8 ms·
> Most people see potholes on their street and publicly complain that the government is terrible yet the 320,000 person city next door here has a TWO YEAR back
by mistrial9 5y ago
> Most people see potholes on their street and publicly complain that the government is terrible
yet the 320,000 person city next door here has a TWO YEAR backlog of street fixes, I was told. Property taxes are as high as any place in the USA. There is no shortage of money, retirement 401k and medical care for city workers. Of course they also play the sub-contractor game a bit, not as bad as corporate on that one.
- ohples 5y agoOne of the reasons might be because a lot cities in america are going bankrupt just trying to maintain all the car centric infrastructure that has been built: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJp5q-R0lZ0_FCUbeVWK6OGLN69ehUTVa https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJp5q-R0lZ0_FCUbeVWK6...
- mperham 5y agoWe can't afford it. Roads are a massive treadmill of maintenance. To step back, why do we have so many square feet of road space? Why do we keep expanding highways when it is proven that it does not help? The automobile and its inefficient infrastructure is bankrupting this country. We keep building more roads rather than investing in transportation infrastructure which is far cheaper in the long run. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORzNZUeUHAM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORzNZUeUHAM
- criddell 5y ago> why do we have so many square feet of road space? Because that's what voters want. If true self-driving cars ever become a reality, there's going to be a big demand spike for more and bigger roads.
- winkeltripel 5y ago> If true self-driving cars ever become a reality, there's going to be a big demand spike for more and bigger roads Why would there be a need for more roads? It seems like the opposite would be true: self-driving cars don't need safe following distance to each other. They could form a massive train (the more you look at self driving cars, the more they look like trains), with 1 inch of space between each vehicle. Highway lanes are so wide, that small self-driving vehicles could sit 2-across, with an inch of space between them. On-demand self-driving-cars could cut the total number of cars on the road by a big factor. Self-driving cars might never crash, so they won't need all those tons of safety equipment that each car lugs about, saving a pile of net energy.
- ryukafalz 5y ago> They could form a massive train ... with 1 inch of space between each vehicle. Okay, now a deer or a moose runs onto that road during a short gap in traffic. What happens next? > the more you look at self driving cars, the more they look like trains Sure, really big trains, with a tiny fraction of the carrying capacity.
- criddell 5y agoSelf driving cars will eventually be significantly less expensive than current vehicles. They will be small and electric inexpensive to operate and trips will be very cheap. When the cost of a trip drops, more trips will be made. If self-driving succeeds to the point where I can send my car to pick up my dry cleaning or food without needing to be in the car, then expect the number of vehicles on the road to go up a lot. We might be able to pack two times as many cars on the road and make intersections way more efficient, but that won't be enough.
- tqi 5y agoI don't think most people conceptualize commutes in terms of distance, but rather time. So if commutes are now faster, people will move further out into areas that previously were less developed ie require new/more roads.
- cinntaile 5y agoYou can afford it, but you don't want to. Increase the taxes on vehicles and on fuel and earmark these taxes for transportation infrastructure. If too many people would just fill up their tanks in a neighboring state require a miles logger instead. Technically it's easy to fix but this is a people's problem.
- nitrogen 5y agorequire a miles logger instead That's a huge non-starter warranting much harsher language than is reasonable for HN.
- gumby 5y agoWhy? It ties taxation to usage and is uniform between dino-burners and electrics. Every street-legal vehicle already has one, so the question is really how to get an authenticated reading once per year/period.
- HWR_14 5y agoI assume you are talking about annual mileage charge (based on odometer readings) and it was read as constant GPS tracking to charge continuously based on mileage.
- nitrogen 5y agoAnnual odometer reporting is totally fine, of course. I read "logger" as "continuous data logger." That's never going to be acceptable.
- cinntaile 5y agoI assume you already carry a continuous data logger in your pocket. At least it's voluntary. ;) I don't know what the most practical solution is while still being respectful of people's privacy. It could be a combination of GPS and an odometer or just one of these or something else. It doesn't have to leave the car and only the total number each year is important. You just need to somehow make sure the results weren't tampered with.
