3 ms·
> When something survives 2x longer than expected, it might be survivorship bias. When it survives 10x, 100x, or 1000x longer than expected, you should probably
by kragen 5y ago
> When something survives 2x longer than expected, it might be survivorship bias. When it survives 10x, 100x, or 1000x longer than expected, you should probably look closer
You're implicitly assuming a normal distribution or something like it, but it's easy for a lognormal distribution to span multiple orders of magnitude like that, and the Weibull distribution commonly used in reliability modeling for this kind of thing can also be heavy-tailed if k > 1.
A simple physical example of how this could arise would be if the filament diameter of a batch of bulbs was normally distributed spanning a factor of 2, resulting in filament resistances spanning a factor of 4, resulting in filament powers spanning that same factor of 4, resulting in filament powers per unit area of filament surface spanning a factor of 2 (since the thickest filaments have the lowest resistance and thus the highest power at a fixed voltage; it'd be 8x instead on a constant-current source), resulting in filament Stefan-Boltzmann temperatures varying by about 19% (1.19 is the fourth root of 2), which works out to a temperature difference of about 200 K for filament temperatures of about 1000 K. That's probably (handwaving here) enough temperature difference for about an order of magnitude difference in vapor pressure, which (handwaving wildly at this point) might mean an order of magnitude difference in filament evaporation rate.
Also, typically there are hotspots in a filament where it's thinner than the rest, which evaporate more rapidly because they're hotter, which makes them get thinner faster, making them even hotter. So the dominating factor in filament lifetime (at a given voltage) might not be how thick it is but how smooth it is.
So, you might find out something interesting. Or you might just find that this bulb had an unusually thick or smooth filament.
(Carbon has 1000x higher vapor pressure than tungsten, though, which is relevant here: https://www.powerstream.com/vapor-pressure.htm https://www.powerstream.com/vapor-pressure.htm.)
- jbay808 5y ago> You're implicitly assuming a normal distribution I'm not really making that assumption. Instead, I'm pointing out that learning this particular bulb survived due to "unusually think or smooth filament compared with other bulbs" is indeed something interesting you can learn by inspecting the survivor, and that might be something you can apply for process quality improvement. Basically, I'm advocating the point of view that if you are trying to improve lightbulb, or say, ball bearing quality (rather than just model it), then it's useful to look beyond the fact that the Weibull distribution is long-tailed. A wide distribution is a reflection of ignorance and thus a learning opportunity; the long tails are still caused by something. Yes, from a given batch of ball bearings, some might last 10x or 100x longer than others under the same loading conditions. But if you put those super-long-lasting bearings under a microscope, you might observe real, important differences compared with others from the same batch. The balls might all be rounder or more identically-sized compared with their cousins. (You can do the inspection before the lifetime test if you want to be extra fair). But it's even more important when you don't expect a long-tailed distribution to begin with; for example, if you have a linear damage model. In this case, if you control for filament diameter, resistance, or brightness, and still see that one bulb is a mysterious outlier, you might want to inspect the joints or run the gas in the bulb through an analyzer to see if there are any other surprises.
- kragen 5y agoAgreed!