3 ms·
So why is that surprising? There are few or no quality scifi/fantasy movies if you actually read scifi/fantasy books. Villeneuve did something competent-ish wi
by nottorp 5y ago
So why is that surprising? There are few or no quality scifi/fantasy movies if you actually read scifi/fantasy books.
Villeneuve did something competent-ish with Dune. Altered Carbon season one was decent. I couldn't watch the second season because they really went off the rails with it. That's about all lately.
Funny enough, I think the best sf movies are the one that ignore the source material and do ... something else. Blade Runner for example. Or Tarkovski's Stalker. Note that they aren't named as the books that inspired them.
As for Foundation, I haven't seen it and don't intend to. But judging by people's opinions it looks to me that not only it has no connection with the book. It's also a bad movie taken as a standalone movie?
- throw0101a 5y ago> That's about all lately. Checkout the The Expanse. > ignore the source material and do ... something else. Blade Runner for example. Blade Runner did not call itself Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?. Contrast that with the Will Smith movie I, Robot.
- nottorp 5y ago> Checkout the The Expanse. That doesn't count because the books read like a film script (the authors are professional script writers). And yes, I've read them. Before they were made into a movie even. > Blade Runner did not call itself Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?. Contrast that with the Will Smith movie I, Robot. "Note that they aren't named as the books that inspired them." i said :)