- toast0 5y ago> Why do we keep expanding highways when it is proven that it does not help? Expanding highways increases throughput almost everytime. Certainly, it rarely ends congestion. It often reduces congestion, but that depends on how far the capacity is behind the actual demand. In most places I've lived, road expansion is a response to increased demand from increased population, either through density or sprawl (but usually both). If you let population increase without increasing tranport capacity, you get congestion. That's true for roads and mass transit. Ideally, as the population grows, you expand both. But, expanding roads is often simpler, as you can do it in parts, addressing bottlenecks one at a time, whereas mass transit isn't very effective with piece-wise solutions; I can't easily drive to a highway transit station, take that 10 miles, then drive to my final destination, I need at least one of the local trips to be on transit/walkable and have parking available or have favorable conditions for biking (weather, physical ability, room on transit, managable hills).
- ryukafalz 5y ago> road expansion is a response to increased demand from increased population, either through density or sprawl Though it's the road expansion itself that often leads to more sprawl. It's worth noting that congestion in mass transit leads to better service. (Well, if you have a halfway competent transit agency, anyway.) More riders leads to more fares leads to more frequent service leads to getting you where you need to be more quickly. Road congestion doesn't have the same effect. Maybe it's a toll road in which case you have some increased revenue, but often it isn't - so congestion is typically net negative for drivers.
- nitrogen 5y agoThough it's the road expansion itself that often leads to more sprawl. Every trip taken is an economic activity that would not have otherwise occurred. Traffic is commerce. Sprawl allows the middle class to continue to exist. More people, more property taxes, more fuel taxes, more money for roads.
- ryukafalz 5y ago
- m4rtink 5y agoNarrow gauge railway siding for every house! ;-) (And I'm just half joking, that would be insanely cool!)
- masklinn 5y agoThat was pretty much the standard in the late 19th and early 20th century. The lines were often economically non-viable and were shut down in the 30s, but on the eve of WWI you had villages of under 1000 people with their own train stations (as small as 20sqm), gauges so narrow you had to walk sideways to fit between the rails (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2_ft_and_600_mm_gauge_railways https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2_ft_and_600_mm_gauge_railways), and sometimes closer to trams than regular rails with the rails bolted straight onto road surface.
- m4rtink 5y agoThere were even dedicated estate railways! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_narrow-gauge_railways#Estate_railways https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_narrow-gauge_railways#... Not enough milk in the estate kitchen ? Send a maid with a train to the village to restock! Also on north Germany they have a 60 cm railway connecting an island at low tide: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%BCttmoorsiel-Nordstrandischmoor_island_railway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%BCttmoorsiel-Nordstrandis... Or the famous Kurobe Gorge Railway in Japan at 762 mm that goes via hard moutain terrain and 40+ (!) tunnels: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurobe_Gorge_Railway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurobe_Gorge_Railway (We travelled it once, can recommend, superb experience!) Still apparently even if you switch to electric cars and/or trolley buses tire and road surface abrasion is still apparently a significant pollution hazard. I guess metal wheels on metal rails are less of an issues, so it might make sense to use rail based wehicles more heavily, especially with modern technology improvements (automatic routing/switching, battery powered trains, etc.).
- xyzzyz 5y ago> We can't afford it. Roads are a massive treadmill of maintenance. They are not. They are less than 10% of budget of most municipalities. We can easily afford the road, even at today’s highly inflated construction costs.
- ryukafalz 5y agoOkay, what percentage of the budget would they be if we were fixing them fast enough that we didn't have a constantly growing backlog of repairs?
- xyzzyz 5y agoThat depends on the the practices in that place. Many places have little no significant backlog and low expenditures. It’s all a matter of how the municipality contracts out the work, who gets the work and how, what work is prioritized etc.
- ryukafalz 5y agoGot an example? I'd like to see a low-density city that's actually been consistently able to pay for its road maintenance. And not a place that only has relatively new roads, mind you: somewhere that's already had to go through the process of repaving them as they deteriorate at least once or twice.
- xyzzyz 5y agoSure. For example, consider the municipality of Wenatchee, in eastern Washington. In 2021, street maintenance is 3.5% of entire municipal budget. Another 6% is for capital improvements for road infrastructure (e.g. installing new traffic lights, new sidewalks, etc), but capital improvements do reduce maintenance in areas where capital improvements were done, so let’s say that 5% of entire municipal budget goes for road infrastructure maintenance. That’s hardly a large maintenance burden. As it happens, most places that are not having some unrelated problems, like eg. being depopulated after industrial collapse, can easily cover the road maintenance, considering how little they spend on it, compared to other items in the budget. If you don’t believe me, now it’s your turn to look at the data: pick a municipality with terribly maintained road, and tell me what percentage of their budget is spent on road maintenance.
