2 ms·
> But one has to convince the residents or other voting population of that. There's plenty of other things that that has obviously not been true for, I don't s
by whimsicalism 5y ago
> But one has to convince the residents or other voting population of that.
There's plenty of other things that that has obviously not been true for, I don't see why we should default to this extreme localism you seem to be advocating.
We didn't let local voters decide to continue imposing testing requirements to vote, we didn't let them allow businesses to continue to determine patrons based on race, we don't allow local jurisdictions to unilaterally confiscate land/property from private owners.
Given that this is a large problem, I don't see why non-local governmental action should be given an effective veto power by residents who don't want to see anyone new in their neighborhood. The burden is on you to justify that, given extensive evidence on how this would be welfare & growth enhancing.
> What the preference was aimed at is that many people want single homes, garages, yards, etc. If they can't get them, they will end up moving to where they can. If they have them, they (and the other neighbors) will advocate to keep the neighborhood that way.
Yes, plenty of people advocate for things that are in their self-interest yet bad for society. Your point?
> You can call something societally beneficial, but others might not see it the same way.
Sure. By beneficial, I mean net welfare enhancing for society. It's obviously not beneficial if your criteria is "increasing the price of my home by constricting supply."
- giantg2 5y ago"Given that this is a large problem, I don't see why non-local governmental action should be given an effective veto power by residents who don't want to see anyone new in their neighborhood." So my question still stands and just moves up to the next level. Now you have to convince the majority of the state or country to support that sort of law. At the federal level, the 10th ammendment might even prevent this type of law. The second half of that sentence is pretty inflammatory. There are many people who don't want new houses constructed and changing the density of their neighborhood but would welcome someone new if they're moving into an existing house. "Yes, plenty of people advocate for things that are in their self-interest yet bad for society. Your point?" My point is that people want single homes with these amenities and in that sort of setting. Why shouldn't they have that? You're implying that this is bad for society, yet I see no support for this. I see nothing that prevents the free market from addressing or self correcting housing issues. Vaguely claiming that your position is beneficial and others are not is unproven. Even if it would be beneficial, you still have to convince the voters to support it. "Sure. By beneficial, I mean net welfare enhancing for society. It's obviously not beneficial if your criteria is "increasing the price of my home by constricting supply."" We would have to prove the net benefit part. Nobody said it was about home values. Some people support many restrictions for reasons other than property value, like quality of life, infrastructure issues, etc.