6 ms·
Like every single article on the subject, the author fails to propose an alternate credential system that will replace college. Will some academics (like the au
by keiferski 15y ago
Like every single article on the subject, the author fails to propose an alternate credential system that will replace college. Will some academics (like the author) lose their jobs to technology? Probably, but that has little to do with the credential aspect of a degree.
- tptacek 15y agoOutside of The Professions, where is college an effective credential system? College is clearly not that important in our field. Even at the companies that most famously do use degrees as selection criteria, the requirement is trivially circumvented with the right work experience.
- keiferski 15y agoOutside of the silicon valley/ tech industry, it's impossible to get a decent job without a degree.
- tptacek 15y agoYou mean except in trading, sales, marketing, and management of those fields and technology? Like I said: outside the Professions, where is the degree an absolute requirement? A degree is necessary to be an accountant, a lawyer, a doctor, or an (non-computing) engineer. But that's a small slice of the overall workforce. And sure, especially in the Fortune 1000, companies strongly consider degrees even outside the professions. But I guarantee you that success in (say) sales has almost nothing to do with the degree (or lack thereof) you start with, and management of sales teams has everything to do with prior sales success.
- keiferski 15y agoYou can't get a job as a secretary without a degree these days. There is a bubble in Silicon Valley, but it's not an economic one...
- tptacek 15y agoYeah I think you're just wrong.
- cosgroveb 15y agoI have a friend at a Fortune 500 where I used to work who started working as an administrative assistant (secretary) and now 4 years later is a project manager and is making more than I did as a fresh out of college as a junior dev. She only has a high school diploma. I can think of at least three other similar examples at the same financial institution. There are lots of ways into "real" jobs without a degree if you're smart and you find the right path into the career you want (obviously this does not work for professions with licensing bodies).
- forkandwait 15y agoThere might be verbiage like "B.A. or equivalent experience" on the description, but if it is a managerial position I think 90% is B.A, 10% is equivalent experience. So, there may be no literal requirement, but there is still a de facto requirement. Sales may be an exception here -- though I would hazard a guess that to sell software for IBM to governments and businesses, my above comment would apply. To sell real estate, though, nobody really cares (same for cars, etc).
- tptacek 15y agoGetting hired externally into a management role probably does require a degree, but many of these positions are filled internally, and if you are (e.g.) a star sales account manager or responsible for the company's most successful marketing program, the degree is probably a non-issue when you bid for the promotion.
- forkandwait 15y agoEvidence? Seems plausible or common knowledge, but lots of wrong things seem plausible or common knowledge (remember Columbus and falling off the side of the earth?)
- rdouble 15y agoIt seems to work ok for subjects like chemistry, biological sciences, and other engineering disciplines.
- timsally 15y agoYou can't perform experiments in chemistry or material science on a laptop. The practice oriented classes in these fields often require facilities and equipment that are too expensive for individuals to purchase. Hence why in those fields college credentials is a variable with r > 0 for on the job competence. In contrast, it costs about $600 dollars in computer equipment and used books in order to get started in programming or security. The security industry in particular reflects this. Over half of the guys running top security companies either don't have a degree or have one from a highly technical college. Hell, the guy running cyber security research for the government has a music degree.
- forkandwait 15y agoGetting a job as a mid-level manager in government service is very difficult without a degree, unless you are old enough to grandfather in when things were different. And even if you do get a job, there will be a noticeable level of weirdness around you because you didn't finish college. Note that you don't have to go to a particularly good school -- it is government service, after all. I think a similar thing is true -- I would be interested in knowing how many people at supervisor or above at, say, Netflix (or an oil company) don't have a degree? I don't know... hopefully other people can share anecdotal evidence ;)
- tptacek 15y agoOne tricky thing about this is that demographically, most people that end up in "white collar" jobs do get degrees. But I think that's post-hoc evidence for the implied requirement of a degree. Those same people might have done just as well (or even better, considering the 4 years opportunity cost of a degree) without college.
- forkandwait 15y agoI don't think you have any real evidence for whether the association of white-collar job and degree is post-hoc or not? Do you? Without evidence, it's kind of a cheap shot.
- tptacek 15y agoI don't think we need to cite sources to suggest that white collar jobs tend to be filled by people above the socioeconomic median, or the fact that the same demographic cohort overwhelmingly tends to go to college. The middle class goes to university (a) because it's a default, (b) because it's part of the middle class lifestyle, and (c) because it's perceived as necessary for a career. Only 1/3rd of those reasons are about credentials.† Stipulating the fact that jobs are just statistically going to be filled by people who automatically got degrees, I don't think it's a stretch (or a cheap shot) to suggest that the relationship between jobs and school is tenuous. Moreover, given the fact that white collar jobs in large companies tend to be managed conservatively, and the fact that people without degrees are outliers (because almost every applicant for any job went to college by default), some of the "credentialing effect" of a degree is actually just an observational bias. † Note also the preponderance of college attendees who attain degrees that are almost objectively without credentialing merit, such as the liberal arts.†† †† "Without credentialing merit" being intended as an objective statement and not as an argument that people shouldn't get liberal arts degrees; I think most degrees are without credentialing merit.