3 ms·
"Three University of Florida professors were denied permission from the school to testify in a major voting rights case " What the fuck is 'permission to testi
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
"Three University of Florida professors were denied permission from the school to testify in a major voting rights case "
What the fuck is 'permission to testify'? I thought access to justice was a constitutional right. If you can't get anyone to tesrify, then you have no access to justice.
We have surrendered so many rights in various contracts, we hardly have any freedoms left.
- brazzledazzle 5y agoI find it fascinating that the supreme court has upheld the ability to forgo so many purportedly inalienable rights via contract.
- mullen 5y agoWell, you did voluntary signed a Contract. As part of a commercial exchange, you agree to do and do not certain things for money. Inalienable Rights can't be signed away, so the argument that you are signing away Inalienable Rights really does not hold water.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoI need person X to teatify so that I don't go to jail, and I never signed a contract. Also, did amazom workers voluntarily sign up to pee in bottles?
- JaceLightning 5y agoYes
- brazzledazzle 5y agoCorrect me if I’m wrong but it seems to me that confining yourself to civil judgement via private arbitration removes your rights.
- colejohnson66 5y agoIt’s worth remembering that arbitration is actually a common enough practice outside of employment. Any divorce involving “mediation” is arbitration, and both parties agreed to it. The disconnect comes when the person “suggesting” arbitration (the employer) is in a position of power.
- FireBeyond 5y agoIf mediation is unsuccessful, neither party has lost or waived the right to a court appearance, so your analogy doesn't hold. Mediation in divorce is a cost-saving measure often required by the court.
- colejohnson66 5y agoThat's a very valid point. That's why I think employer (or TOS) mandated arbitration are ridiculous. I should have the option of disputing the arbitration result by default, but many clauses say that the arbitration result is binding and that you have no other recourse.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI agree but I believe the Supreme Court does not, which would imply to me that they do not believe any right that can be signed away is inalienable - although I also expect they would never say this outright.
- specialist 5y agoI've recently been disabused of the quaint notion that our Supreme Court's job is to make findings of law. https://www.fivefourpod.com https://www.fivefourpod.com
- ska 5y ago> What the fuck is 'permission to testify'? I suspect this means to function as a (voluntary) expert witness, not as someone formally required to testify.
- nickff 5y agoThe professors were looking to make money by testifying against the interests of their employer's parent organization: >"the university denied requests of these full-time employees to undertake outside paid work that is adverse to the university's interests as a state of Florida institution." This seems reasonable to me; if they want to testify to express themselves, they can still do it pro-bono, otherwise, they should probably seek non-government employment.
- iudqnolq 5y agoThe supreme court has historically taken a more nuanced stance on this sort of issue than you. Broadly speaking in the US everyone has many constitutional protections against the government restricting them in certain ways. When you become a government employee you give up only the most narrow subset of the protections necessary for the government to effectively be your boss. This means the professors have a reasonably strong court case as mentioned by their lawyer in TFA. See for example https://www.popehat.com/2013/09/05/ninth-circuit-clarifies-first-amendment-rights-of-public-university-professors/ https://www.popehat.com/2013/09/05/ninth-circuit-clarifies-f... > First a court must determine whether or not the speech is on a matter of public interest. Speech on matters of public interest are entitled to protection, even when uttered by employees; speech on purely private matters (like, say, a private and internal spat among employees) is not. Then the court must balance the employer's interest in an orderly and efficient workplace against the speech rights of the employee, taking into account things like whether the speech restriction is content-based (that is, whether it censors some viewpoints but not others), the circumstances of the speech, the strength of the employee's interest in the speech, whether the speech genuinely disrupts discipline and order and interferes with relationships, and so on.
- nickff 5y agoThe critical question here is whether the University is restricting alternate employment or speech. It seems reasonable that a full-time employee on salary be prohibited from accepting simultaneous alternative employment in their primary field of work.