4 ms·
It is really noticeable in talk on solar prices that the learning curve for nuclear tech is negative. Ie, nuclear plants get more expensive as technology improv
by roenxi 5y ago
It is really noticeable in talk on solar prices that the learning curve for nuclear tech is negative. Ie, nuclear plants get more expensive as technology improves.
The odds of that being a natural effect are minuscule. Something is strangling innovation and it is probably some piece of regulation. It is a bit grim but I suppose we're looking to places like India and China for the next big waves of innovation in nuclear energy.
- sien 5y agoSouth Korea had reducing nuclear construction costs. https://thebreakthrough.org/articles/historical-construction-costs-of-global-nuclear-power-reactors https://thebreakthrough.org/articles/historical-construction...
- kragen 5y agoOther cases where this seems to have happened include pacemakers; hearing aids; supersonic jets; ocean-liner trips; small planes (e.g., Cessnas); mercury; chemistry sets; most vacuum tubes; hovercraft; bubble memory (and more generally SSDs that don't die from read disturb); Gyrojet guns; brass vacuum fittings; ebonite; and old-growth lumber. If you limit yourself to just US production, you can apparently add things like microcontrollers; many kinds of machine tools; ventilators; Nixie tubes; and N95 respirators. I don't think it's grim at all that India and China are having big waves of nuclear innovation, but I don't think they stand much of a chance against solar except for niche applications until there's a total manufacturing revolution.
- psd1 5y agoI don't believe a dicky-bird from the UK govt until I see the evidence, but they have announced support for adding new nuclear capacity, with RR in the frame. Turns out that wattage isn't fungible, 24/7 is worth a premium, and land has value.
- voldacar 5y agoI highly recommend giving the book "Where is my flying car?" a read. It is a very idiosyncratic and unconventional book, written by an engineer rather than an academic. He goes into great depth about how the FAA and NRC basically deliberately killed general aviation and nuclear energy, how this happened, and its implications regarding the "great stagnation" and the future of tech.
- bobthepanda 5y agoSupersonic was killed by the dual shock of the oil crisis and the regulations banning sonic booms from overland flights. Which, to be fair, were pretty terrible, or at least were horribly managed from a PR point of view. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oklahoma_City_sonic_boom_tests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oklahoma_City_sonic_boom_tests Concorde was really in the wrong place, at the wrong time, and with not enough of a big market. It didn't fly far enough for it to make a big enough dent in travel times, and it turns out passengers don't mind six vs three hours on a transatlantic hop if they get to spend it sleeping in a redeye in a cushy lie flat seat. If it had been capable of making the transpacific hop, I suspect it would have had a successor even with the sonic boom problem.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"It is a bit grim but I suppose we're looking to places like India and China for the next big waves of innovation in nuclear energy." Or the next wave of chernobyls. Bangladesh is about to open their first reactor. Given how much else is not going well in that country, I would not want to live next to that thing. (and I think 1.5 million people do, who have no chance of getting evacuated in time, in case something big goes wrong). So in general I am really not a fan of regulation - but when it comes to a energy source, where one major accident 35 years ago, and far from where I live, was enough to render the soil around here contaminated, so that collecting mushrooms and eating boar, is still advised against TODAY - then I do see the benefits of regulation.