3 ms·
> The most fundamental piece of applicable psychology is the idea that you are responsible for your own thoughts, feelings, and actions, period. You are respons
by sofixa 5y ago
> The most fundamental piece of applicable psychology is the idea that you are responsible for your own thoughts, feelings, and actions, period. You are responsible for making yourself happy, for asserting yourself, for setting any boundaries you choose. People on Twitter can just block, or mute, or turn off their DMs for people they don't follow. What's wrong with that? Now there's a human right to use Twitter unhindered? They just spent the last decade telling us there wasn't!
You should try telling this to those who get abused online. I think people who regularly get rape threats and racial abuse, many of whom are calling for such legislation ( recently there have been numerous cases with black footballers and also some with female journalists), have a slightly higher priority than people who just want to insult freely without fear of consequences. Considering people have committed suicide over online harassment, it's not as simple as "just block the baddies".
- sokoloff 5y agoWe already have a crime of assault (as distinct from battery or rape). A credible threat is already a crime of assault and that’s as it should be. “<Foobar> is a poopyhead”, even if it provokes an outsized negative reaction on Foobar’s part, is nowhere near the same thing.
- sofixa 5y agoSomeone hurling racial slurs on Twitter or sending rape threats, from the comfort of their home without any credibility, isn't a "credible threat", but isn't insignificant.
- chrismcb 5y agoSomeone hurling racial slurs is not the same as someone sending rape threats
- skinkestek 5y agoIt is also already now punishable by existing, sane laws in many countries.
- mdavis6890 5y agoWe currently (in the US, anyway) have laws against harassment and threats. They may not be well-enforced, but we do have those laws. Adding additional, vague laws will not help with enforcement, but it would open the door for authorities to prosecute lower and lower levels of 'harmful' behavior which go well beyond what you would want. The solution is to crack down hard on the real harm, based on the many laws we already have on the books.
- kradeelav 5y agoI can't speak for more than myself, but here's an alternative viewpoint: as a female that fits into other undisclosed minorities, and as an erotic artist who regularly gets threats (comes with the package) - I am far more afraid of the consequences of this dystopian line of thinking than I am of the occasional hate mobs. There are tools out there to deal with mobs/threats, even if it's unpleasant, but giving puritans a legal leverage to take down my art (and anyone who's creative work is remotely controversial) is going to wreck an unholy amount of damage. The typical line of attack is claiming that our art is "harmful" because of BDSM content, and the proposed legistlation would just reinforce that. I feel like you mean the best in your heart, but would encourage anyone to think deeply before white knighting for minorities. A lot of times well meaning laws can have disastrous consequences in smothering less-powerful voices (laws against "immoral" content referring to anything sexual online regularly making things worse for actual sex workers, for instance). The ACLU has a long list of historical incidences where "legal" censorship ended up hurting civil rights activists, queer activists and creatives, and too many other groups to name.
- sofixa 5y ago> I feel like you mean the best in your heart, but would encourage anyone to think deeply before white knighting for minorities. A lot of times well meaning laws can have disastrous consequences in smothering less-powerful voices (laws against "immoral" content referring to anything sexual online regularly making things worse for actual sex workers, for instance). The ACLU has a long list of historical incidences where "legal" censorship ended up hurting civil rights activists, queer activists and creatives, and too many other groups to name. Absolutely, especially in clown shitfests like the UK. That doesn't mean people who enjoy racially abusing teenagers on Twitter should just be left to do so. There's a middle ground between banning anything anyone might deem "offensive" (like erotica or BDSM) and the wild west.
- Levitz 5y ago>I think people who regularly get rape threats and racial abuse, many of whom are calling for such legislation ( recently there have been numerous cases with black footballers and also some with female journalists), have a slightly higher priority than people who just want to insult freely without fear of consequences. They don't have higher priority than the rest of society, which enjoy an important lack of authoritarianism in this regard. It's not about wanting to insult freely, but about the right to offend.
- sofixa 5y ago> A person's freedom ends where another man's freedom begins I don't know why you think your freedom to offend/insult is higher than another person's freedom to not be offended/insulted.
- chrismcb 5y agoNo one has a freedom to not be offended. It they did, then it would be impossible to have free speech. As there is no way to know if your speech won't offend everyone.
- sokoloff 5y agoI think inherent in the right to speak is the possibility to say things which risk some other person experiencing (or claiming) offense. Perhaps I claim to be genuinely offended/insulted by speech in the form of a haiku. You can’t prove that my claimed offense/insult is not genuine, yet it would be ridiculous to ban such speech or prosecute it. I think there is therefore a necessary middle ground of speech which is legal but for which someone claims it offends them. If it offends some people, see xkcd 1357. https://xkcd.com/1357/ https://xkcd.com/1357/
- kofejnik 5y agoI was deeply hurt and insulted by your comment, please delete it immediately and stop posting on the internets!
- msla 5y agoThis proposed law is discriminatory against autistic people (of which I am one) and, possibly, other people who, due to difficulty in reading a room or difficulty in self-censoring or difficulty in separating fact from imagination, might say or post offensive things without intending to cause hurt. (Or, maybe, without intending to hurt anyone who actually exists, as opposed to their imagined enemies.) I could also add that it's discriminatory against people who were raised in certain environments, but I've noticed that "They were raised that way" isn't seen as a valid defense, as it's apparently viewed as axiomatic that everyone has a chance to revise all of their implicit biases before posting to Twitter.