- BurningFrog 5y agoThe real cause is that we sell road access for $0. So the same thing happens as when you sell bread for $0. Supply runs out, you have long lines, and everyone is unhappy. Road pricing would make driving enormously much better, but it's counterintuitive and radical, so I doubt we'll see it in my lifetime.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoToll roads?
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoTextbook regressive tax, even more so in this day and age where the less well off you are the more likely you are to have to live further out. You can always find someone poorer who commutes by bus to underpin an anecdote but going from renting an apartment within the public transit network to owning a car, renting outside the public transit network and commuting in is a big level up for most people because despite the commute arguably being worse it gives you flexibility when choosing your next jobs so your next steps up come easier.
- BurningFrog 5y agoPaying for what you consume is not a tax! This argument is only applied to road consumption for some reason. Note that is road pricing makes traffic flow at the speed limit rather than crawling during rush hour, people can commute from much further away.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>Paying for what you consume is not a tax! Everybody is already paying for it in their taxes. Furthermore everybody is also paying per use for the energy used, time and cost of vehicle ownership. How would you like it if the city started charging per use at the park beside your house? Maybe then you'd see how comically asinine it is to repressively tax public infrastructure that we have already decided is a net positive. And I'll preempt the obvious low effort retort by saying that city public transit should also be free at the point of use. >Note that is road pricing makes traffic flow at the speed limit rather than crawling during rush hour, people can commute from much further away. Yeah, if you're a doctor or lawyer or techie and can justify the cost relative to your increased earnings from commuting. The drywaller and the janitor have just as much right to sit in a traffic jam as you do. Increasing the cost per use for public good when not coupled to an increased cost to provide that good (last I checked bitumen prices didn't skyrocket) ALWAYS boils down to kicking the poors out so that whosoever left can have a better experience. This approach is completely antithetical to the reasoning behind spending money on these public goods in the first place. Making everyone endure the same crap equally ensures that the people who can most effectively load balance to something else or a different commute time do.
- conductr 5y ago> Why do we keep expanding highways when it is proven that it does not help? We're stuck inside of a ponzi scheme
- bingohbangoh 5y agoCalifornia has roving black-outs [0], New Jersey can't have clean water [1], New York subways are disgusting. [2] But I'm told over and over again: "you get what you pay for." I just don't believe it anymore. Per your bit about roads, many have tried to decipher why the US has such expensive road construction and its not at all clear. We're a very bizarre outlier. It's more than just being affluent. [3,4] I'm venting a bit but its tragic that such a rich nation can't properly build anything anymore. Heck, Flint Michigan got hundreds of millions of dollars _and still doesn't have clean water_. [5] Most bizarre to me is that nobody seems that interested in where the money goes. NYC spent $1.25 billion on a mental health outreach program that has had no publicly visible effects or milestones. [6] It was made permanent this year. [7] I'm told over and over again that the problem is "not enough money" but where the hell is it going to in the first place? Why does nobody care to answer this question? [0]: https://www.politico.com/states/california/story/2020/08/18/california-has-first-rolling-blackouts-in-19-years-and-everyone-faces-blame-1309757 https://www.politico.com/states/california/story/2020/08/18/... [1]: https://patch.com/new-jersey/newbrunswick/high-pfoa-levels-middlesex-co-water-get-full-story https://patch.com/new-jersey/newbrunswick/high-pfoa-levels-m... [2]: https://www.amny.com/transit/nyc-subway-stations-garbage-dumps-fail-to-meet-cleaning-standards-according-to-audit-1.10437148/ https://www.amny.com/transit/nyc-subway-stations-garbage-dum... [3]: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/08/why-didnt-the-2009-recovery-act-improve-the-nations-highways-and-bridges.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/08/wh... [4]: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2019/07/why-we-cant-figure-out-why-infrastructure-is-so-expensive.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2019/07/why-we-cant-figure-o... [5]: https://www.npr.org/2019/04/25/717104335/5-years-after-flints-crisis-began-is-the-water-safe https://www.npr.org/2019/04/25/717104335/5-years-after-flint... [6]: https://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/too-much-money-chirlane-mccrays-hands-thrivenyc https://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/too-much-money-chir... [7]: https://nypost.com/2021/05/06/de-blasio-rebrands-wifes-1b-thrivenyc-makes-program-permanent/ https://nypost.com/2021/05/06/de-blasio-rebrands-wifes-1b-th...
