6 ms·
Freeman Dyson's autobiography tells how in 01956 he joined General Atomics, a nuclear-reactor startup, and his small team designed and built a new kind of nucle
by kragen 5y ago
Freeman Dyson's autobiography tells how in 01956 he joined General Atomics, a nuclear-reactor startup, and his small team designed and built a new kind of nuclear reactor in two years, the TRIGA; Teller was one of the team members. The prototype operated for 39 years, 33 of them were manufactured, some are still in operation, and none of them has ever had a nuclear accident.
A few years after that, when Project Orion was canceled, he stopped working on nuclear reactors. He said it just wasn't fun anymore. And I imagine he's right; since about that time, working on nuclear reactors enmeshes you in the national security state, where promotion depends on political favor as much as technical competence, and rank is measured by headcount and by project classification level. There's a certain kind of person that's fun for, but it's usually not the kind of person who spends his Christmas vacation working problems from a calculus textbook. It's not the kind of person who discovers a lot of new things. Atomic Energy merit badges went out of style.
About 20 years later, at the end of the 01970s, the costs of building new nuclear reactors started to skyrocket, which is another way of saying that our productivity at building nuclear reactors started to collapse.
I just read Atlas Shrugged, which tells a story of a technological society strangled by regulation, unpredictable kleptocracy, and a brain drain ("draining the brains", the book said, 6 years before the Royal Society coined the term "brain drain"). This aspect of the book resonated with me, although many others did not, perhaps in part because I live in Argentina, whose technological development is strangled by regulation, unpredictable kleptocracy, and a brain drain, though the brain drain is to the US and Europe rather than to a secret conspiracy. We had a famous fusion energy program, Project Huemul, which turned out to be a scam.
I wonder if the same thing happened to nuclear engineering? Maybe the potential Tellers and Freeman Dysons born in the 01960s and later never got involved in nuclear physics, except for David Hahn, who ended up with paranoid schizophrenia after his mother committed suicide, and died at 39 of an overdose of opiates. Maybe nuclear engineering had a brain drain to electrical engineering, computer science, and related fields.
- rackjack 5y agoAtlas Shrugged actually being applicable to your situation is interesting.
- kragen 5y agoNot, I hasten to add, in numerous other ways. I only mentioned the similarities.
- aidenn0 5y agoI think the fact that kleptocracy, brain-drain and mis-regulation are real problems are part of the reason for the (relative) popularity of objectivism. You can't get people to buy into your solution until you get them to buy into the problem.
- roenxi 5y agoIt is really noticeable in talk on solar prices that the learning curve for nuclear tech is negative. Ie, nuclear plants get more expensive as technology improves. The odds of that being a natural effect are minuscule. Something is strangling innovation and it is probably some piece of regulation. It is a bit grim but I suppose we're looking to places like India and China for the next big waves of innovation in nuclear energy.
- sien 5y agoSouth Korea had reducing nuclear construction costs. https://thebreakthrough.org/articles/historical-construction-costs-of-global-nuclear-power-reactors https://thebreakthrough.org/articles/historical-construction...
- kragen 5y agoOther cases where this seems to have happened include pacemakers; hearing aids; supersonic jets; ocean-liner trips; small planes (e.g., Cessnas); mercury; chemistry sets; most vacuum tubes; hovercraft; bubble memory (and more generally SSDs that don't die from read disturb); Gyrojet guns; brass vacuum fittings; ebonite; and old-growth lumber. If you limit yourself to just US production, you can apparently add things like microcontrollers; many kinds of machine tools; ventilators; Nixie tubes; and N95 respirators. I don't think it's grim at all that India and China are having big waves of nuclear innovation, but I don't think they stand much of a chance against solar except for niche applications until there's a total manufacturing revolution.
- psd1 5y agoI don't believe a dicky-bird from the UK govt until I see the evidence, but they have announced support for adding new nuclear capacity, with RR in the frame. Turns out that wattage isn't fungible, 24/7 is worth a premium, and land has value.
- voldacar 5y agoI highly recommend giving the book "Where is my flying car?" a read. It is a very idiosyncratic and unconventional book, written by an engineer rather than an academic. He goes into great depth about how the FAA and NRC basically deliberately killed general aviation and nuclear energy, how this happened, and its implications regarding the "great stagnation" and the future of tech.
