3 ms·
Is it, really, actually more important? Or do the CEO and board of like-minded folks who are executives at adjacent companies merely have more direct control o
by klyrs 5y ago
Is it, really, actually more important? Or do the CEO and board of like-minded folks who are executives at adjacent companies merely have more direct control over who gets the money? Because without the folks who actually make the tractors, the company quickly loses its primary source of income. What's the CEO's actual value-add?
- refurb 5y agoI see this attitude a lot among younger workers with technical expertise. “How hard is running a company? Making “X” is what’s hard.” They then point to the fact they are at the top of their game and an expert and have a post-graduate degree. Their job is very hard and they are very skilled, no doubt. But once you get exposed to upper management you start to realize it’s really hard to get a large group of people to work towards a common goal. Stuff goes off the rails very easily when people don't understand, care of even know what the company is trying to accomplish and how that relates to their job. And convincing outside investors (public or private) that your business is actually worthwhile investing in and in "capable hands" isn't easy either. Yes, giving speeches and making “best guesses” on where the business is going seem trivial. But it’s a critical role where if not done well shit falls apart quickly. Remember, some hedge fund doesn't want to know the intricacies of your CPU design - they want to know your company has a product people want and you can deliver it to them profitably. There is a definite "we trust this guy can deliver" filter when it comes to CEOs and it's often based on track record (fairly or not). Look at Elon Musk. What is his value? Knowledge of rocket design? Knowledge of battery technology? Though I hear he’s technical his knowledge is trivial compared to the experts he hires. The depth of his expertise is likely asking his engineers which is best, asking some pointed questions and then making a call on the totality of everything at stake. His value is also in being “the face” of Tesla internally and externally. Motivating his employees with a vision when everyone is betting the company will fail. Convincing people they can do something no one has done before. Very few people can do that well and even fewer can do it for years like Musk did. Now of course very few CEOs are like that, but don’t underestimate the value of CEOs who successfully run even a small business. Those soft skills many technical people think are useless are critical and not many have them in one package. As such, if you've demonstrated you have the chops to run a billion dollar business you can ask for (and will get) a pay package that dwarfs a typical job. And of course you have grifter CEOs who are idiots, but say the right thing. No different than any other job. They don’t tend to last very long as CEOs either.
- boston_clone 5y agoHaving been exposed to upper management in different sectors, most of what you're saying is hyper-inflated, and can be distilled into one singular category: communication. Helping people understand their fit, describing a common or specific goal, convincing investors, giving speeches and reassurances to technologically ignorant people, maintaining a veil of trust in some...thing, is just simply communication. And probably a fair amount of psychopathy, at least in some cases. What this event in particular shows, and will likely continue at other organizations, is that absurd executive pay is absurd, and workers that are underpaid or given inequitable compensation for their work can demonstrably cease operations. The company does not hinge on a single CEO. The inequality is despicable, and the amount of paragraphs here defending that gap is beyond strange, at least from a hacker perspective. And yes, of course, there are CEOs that are idiots. There are also moderately capable CEOs that surround themselves with idiots to insulate themselves from criticisms like "do you really need a $2MM raise?"
- klyrs 5y agoIf you'll read more carefully, you'll note that I didn't say that making tractors is "hard." I said that it's the core business. You get what you pay for. CEOs that pay themselves fantastically high wages, while skimping on their workers, get low-quality results and short-term personal gain at cost to the long-term survival of the company. They demand loyalty from the workers (who often love the company they work for, despite the bullshit from up top), but they're only looking out for number one. I'm not saying that all CEOs are like this, and I've known some incredibly dedicated founder/CEOs who truly bust their asses for the company. But charcircuit's insistence that it's the CEOs who actually make the business work ignores the other 99.9% of the people at the company doing back-breaking work, work the actual overtime, and don't get first-class (or private) flights to go play golf on the company dime. The fact that these people can be replaced is irrelevant. Treat them as disposable, and the company suffers. Underpay them and the economy suffers.