these days are big businesses: they suffer a lot of transient economic pressure (busts and booms) but we need a reliable food supply. So we engage in dreadfully wasteful behavior because we've decided it's better to pay that than suffer a food supply shock.