5 ms·
Justice sues to block Penguin Random House’s acquisition of Simon and Schuster
- richardatlarge 5y agoI once signed a contract to write a textbook. The publishers were so busy swallowing up each other I had a clause added: if the house sold, I would be able to move to another publisher and keep my advance, and one year later, I did
- keneda7 5y agoI am all for this. IMO publishers especially textbook publishers are running a racket on us. Giving one company even more control over the market is definitely not going to help the situation. They mention with the acquisition Penguin would "control of close to half the market for acquiring publishing rights to anticipated top-selling books". They also mention how the market is dominated by 5 major players already. Is this domination due to the major 5 players being able to pay substantially more to acquire publishing rights than the little guys or is something else at play?
- poidos 5y ago[I have a close family member that works in publishing] As far as I can tell, part of it is that the bigger publishing houses are able to get lucky more often; they're more likely to get a bestseller than a smaller publishing house. This is apparently due to a combination of 1. Being able to pay more authors as a raw number (they're numerically more likely to get a "hit"), which is partly because of 2. Inertia from already having big authors, so people look to sign with them before considering the smaller publishers. Note that this is really only for mass-market stuff; specialty genres are different. The big publishers are also able to cut better deals with distribution centers and booksellers.
- keneda7 5y agoThank you very much for your reply. Its always good to hear from inside the industry. The two points make complete sense. I can definitely see an author wanting to stick with a publisher that has made them money in the past.
- quartesixte 5y agoNot to mention: Advances. No not for the big celebrity writers doing memoirs/biographies. Those are already out of the realm of imagination for indies. It’s the advances given to up-and-comers out of the MFAs, and the advances given to professors teaching at said programs. An indie book house will not be able to front 100k to an author for a book in the way the big 4 does (funded in part by the celebrity books they sell).
- scyzoryk_xyz 5y agoThis is a cynical take and I’m no expert but perhaps the publishing industry can’t afford the legal fortress needed for effective protection from anti-trust enforcement? I mean there seem to be plenty of enormous mergers and acquisitions that aren’t and haven’t been blocked over the past several decades.
- 999900000999 5y agoI'm still a bit lost as to why this and the music industry haven't been more disrupted by technology. You don't need a record label you don't need a book publisher, you can, if people want to consume your content just write your book and have people just send you money via patreon or one time donations. I've made music with friends for a long time, and the industry makes it very hard for any independent artist to get ahead. You have some of the worst deals ever imaginable given to these kids, who are often only 18 or 19 and the label just takes everything. Why do we need any of that, I go out of my way to buy music exclusively from independent artist, while I might stream some popular hit. When it comes to actually buying merchandise, or music I only give it to the Indies.
- kevingadd 5y agoIt's in part because advertising still drives visibility which drives sales, and all the main discovery mediums are centralized and sell ad placements to the highest bidder. Combine that with the typical algorithmic promotion algorithm, where Amazon etc want to show you things they think you're likely to buy, so they mostly sell you things that are already top sellers.
- JeremyReimer 5y agoThe publishing industry was disrupted by technology in 2007 when Amazon released the Kindle. It took a few years, but for a while, independent book authors were rivalling the "Big Five" publishers in terms of both sales volume and books sold. Part of this was driven by the big publishers' response to indies: they raised the price of their own eBooks to protect their hardcover market. They even illegally colluded with each other, along with Apple, to force these higher prices across the industry. But they were sued and lost, and the result was a lowering of big publisher eBook prices across the board. On the independent side, the problem was that too many people were publishing too many books. It was impossible to keep up, and there was no good system for finding the "best" independent authors, since tastes are so subjective and the vast majority of independent authors didn't have any money to spend on marketing anyway. So that leads us to today, where the "Big Four" (trying to become the Big Three) still have access to their promotional machinery, which includes retail bookstores. There are a very few insanely successful independent authors, and a veeeeeery long tail of folks that have no way of getting noticed in the crowd. Still, the sales volume of traditional publishing and independent publishing remains about equivalent even today (it's hard to get exact numbers because Amazon doesn't like giving them out, but apps like KindleSpy offer a broad estimate) It's just that the latter is spread out among many more authors.
- antonzabirko 5y agoInstead of going after google, microsoft, or even citadel they go after publishing companies. It would be funny if it wasn't so sad.
- throwawaysea 5y agoApart from the anti-trust angles as to why such a merger is bad, I am also concerned about the increasing political biases among employees in the publishing world. For example, employees at Penguin Random House protested the publishing of Jordan Peterson’s new book (https://reason.com/2020/11/25/jordan-peterson-12-rules-for-life-sequel-penguin-random-house/ https://reason.com/2020/11/25/jordan-peterson-12-rules-for-l...). Simon and Schuster employees protested the publishing of Mike Pence’s memoir (https://thehill.com/homenews/media/549311-simon-schuster-rejects-employees-call-to-drop-pence-book-deal https://thehill.com/homenews/media/549311-simon-schuster-rej...). There are numerous other examples that can be found via search, and the spike in political protests at publishers coincides with the rise of protests and calls for deplatforming elsewhere. Something similar has been happening with booksellers as well. Industry groups like the American Booksellers Association have been bowing down to progressive activists’ pressure (https://apnews.com/article/lifestyle-entertainment-business-arts-and-entertainment-amazoncom-inc-26035c9ee8c2720d1bd2dc7983b035f3 https://apnews.com/article/lifestyle-entertainment-business-...). Leftist activists have pressured physical bookstores to remove books from their shelves (https://reason.com/2021/01/11/powells-books-antifa-andy-ngo-store-censorship/ https://reason.com/2021/01/11/powells-books-antifa-andy-ngo-...). Even new online independent bookstore Bookshop.org has joined the culture wars, asking customers to donate to send copies of “The 1619 Project” to schools (https://bookshop.org/1619 https://bookshop.org/1619). Books are a really fundamental tool in our society for the exchange of information and ideas. The introduction of political and ideological wars into the world of book publishing and sales is scary, and out of touch with classically liberal enlightenment values. However, seeing as how many institutions have been taken over or caved to such pressures, I feel like choice and competition are the one thing protecting free expression on this medium. As such, I would not like to see the type of consolidation these publishers are pushing for.
- mcphage 5y ago> The introduction of political and ideological wars into the world of book publishing and sales is scary, and out of touch with classically liberal enlightenment values. You think the presence of political and ideological wars in book publishing is new?