4 ms·
> Seems civics in the US are about to be rigged for one party rule. The good news is that it doesn't actually work that way. First past the post results in a t
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Seems civics in the US are about to be rigged for one party rule.
The good news is that it doesn't actually work that way. First past the post results in a two party system. Nobody can gerrymander that away.
Drawing the lines different affects what party platforms need to be in order to get half of the seats, but there will still be two parties and they will still each control the government half of the time.
Which isn't to say that it doesn't matter, but the thing it does is different than the thing you think it does. Even the party drawing the lines is reshaping what they'll need their own positions to be in order to win.
If you really want to fix it, replace first past the post with range voting. Good luck gerrymandering that. Might even solve polarization by getting rid of the poles.
- mcherm 5y ago> First past the post results in a two party system. Nobody can gerrymander that away. Really? Consider the Democratic party lock on the US southern states for roughly 50 years after reconstruction.[1] A huge portion of the population wasn't permitted to vote (despite laws on the books being racially blind, most blacks were prevented from voting in many of these states up until the passage of the Voting Rights Act. And even among those who DID vote, a single party remained utterly dominant. Does this counterexample mean anything to you? (PS: I agree with you that I'm strongly in favor of changes to our voting system to move away from first-past-the-post and government gerrymandering. But I'm NOT going to claim that single party rule is impossible when there are hundreds of examples of it across the world.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solid_South https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solid_South
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Consider the Democratic party lock on the US southern states for roughly 50 years after reconstruction. Yet each party still controlled the government around half of the time, because the Republicans took the North. Each party will change the amount necessary to flip the marginal district. The districts in the South were harder for Republicans to flip than some others, so they took ones it was easier for them to get, and didn't take the ones they didn't need. > But I'm NOT going to claim that single party rule is impossible when there are hundreds of examples of it across the world. The rest of the world uses different voting systems (or lack thereof). There was "single party rule" in the USSR and it wasn't because of gerrymandering.
- OrvalWintermute 5y ago> Yet each party still controlled the government around half of the time, because the Republicans took the North. That is not correct. Counting the House, the Senate, and the Presidency individually: Republicans had control of 52 time periods, compared to the Democrats 23. Based on a starting point & ending of the following: 44th (1875–1877) 45th (1877–1879) 46th (1879–1881) 47th (1881–1883) 48th (1883–1885) 49th (1885–1887) 50th (1887–1889) 51st (1889–1891) 52nd (1891–1893) 53rd (1893–1895) 54th (1895–1897) 55th (1897–1899) 56th (1899–1901) 57th (1901–1903) 58th (1903–1905) 59th (1905–1907) 60th (1907–1909) 61st (1909–1911) 62nd (1911–1913) 63rd (1913–1915) 64th (1915–1917) 65th (1917–1919) 66th (1919–1921) 67th (1921–1923) 68th (1923–1925) 69th (1925–1927)
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoSure, elections aren't that frequent and then you get large variation because the sample size is small. Notice that your stopping point is just before FDR and Truman (both Democrats) held the Presidency for 20 years straight, which was still before the South stopped going for the Democrats.