2 ms·
Yes, scientists must absolutely be aware what ties authors have if those authors are arguing in bad faith to push an agenda: > First, researchers must learn to
by xg15 5y ago
Yes, scientists must absolutely be aware what ties authors have if those authors are arguing in bad faith to push an agenda:
> First, researchers must learn to identify authors of research, and their relationships with industry and with non-profit groups that have specialized agendas. How the tobacco industry paid scientists and physicians to serve as advisers and consultants to undermine the body of evidence pointing to the harms of tobacco is extensively documented. More recent examples abound. For instance, the non-profit International Life Sciences Institute, based in Washington DC and funded by leading companies in the food and chemical industries, promotes doubt about science that links ultraprocessed foods with health concerns, and provides experts to promote personal responsibility rather than regulations on junk food in policies to combat obesity.
Edit:
> What we need is scientists who have backbone, who have an unwaivering unaltering desire to get to the truth at all costs.
This is one part of what this article is demanding. It's arguing against efforts of entrenched interests - often businesses - to obscure the truth or make it harder for the general public to tell truth from untruth.
The second part is about taking action. Informing is one part, but at some point courses of action have to be decided - and for many problems, it's not enough to delegate this to individuals, the decision has to be taken on a collective level. Because we will never have 100% knowledge, a certain amount of uncertainty has to be tolerated when deciding on a course.
What this article also argues against is tactics that specifically target this unavoidable amount of uncertainty with the interest of delaying action.
- tomohawk 5y agoMore importantly, they should be aware of their own biases. Human history shows that this is too much to ask, as we all have biases. That is the whole point of having a transparent debate and looking at falsifiable evidence/tests.
- xg15 5y agoAnd then what? Again, at some point, we have to decide which action to take.
- pdonis 5y ago> but at some point courses of action have to be decided And doing that is not the scientist's job. So scientists should not be filtering what they say because they want to encourage or discourage some course of action. They should just be telling the truth as best they know it. > for many problems, it's not enough to delegate this to individuals, the decision has to be taken on a collective level. First, I think the problems for which a collective decision has to be made are much rarer than many people think. Governments have gotten their fingers into all kinds of pies that they don't actually need to be in, but where government intervention serves a special interest. Second, there isn't just one collective level. There are many of them. As a general rule, you want people who are going to bear the costs and reap the benefits in a particular area to be involved in collective decisions about that area, but you don't want people involved who aren't. That generally means pushing collective decisions down to the lowest possible collective level. But again, our political system very often doesn't do that. Third, when it comes to collective policy decisions, scientists have no special expertise; they are just citizens like everyone else. Scientists who believe some kind of action is required because of something they found in their scientific research still are only seeing that one narrow viewpoint of their research; that doesn't give them any special ability to see the big picture or to take other interests or factors into account. > What this article also argues against is tactics that specifically target this unavoidable amount of uncertainty with the interest of delaying action. Uncertainty can be used either way: it can be used to try to delay action, or to try to motivate it (we don't know whether X will be a problem, but if it is, it will be huge, so we can't take a chance on not doing something about it). Both can be issues.
- xg15 5y ago> As a general rule, you want people who are going to bear the costs and reap the benefits in a particular area to be involved in collective decisions about that area, but you don't want people involved who aren't. But this is exactly what the article is arguing for. Often enough industry groups like the tobacco or oil industry were manipulating policy such that they were reaping the benefits while everyone else was bearing the costs. Those industry groups are already producing biased research. The article argues that more scientists should be ready to expose this bias. This rule also isn't completely general. Those who bear the costs, those who reap the benefits and those who would be affected by actions might be three different groups. It sometimes can be desirable to make a rule that is applied very broadly to avoid inequities and arbitrage effects. Finally, in global issues such as climate change and COVID, everyone is bearing the costs, so action can't be restricted locally. > Uncertainty can be used either way: it can be used to try to delay action, or to try to motivate it (we don't know whether X will be a problem, but if it is, it will be huge, so we can't take a chance on not doing something about it). Both can be issues. Both can be issues, yes. But in the discussed fields, again climate change, COVID, tobacco use, health effects of highly processed food, etc, scientific consensus is by a wide margin that X is both very likely and will deal enormous damage. So uncertainty in that direction is already very small.