3 ms·
The places that can weather climate change well will be overrun by refugees from poorer countries that can't. For most first world countries the first order ef
by wongarsu 5y ago
The places that can weather climate change well will be overrun by refugees from poorer countries that can't.
For most first world countries the first order effects are mostly a drag on infrastructure costs and costs of living. Even absurd things like damming in the entire North Sea to protect against sea level rise are viable with enough political will [1]. But places that can't afford that will lose population centers to sea level rise, will be unable to produce enough water for drinking and agriculture, or just become too hot in the summer months to be livable without AC everywhere. And all those people won't just keel over and die, they will have the same thought you just expressed.
1: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/feb/12/giant-dams-could-protect-millions-from-rising-north-sea https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/feb/12/giant-da...
- PeterisP 5y agoWhat I hear in your words is essentially an argument that it would be prudent to invest in arms manufacturers, as their products are obviously going to have an increased demand in the world-after-warming.
- skyfaller 5y agoInvesting in arms manufacturers could also hasten the end of civilization and possibly cause human extinction. Although the climate crisis is dire, I do not think that climate change alone is likely to kill us all. Resource wars that result from the climate crisis, however, I think could finish off humanity. Arms manufacturers do what they can to increase the likelihood of war. Not to mention that militaries produce disproportionate amounts of greenhouse gases. I mean, arms manufacturing is blood money even in "ordinary" times, but it takes another level of self-destructive evil to attempt to profit off the apocalypse.
- shrimpx 5y agoProfiting off the apocalypse is exactly what’s happening in the fossil fuel-based industries isn’t it? It may not look like the apocalypse until the last minute.
- PeterisP 5y agoIt's not about profiting, it's about what your community needs. If you are one of "all those people won't just keel over and die" (as the grandparent post states), then your community will need arms to, well, not just keel over and die. The same applies for any community that might get overrun by their neighbours - if global warming is going to bring on resource conflicts, if you refuse to be prepared and armed as a deterrant, then you will be inviting violence to your home as you will be an attractive victim. Sic pace, para bellum is an ancient principle that's relevant whenever a contest for resources becomes meaningful; so the point in investing in arms companies is not about profit, but about ensuring that your community suffers less in the coming turndown; you and your community will not get a "fair share" of dwindling resources just by existing (that's hard enough even in times of plenty with less motivation to compete for basic resources), it will get only as much as its strength allows.
- scohesc 5y agoI think the climate crisis will cause new companies to emerge and make technologies and ideas to harvest these minerals that are now unavailable with current technologies. Coincidentally, it's going to be deep-water oil drilling that has the most capability of helping technology-wise in this future.
- Zababa 5y ago> The places that can weather climate change well will be overrun by refugees from poorer countries that can't. That feels like an argument to convince people to do something rather than what will actually happen. A bit like "there is no escape, FIGHT NOW!".
- wongarsu 5y agoThat's not really a counter argument. But yes, the conclusion would be to either do something before it's too late or to go to a self-sufficient colony on Mars. There's plenty of other angles that support this, whether that's melting permafrost or the studies that calculate that limiting climate change now is far cheaper than mitigating the consequences later.
- Zababa 5y agoIt's not a counter argument, but more of a questioning of your argument. I think it's an argument of the same type as Pascal's Wager, though more based on reality. I don't think that there will be no places with a good climate and no refugees, at least that depends on what you consider a "place". Maybe no countries, I could agree with that, and even for that, you could argue that island countries could easily block refugees. All of that to say, it feels like you're saying to people "either you fight climate change, or you will get refugees", while in real life that's not really what will happen, I think. I don't think you're completely wrong, but for example the average person can't really run away from refugees, but also can't make a difference in fighting climate change, so many of them will probably fight climate change and get refugees; while a very rich person can change more things but also run away more easily.
- yongjik 5y agoDepends on what one means by "overrun" - people talk about the European migrant crisis of 2015, with 1.3 million refugees in a year. With climate change, even 100 million is not out of question - it will put a severe strain on every affected country, to put it mildly.