8 ms·
> Why do we keep expanding highways when it is proven that it does not help? Expanding highways increases throughput almost everytime. Certainly, it rarely end
by toast0 5y ago
> Why do we keep expanding highways when it is proven that it does not help?
Expanding highways increases throughput almost everytime. Certainly, it rarely ends congestion. It often reduces congestion, but that depends on how far the capacity is behind the actual demand.
In most places I've lived, road expansion is a response to increased demand from increased population, either through density or sprawl (but usually both). If you let population increase without increasing tranport capacity, you get congestion. That's true for roads and mass transit. Ideally, as the population grows, you expand both. But, expanding roads is often simpler, as you can do it in parts, addressing bottlenecks one at a time, whereas mass transit isn't very effective with piece-wise solutions; I can't easily drive to a highway transit station, take that 10 miles, then drive to my final destination, I need at least one of the local trips to be on transit/walkable and have parking available or have favorable conditions for biking (weather, physical ability, room on transit, managable hills).
- ryukafalz 5y ago> road expansion is a response to increased demand from increased population, either through density or sprawl Though it's the road expansion itself that often leads to more sprawl. It's worth noting that congestion in mass transit leads to better service. (Well, if you have a halfway competent transit agency, anyway.) More riders leads to more fares leads to more frequent service leads to getting you where you need to be more quickly. Road congestion doesn't have the same effect. Maybe it's a toll road in which case you have some increased revenue, but often it isn't - so congestion is typically net negative for drivers.
- nitrogen 5y agoThough it's the road expansion itself that often leads to more sprawl. Every trip taken is an economic activity that would not have otherwise occurred. Traffic is commerce. Sprawl allows the middle class to continue to exist. More people, more property taxes, more fuel taxes, more money for roads.
- ryukafalz 5y agoSprawl allows the middle class to continue to exist? There are plenty of places that don't have nearly the level of sprawl that we have in the US; does the middle class not exist there? (Japan, for example.) More money for roads? If the population increases but is pushed to the periphery, requiring new roads to support them, aren't we just digging ourselves in deeper? How does that pay for the existing roads?
- mcguire 5y ago"Sprawl allows the middle class to continue to exist? There are plenty of places that don't have nearly the level of sprawl that we have in the US; does the middle class not exist there? (Japan, for example.)" I can't really speak to the existence of the middle class but I'll just leave this here: "An astonishing fact: 92 percent of Japanese [like many countries including the US] consider themselves middle-class, according to a labor ministry report published in 2019. That seems to clash with another fact: that nearly 40 percent of Japan’s work force is employed on a part-time or temporary basis, earning less and more vulnerable to layoffs than regular company employees." Anyway, this is interesting: https://resources.realestate.co.jp/rent/what-is-the-average-rent-in-tokyo-2020-ranking-by-ward-and-layout/ https://resources.realestate.co.jp/rent/what-is-the-average-... A 1K/1DK (1 bedroom) apartment in the Central Six wards of Tokyo averages 106,000Y per month. The other 17 wards average 72,000Y. A 1K/1DK apartment in Saitama (https://resources.realestate.co.jp/rent/what-is-the-average-rent-in-saitama/ https://resources.realestate.co.jp/rent/what-is-the-average-...) is 49,000Y. That's ~30-45 min by car or 40 min to 1hr by train (according to Google); i.e. kinda sprawly. I can't find a median wage for Japan, but the average seems to be about 300,000Y per month, meaning that apartment in the Central Six is out of reach, the other wards would be doable, and outside Tokyo proper would be very doable.
- modriano 5y agoBut the reason Japan doesn't have this kind of sprawl is that buildings are depreciating assets in Japan with an expected lifespan between 20 and 40 years, which both creates regular opportunities to build higher occupancy buildings and eliminates the paralyzing financial incentives for restricting housing supply [0]. In the US, real estate is the dominant store of wealth for a plurality of Americans, which is why we see such fierce opposition to development. Dense accumulations of people affords great economic opportunities which attract more people, but people need somewhere to live, and if the supply of housing is held far below the demand, prices rise and push out people who can't afford said prices. So people who can't afford sufficient housing within commuting range of economic opportunities within their abilities can either A) forgo the benefits of metropolitan living, B) search the fringes of the metropolitan area for places they can afford/are allowed to build, or C) become homeless. It would be great if we could just nationally eradicate the regulations, ordinances, zoning codes, etc that cities and towns use to prevent development, but I don't think the 10th amendment allows for that kind of law. And without more housing, there will be sprawl. [0] https://www.rethinktokyo.com/2018/06/06/depreciate-limited-life-span-japanese-home/1527843245l https://www.rethinktokyo.com/2018/06/06/depreciate-limited-l...
- amurthy1 5y agoIncreased ridership on roads does increase revenues via gas taxes.
- dralley 5y agoIf you have more roads to maintain, what good does the extra revenue do you?
- throw0101a 5y ago> Certainly, it rarely ends congestion. It never ends congestion. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess%27s_paradox * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Downs%E2%80%93Thomson_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Downs%E2%80%93Thomson_paradox Want to reduce congestion? Improve transit, build higher density communities, and demolish highways.
- Domenic_S 5y agoThe answer has to be more nuanced than that. Before 2004 the Cuesta Grade near SLO was 4 lanes and permanently congested at commute time. After widening to 6 lanes in 2004, I've rarely noticed congestion at typical congestion times.
- maccam94 5y agoIt's possible to overbuild roads where there isn't demand for them. But for major metropolitan areas, there are large numbers of people who want to go to similar categories of destinations, and their choice of specific destination is constrained by convenience. If expanding a road reduces congestion (and thus time to reach somewhere), more people will travel farther distances to get there until a new congestion equilibrium is reached.
- spothedog1 5y agoYou could design cities so people could walk to local neighborhood shops instead of ripping coal on a highway to get to Walmart. Skip public transit, just a local bodega in a lot of neighborhoods would cut car trips by a ton.
- avianlyric 5y ago> That's true for roads and mass transit. Ideally, as the population grows, you expand both Difference is that mass transit benefits substantially from scale, with cost per rider dropping with ridership increases. Road networks, not so much. Kickstarting the process is a little tricky. But just about every other developed country has managed it, I’m sure the US can figure it out too.
- stonogo 5y ago> Expanding highways increases throughput almost everytime. Certainly, it rarely ends congestion. It often reduces congestion, That turns out not to be the case. Road widening almost always worsens congestion. http://plazaperspective.com/road-widening/ http://plazaperspective.com/road-widening/ People never complain about throughput. People complain about trip times, and road widening never helps that.
- toast0 5y agoHere's some stats from a Los Angeles area project. http://boardarchives.metro.net/BoardBox/BB2015/2015_05_May/150526_I_405_Sepulveda_Pass_Improvements_Project_Evaluation.pdf http://boardarchives.metro.net/BoardBox/BB2015/2015_05_May/1... Have a look around page 18. Time with congestion was reduced by about 2 hours daily from before the project to after the project. There's also several charts of trip times in there, although some of them are comparing different times of the year which is less apples to apples IMHO. If exhibit 4-133 from the report after the slides is a good comparison, the congestion was effectively eliminated; however the before is during construction, and it's a single day, so that's a bit hard to take at face value; I'm guessing they didn't have any/enough saturday data from the 2009 before construction data set to compare with.