3 ms·
A sounds like it would lead to increased chances of people overpaying and overextending themselves, and B sounds like it would lead to more accurate pricing.
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
A sounds like it would lead to increased chances of people overpaying and overextending themselves, and B sounds like it would lead to more accurate pricing.
- toolz 5y agoI agree B) isn't being employed by only malicious companies. We're talking about a huge market and tons of competition. It would take a lot of effort to keep honest companies from making money also bringing prices down if there was artificial price inflation. I've definitely not studied the market extensively, but it seems rather intuitive to me that if you artificially give everyone access to the best loans in any market, you'll see prices continue to inflate until everyone in the housing market is educated and capable on benefiting from the subsidized loans.
- drnonsense42 5y agoThat’s one of the talking points parroted by HFT firm representatives defending their business. There’s a lot of research on it as well. I bet successful real estate firms will use that same argument. I personally have a hard time believing this will benefit the average consumer buying a home.
- long_time_gone 5y agoYou are right that the pricing is more accurate. But it is more accurate for a company trying to increase their own revenue, not someone trying to own and occupy a house (most Americans, based on home ownership rates). The calculations used are entirely different and so is the capital available. In the world without this type of behavior, that pricing difference could be captured by an actual homeowner over the life of their mortgage. It's another thing we are seeing "optimized" right in front of us. Meanwhile, housing, education, and healthcare get more expensive for actual humans.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> But it is more accurate for a company trying to increase their own revenue, not someone trying to own and occupy a house (most Americans, based on home ownership rates). Also for the house seller (prior to the company), who is getting paid a more accurate, higher price. And a price is accurate all the same for buyer and seller, since there exists a range with the minimum price the seller wants to receive and a maximum price the buyer wants to pay. The smaller this range, the more accurate the price. With more data and more accurate projections, it may be possible for current owners to capture more of the gain that may have happened down the road.