42 ms·
> The driver said she was using Autopilot, that an OTA update had had a problem earlier in the day, and that she had actually had the same kind of collision on
by heavyset_go 5y ago
> The driver said she was using Autopilot, that an OTA update had had a problem earlier in the day, and that she had actually had the same kind of collision on Autopilot previously!
So she continued to use it? That's insane.
It's worrying that there are tons of videos on YouTube reviewing Tesla's Autopilot and FSD where the cars do something incredibly scary and dangerous, and the drivers just laugh it off, go "well, it's a beta!" and continue using it instead of turning off the feature that almost got them into a car accident. I don't want to share the road with drivers who think dangerous driving is a funny game.
- penjelly 5y agothis is how i feel too. i want FSD to succeed and i dont want it to destroy itself during the beta. But the videos ive seen are how you put it, people say "whoa that was close" and then re-engage autopilot and have 3-4 more incidents in the same session
- FireBeyond 5y agoAnd then laugh nervously, and demonstrate a complete misunderstanding of ML. "We need to keep having near misses to train the car of what a near miss might be!". And God forbid if they post a dashcam video to YouTube. Then they'll get hit with comments like this with a sincere straight face: > "FSD didn't try to kill you. More like you're trying to get FSD killed by publishing this video."
- hasdf 5y ago> "So she continued to use it? That's insane." Well its proving to be a great excuse when she runs into people with her car. Sounds like a win for her
- ashtonkem 5y ago“It’s a beta” and the unsaid “and I don’t care about other peoples’ lives anyways”. Still pretty frustrated nobody has regulated “self driving” cars off the market yet. If you’re testing it with a driver and a copilot that’s fine, but putting it in the hands of customers and using “it’s a beta” to hide behind should not be legal.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> “It’s a beta” and the unsaid “and I don’t care about other peoples’ lives anyways”. Yes, it's a bit distressing having myself and the people I care about be treated as NPCs to some Tesla owners as they beta test their new toys on public roadways.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- shadowgovt 5y agoI don't disagree, but I can't help but wonder if people feel the same about Ford's pre-collision assist with automatic emergency braking or, back in the day, anti-lock brakes. Sooner or later, these technologies are either public-ready or they aren't. If Tesla autopilot isn't public-ready, I agree it shouldn't be on the road, but I suddenly realize I have no idea by what criteria the system was cleared for public-access roads.
- ashtonkem 5y agoI would absolutely not expect a feature attached to my car to be beta grade, no. And if early ABS systems had issues, I’d expect them to be recalled and fixed at the manufacturers cost.
- xboxnolifes 5y agoThe question is really: does your expectation match reality, or were you just uninformed of there being existing issues on ABS systems? Or more generally: have things always been the way we currently see them and we just less informed in the past, or has there actually been a change?
- ashtonkem 5y agoI’m not of the right age to know, honestly. That being said I have never seen a car maker ship a feature to me that is self described as a beta. Obviously mistakes happen and plenty of features fall short, but seeing a company knowingly ship a feature incomplete safety system for real world testing by their users with a mere EULA agreement seems like a step beyond the hypothetical of the ABS you raise.
- gameswithgo 5y agoWell she says she did. Further confusing the matter is there is the FSD Beta, which very few people have access to for now. Then there is adaptive cruise (works really well!), then there is adaptive cruise with autosteer (not so good!). So who even knows which she was talking about. I fault Tesla for having a mess of badly named options, and for putting beta stuff out on the roads for sure.
- shmoe 5y agoYea, the fsd beta issues last weekend (weekend before?) involved false forward collision warnings.. I imagine she did not have the fsd beta though.
- slownews45 5y agoThen don't drive with other drivers - NON-autopilot drivers eating, texting (constantly!), seeming to look up directions and much more (falling asleep). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cs0iwz3NEC0&t=2s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cs0iwz3NEC0&t=2s The fact that you promote this absolute recklessness and demand users turn off safety features that may, net net save lives is depressing. Finally, folks get very confused between things like autopilot and other features (autosteer beta with FSD visualization) etc. I think some teslas now even show a message warning that cruise control will not brake in some cases? Anyone have that. I've been following the unintended acceleration claims around tesla's as well. Most seem pretty bogus. For what its worth here is data we currently have from Tesla: "In the 2nd quarter, we recorded one crash for every 4.41 million miles driven in which drivers were using Autopilot technology (Autosteer and active safety features). For drivers who were not using Autopilot technology (no Autosteer and active safety features), we recorded one crash for every 1.2 million miles driven. By comparison, NHTSA’s most recent data shows that in the United States there is an automobile crash every 484,000 miles." So you want to go to a 10x increase in crashes. (1 per 484 vs 1 per 4M). I realize this is nt one to one, but even outside of this we are seeing maybe a 2x improvement (if your normalize for road conditions etc). Nission Maxima had something like 68 deaths per million registered vehicle years. Will be interesting to see how this comes out for Teslas.
- gameswithgo 5y agoThat data is not comparable, the autopilot in question there can only be activated in simple situations like a straight highway when you aren't changing lanes. While the human data is for all scenarios. Tesla is not being transparent enough with their data for us to know anything.
- slownews45 5y agoNo one has shown any credible data that the fatality rate driving a tesla is higher than anything. They go out of their way to ignore cars getting into pretty clearly lots of accidents. My expectation would be that Suburu WRX / Infinit Q50 / Elantra GT type drivers are crashing more than folks using autopilot? Maybe ban them first? Anyways, we should in a few years get some NHTSA data on this, though there is some speculation that given their approach towards tesla if its possible they will delay it and stop updating vehicle model statistics if its favorable towards Tesla.
- rvz 5y ago> I talked with the NTSB who said that they won't investigate because no one was killed. So they must wait until lots of people get killed by autopilot / FSD in order for your incident (and many others) to be investigated? The scary thing is that it is beta quality software on safety critical systems and not only the drivers know it, they use it as an excuse to cover them not paying attention on the road. Was driver monitoring even switched on at the time? As I have said before, this software without proper driver monitoring and autopilot / FSD turned on puts the driver and many others on the road at risk. At this point, this is more like Teslas on LSD rather than FSD judging from the bugs from many YouTube videos and social media posts of all of this. Oh dear.
- HWR_14 5y ago> o they must wait until lots of people get killed by autopilot / FSD in order for your incident (and many others) to be investigated? The entire NTSB (which covers trains, planes and automobiles) has 400 employees. They only get pulled into fatal accidents because they only have that much manpower.
- postmeta 5y agoWas it TACC or Autopilot or FSD or driver trying to blame someone else?
- dkdk8283 5y agoStill need transportation…
- gpvos 5y agoShe's supposed to be able to drive herself, without autopilot.
- gordon_freeman 5y agoI think the main problem here seems to be that the driver has put too much trust into Autopilot and what she needs to do is rather assuming it is as just another driver assistance feature and always be in control of her vehicle at all times.
- ajross 5y ago> So she continued to use it? That's insane. Or she just lied to deflect blame for her clearly at-fault collision. I genuinely don't understand why this story is getting so much play here. It's like people read "Tesla" and completely lose their mind. Literally thousands of these accidents occur every day. This is a routine a collision as one can imagine, and there is basically zero evidence for a system failure here at all. It's One Unreliable Anecdote. And it's generated 300+ comments and counting? Come on HN, do better.