4 ms·
As the author of an open source DAW that already supports non-4/4 time ... first of all, there are some annoying details to even get as far as the full scope o
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
As the author of an open source DAW that already supports non-4/4 time ...
first of all, there are some annoying details to even get as far as the full scope of western metric notation. For example, compound time: 6/8 does not mean "6 eighth notes per bar", even though there's a growing body of DAW-trained young people who seem to think that it does.
But "worse" (harder, is perhaps a better phrase), dealing non-western concepts of meter requires moving beyond "just divide it however is needed". A relatively simple case would be music from the Balkan/Byzantine cultures, which are much better represented using a notation form like [ 3L + 2S + 3L ] ("3 long beats, 2 short beats, 3 long beats"). There is a great deal of music from around the world that uses this structure, and even if a western notation like 8/N migh theoretically capture this, it doesn't contain the information required to play it.
Moving to even harder metrical forms, Carnatic and Hindustani talas are always conceived on in their own cultures as rhythmic cycles that cannot be decomposed to simple western notation. Even teental, perhaps the most widespread and maybe the simplest, is not usefully representable using western time signatures (it consists of a cycle of 16 beats, where the timbre of the beats creates rhythmic motion and structure).
FWIW, I hope to add the [ N + M + P ] form to Ardour in the not (too) distant future.