4 ms·
For most things, Google Docs suffices for me. I rarely do complex formatting, and the most advanced thing I do in Sheets/Excel is vlookups, and even that I have
by saltminer 5y ago
For most things, Google Docs suffices for me. I rarely do complex formatting, and the most advanced thing I do in Sheets/Excel is vlookups, and even that I haven't done in months.
However, for my writing (fanfiction), desktop Office is a necessity. I used to think the "web layout" in Word was weird, but I live by it now. It's a much more efficient use of screen real estate than "print layout" (I have a 4k monitor and like to maximize the window), and Google Docs has no equivalent.
But ignoring the page layout, let's consider something more concrete: loading times.
I loaded a 106 page document in Google Docs on my desktop (AMD R7-1700, 64 GB RAM, NVME SSD, symmetric gigabit internet - a pretty good system overall). It took 27.72 seconds to load, and a couple more after that until I could type without it hitching. According to Chrome's task manager, the tab is already consuming 418 MB of RAM.
On my laptop (Intel i5-6300U, 8 GB RAM, SSD, same internet, Office 365 build 2109), I loaded two Word documents at the same time. Combined, they total 764 pages in print layout. It took 9.71 seconds to load both and for me to be able to type in the 527 page document without any noticeable lag. Word is currently sipping just 250 MB of RAM (and I have never seen it go >500 MB before except when exiting...meanwhile, a single Chrome tab hitting >1 GB is not exactly unusual if my desktop has been running for more than a week).
This doesn't even consider the experience of writing a document this long. Google Docs is already noticeably slower than Word with just a 106 page document, and it gets worse with longer ones. And the grammar checking in Word is miles ahead of what Google has.
Word certainly isn't perfect (I have plenty of complaints about it, and have found bugs which only turn up in long documents), but it remains my tool of choice because Google Docs really can't compete for this use-case. And I know I'm not the only writer in this situation.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoIs there a reason you use office to write in? It’s not good writing software. Ever tried writing software like this? http://www.theologeek.ch/manuskript/ http://www.theologeek.ch/manuskript/
- saltminer 5y agoI've never looked into it except some paid application which I didn't feel was worth what they wanted at the time. I might try that when I finish my current story.
- GhettoComputers 5y agohttps://www.literatureandlatte.com/scrivener/overview https://www.literatureandlatte.com/scrivener/overview was it this one? Its the gold standard for me I love it.
- saltminer 5y agoYeah, that was it. Back when I heard about it, I was writing one-offs and couldn't see the potential usefulness (much less justify spending money).
- GhettoComputers 5y agoIt is a very nice app if it fits your workflow, give it a try, it changes the way you write. You can make tons of short stories, but I am going to try manuskript instead since I have linux, its got a very nice interface.