- Hermitian909 5y agoI'm having trouble tracking it down, but a few years ago congress set up an investigation into why costs are high. The investigation, which basically consisted of calling up various experts, asking them to talk for free, and compiling what they said, reported that the issue was so complicated it needed a better funded study. To my knowledge, that better funded study has not occurred. At a very broad I recall some of the items identified were: - Illegal collusion between contractors capable of expensive jobs - Illegal collusion between contractors and consultants hired by cities to help pick winning bids - No expertise in government due to cutbacks, so no ability to vet a proposal or understand the progress made (see above) - No accountability in government - No accountability for contractors in in contracts - Poorly thought out legislated process on choosing bidders - Inefficiencies in mandated working conditions (think multiple people sitting around watching a hole) - Government/private enterprise corruption These are all over simplified high level points. The dynamics here get quite complex. For example, local government often signs a contract with a local contractor wherein they are able to put in stop work orders as desired without owing payment for the time. This is very expensive for the contractors, they must pay to move heavy machinery to another job or wait while paying their workers. Delays can add millions in cost/lost revenue for the contractor. The contractor thus has to drastically increase prices to hedge against these delays. These issue touch every level of government: city, county, state, and federal. Sadly we no longer have a functional body politic capable of addressing issues of that scale.
- gamblor956 5y agoFixing a pothole is significantly more work than most people think it is. Process for fixing a pothole so that it stays fixed until the next time the road is resurfaced: 1) Identify the size and depth of the pothole; if it's more than just replacing asphalt (i.e., the subsurface is damaged) than it's a significantly more involved job, otherwise... 2) Identify the appropriate asphalt mixture for the road's wear and tear, since a busy road will need a different type of asphalt from a less-traveled road. 3) Get the crew out to the pothole. 4) Clean the pothole and surrounding road so that the new asphalt patch can stick to the existing asphalt. 5a) Apply the tack coat, which will help the asphalt stick to the existing asphalt and to the subsurface. 5) Lay in and roll the asphalt. To create a seamless patch with the existing road, it will be necessary to "creep up" on the proper amount of asphalt, so this step will be repeated a number of times. 7) Block out the patch for at least 24 hours so that the asphalt can properly cure. (More expensive asphalt mixtures can be driven on within a day) 8) Send a work crew back the next day to take down the traffic cones blocking out the patch.
- wolverine876 5y ago> There is no shortage of money, retirement 401k and medical care for city workers. Because this is a common anti-labor narrative which often turns out to be false, I should ask: Do you have any good sources or that? > Property taxes are as high as any place in the USA. There is no shortage of money Property taxes are just one form of revenue, and may not be nearly sufficient.
- mistrial9 5y agoa quick look at the "sunlight" document on city salaries, shows about 12,000 employees of the city overall construction coordinator: starting $76k per year, grades $80k to $98k per year construction & maintenance supervisor II: starting $98k per year, grades $100k to $120k per year construction field inspector: starting $81k per year, grades $81k to $100k per year pavement management supervisor: starting $77k per year, grades $80k to $94k per year every listed position has 401k retirement and health care benefits. why waste time proving this when urban decay is a constant, documented situation? certainly some cities have failed budgets from the 2008 era, thats true, but not in this case. this is the same city that was voted "worst unfixed potholes in the continental US" recently in some media outlet
- wolverine876 5y agoThank you. I'm not sure what the data means to you. Those look like reasonable salaries to me, though I don't work in those fields. > why waste time proving this when urban decay is a constant, documented situation? Urban decay is a meme, like urban crime. Crime is, generally speaking, at generational lows (shootings and murders are up, but that's nationwide, not urban, and those are only a fraction of crimes), but some people imagine cities infested with it. There are certainly urban problems with infrastructure, but using memes doesn't tell me what we're talking about. IME the common narrative is that lots of people, especially these days, want to cut taxes and then complain about reduced services.
- mistrial9 5y agothe city mentioned in consistantly "top 10 most dangerous cities to live in the US"; there are gunshots in neighborhoods multiple times per week, with corresponding fatalities .. sometimes those not involved at all are shot, too.. similar environment to parts of Chicago I hear
- mschuster91 5y ago> There is no shortage of money, retirement 401k and medical care for city workers. Fixing roads (the proper way, but also slapping a bucket of asphalt in the hole and flattening it) is a physically demanding job. You need to go out there and work no matter if it's cold, raining or snowing, so the applicant pool for such a job is extremely small to begin with. The ever-growing "academization" of society (aka Boomer parents and media telling their children that only having a college degree will lead to a good life) eliminates even more of the applicant pool for all trade jobs... and the result of that is that even with some trades offering high five to sometimes six figures worth of wages, many openings go unfilled for years.