- dredmorbius 5y agoTechnology is a verb. Technologies are means to ends, so that technologies act on some precursor to produce a result. Or rather, sets of results. All technologies include a combination of intended and unintended consequences, of greater or lesser apparance (or manifestation), occurring nor or far in time, and with greater or lesser ease in explaining or describing. Positive consequences of technologies exhibit diminishing returns in most cases (networked / dendritic mechanisms are the exception). We see leaps where new specific techniques, materials, fuels, or processes are first applied, but then virtually always a decline in further growth. Even network-based technologies are subject to various impedences and at best grow more slowly than naive models (e.g., Metcalfe) would suggest. And as technologies become established and embedded within processes, practices, institutions, and cultures, dependencies develop such that interactions are more complex. Which is a long wind-up to this: in time, the early prompt-positive impacts of technolgies are dominated by both prompt- and delayed-negative impacts. Pollution, corrosion, health effects, disruption, cognitive overload, and fragility amongst them. Early nuclear designs could focus on the simple and immediate. Longer-term projects had to take into consideration additional concerns: the effects of fuels, waste products, and radiation on materials themselves, natural disaster risks, the frailties of human organisations (a major factor in the four major commercial plant accidents, and countless minor ones), containment, economics, and more. Early visions of running unshielded reactors to power aircraft proved ... slightly less than viable. Maybe it's not fun. Maybe it requires a more mature mind. Maybe the layers of bureaucracy and politics and checks and balances that evolve, even if suffering from their own dysfunctions, have to be there. And can only do so much. Galt is an adolescent fantasy, not a model for the real world.
- kragen 5y agoI don't believe in technology, just technological development. I don't believe technologies exist in an ontologically useful sense, much less that they have positive or negative consequences. Artifacts, knowledge, praxis, and social arrangements have consequences, not technologies. Nothing is required except death; nothing but death has to be there. Everything else is contingent: it will happen or not, depending on historical circumstances. If we want nuclear reactors that aren't dangerous, we should explore what circumstances could give rise to that result. Our current path evidently isn't it, and maybe we should find out why not. Galt is of course a fantasy; in the real world, the people Rand admired so much died in GULAG around the time she escaped Russia. Galt was a power fantasy about rescuing them. But some other things in the novel happen in the real world: people do build railroads, develop new metal alloys, and succumb to brain drains. And, interestingly, fields of knowledge do sometimes fall into decline. Maybe the reason in this case is a variant of the reason she fantasized about in the book; maybe not.
- Alekhine 5y agoWhy are you writing dates with an extra zero in front?
- balsam 5y agoI would have thought he is a crackpot of the Germanic variety (hyper “rational”) of Argentine extraction... but there is such a thing as Long Now Years https://blog.longnow.org/02013/12/31/long-now-years-five-digit-dates-and-10k-compliance-at-home/ https://blog.longnow.org/02013/12/31/long-now-years-five-dig...
- kragen 5y agoWell, at least you got the "crackpot" part right :)
- olau 5y agoI think you need to be careful here. There's this trope going on in circles of people who love nuclear tech that expensive plants are just expensive because of X, where X can be environmentalists, government bureaucrats, old, bad designs (e.g. too large, or not using thorium, or not using molten salt, insert pet design issue here), lack of subsidy (e.g. government backed loans), etc. While there's probably some truth to it, I think it's ignoring the elephant in the room, that nuclear tech is just really difficult to get right, and that the bar has been upped as the nuclear engineering community has learned about new failure modes. Also, I think there's widespread agreement that current nuclear tech needs an oversight committee, just like aircraft tech. Even if it's incompatible with regulation nihilism.
- kragen 5y agoWell, I think the cost for converting thermal energy into electricity is high enough to make thermal energy uncompetitive with PV in most of the world, regardless of its source. So nuclear is unlikely to make a comeback unless there's a revolution (heh) in making steam turbines. I'm not sure why they're so much more expensive than coal plants, though, and I don't think "really difficult to get right" is an adequate reason; the first nuclear reactor was successfully built on a shoestring budget with technology that is now 79 years old. 79 years ago, lasers, jet airliners, artificial satellites, LEDs, lithium-ion batteries, pacemakers, antilock brakes, organ transplants, strong carbon fibers, high-pressure sodium lights, programmable computers, and bulletproof polymers were not just "really difficult to get right" but actually not yet achieved. Vast improvements have been made in many relevant technologies, including control systems, electronics, materials science and engineering, mathematical simulation, metrology, materials processing, heat engines, construction, and of course nuclear physics, not only since the Chicago Pile 1 but even since the end of the last wave of nuclear-power-plant construction in the US 40 years ago. I think it's totally plausible that the reason is that the right people (both investors and hackers) fled the field at the thought of having an "oversight committee" with veto power over their work, no incentive to not veto it, and either no experience designing nuclear plants, or experience doing so as employees of their competitors. I don't think that amounts to "regulation nihilism". Do naval reactors have the same problem?