3 ms·
The point of safety margins is the risk reward ratio is heavily weighted in one direction. 150 is flat out not worth the risk from a public health standpoint.
by Retric 5y ago
The point of safety margins is the risk reward ratio is heavily weighted in one direction. 150 is flat out not worth the risk from a public health standpoint.
Sous vide is nowhere near as safe as many assume. Many spores and some pathogens can survive the process and people with compromised immune systems should seriously avoid eating such food especially if it’s been refrigerated before consumption.
- phonypc 5y ago>150 is flat out not worth the risk from a public health standpoint. It's not worth the risk for public health agencies to recommend 150°, that I can agree on. Too much room for inexperienced cooks to make an error. But chicken held at 150° for a few minutes (which is hard to avoid in most scenarios) is no less safe than the hypothetical "165° for an instant" scenario.
- Retric 5y agoThe problem is not just with the cook, how accurate is your equipment? +/- 4f is likely good enough at 165. +/- 4f at 150 or much worse 130 can be a serious issue. Now it’s not big deal what you do in your own kitchen, but people recommending such practices to a wide audience have real responsibility.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>150 is flat out not worth the risk from a public health standpoint. Im not sure what this means. What is the risk-reward being evaluated to see if it is worth it?
- Retric 5y agoHigher quality meals on one side vs the risk of serious food born illnesses and death on the other.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI should have been a lot more specific in my comment. I'm not really convinced that this is a case for the application of that type of risk benefit analysis. Public health guidance should be (and is?) instructions for how to produce reliably safe food. Is shouldn't be (and isn't?) guidance for what the tradeoff should be between risk and pleasure. The latter is entirely subjective and up to individuals. This is why you can go out to a public restaurant and get chicken sashimi if you want.[1] https://duckduckgo.com/?q=chicken+sashimi&t=h_&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=chicken+sashimi&t=h_&ia=web
- fomine3 5y agoduckduckgo looks pretty legit domain to search chicken :D Chicken sashimi is almost (but not in law) prohibited (except limited area) by Japanese health center but it still served because of those restaurants are stupid. They constantly produce ill customer. To be fair, most restaurants won't serve raw chickens. Speaking about limited area, Kyushu produces very clean chickens that considered to very low risk to eat in raw (Torisashi). They are allowed by local health center.
- phonypc 5y ago>This is why you can go out to a public restaurant and get chicken sashimi if you want.[1] You actually can't do that, with very few exceptions.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIs it illegal? Looking around online people say you can get it at restaurants in SF and LA. Maybe it is an illegal off menu item.
- Retric 5y agoRelevant bits in CA Page 37, you can serve unsafe food in California as long as you notify people doing so is unsafe. Though these are minimum legal requirements, you can still get sued over the practice. “A raw animal food such as raw egg, raw fish, raw marinated fish, raw molluscan shellfish, or steak tartare, or a partially cooked food such as lightly cooked fish, soft cooked eggs, or rare meat other than whole-muscle, intact beef steaks as specified in subdivision (c), may be served or offered for sale upon consumer request or selection in a ready-to-eat form if either of the following conditions are satisfied: (1) All of the following requirements are met: (A) As specified in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 114091, the food facility serves a population that is not a highly susceptible population. (B) The food, if served or offered for service by consumer selection from a children’s menu, does not contain comminuted meat. (C) The consumer is informed pursuant to Section 114093 to ensure its safety, the food should be cooked as specified in subdivision (a) or (b). (2) The department grants a variance from subdivision (a) or (b) pursuant to Section 114417 based on a HACCP plan that satisfies all of the following conditions: (A) It is submitted by the permitholder and approved pursuant to Sections 114417.1 and 114417.3. (B) It documents scientific data or other information showing that a lesser time and temperature regimen results in safe food. (C) It verifies that equipment and procedures for food prepared and training of food employees at the food facility meet the conditions of the variance.” https://www.cdph.ca.gov/Programs/CEH/DFDCS/CDPH%20Document%20Library/FDB/FoodSafetyProgram/RetailFood/CRFC.pdf?TSPD_101_R0=087ed344cfab2000281891e5251e8b5a0c6d6b17921210ae20196669bce0dd64210f58fc605cfe75088a40e434143000d574c7f68ff31206ddd69be0c297bb8b2c13294940c2409ac127c7675bece280e6a694c7d0e32e047dec5a16f8d59dc3#page34 https://www.cdph.ca.gov/Programs/CEH/DFDCS/CDPH%20Document%2...