6 ms·
It's definitely about more than just national security. BT was explicitly pressured to remove "dumb" components that were thoroughly vetted after they'd started
by pydry 5y ago
It's definitely about more than just national security. BT was explicitly pressured to remove "dumb" components that were thoroughly vetted after they'd started removing smart components where surveillance risk was higher.
At no point was any surveillance detected on any kit.
Removing it all (as opposed to just the "smart" kit) is extremely costly and if security was the real concern, not worth it.
They did bug the african congress but they were invited to set everything up in that building and nobody paid attention to anything they installed.
I suspect it's an attempt to wage "economic" warfare. Under WTO rules national security is a virtual get out of jail free card for protectionism. Huawei had just recently proven that China can overtake western technological capabilities in a key industry. That's the point when America flinched.
It also explains why they bullied all their allies into taking out all the tech all at the same time after years of seeminglh not being concerned about their own networks (let alone their allies) and without any evidence of a breach or anything.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI personally feel it is a pro-rated cost. I completely understand in China doesn't want to add US technology to their critical infrastructure and I hope China understands the practicality of it. It's a one time sunk cost, we would have to do it at some point. We aren't waging economic warfare as this is a tiny amount of trade that happens between the USA and China, if your theory was correct we would be doing it in all industries.
- roody15 5y agoI think you are correct here that this is a more a economic move than national security. The truth is Huawei networks switches and routers are equal to if not are better than equivalent Cisco devices. Cisco just cannot compete at this price point IMO.
- kube-system 5y agoThat national security concerns about Huawei equipment has nothing to do with the quality of the equipment. The issue is whether the vendor can be trusted in hypothetical scenarios in the future. If the US implements all Huawei equipment, and China sanctions the US from receiving support/updates/parts from Huawei (or worse, go to war and use it as a weapon), then the US telecommunication infrastructure is at risk.
- uap 5y agoSo if it is true that this is economics not security, what was offered or threatened to coordinate action across all the countries sending Huawei away? Mass population is moved by fear, but is that how concordance is manufactured across the executives of a set of countries: a few terrifying top-secret presentations, and IC has successfully reputation-assassinated a foreign company? Why would these countries agree if there was no breach and a cheaper price? What offer or threat besides a more expensive but more secure infra? I suppose if you view telcoinfra as defense assets then it's a no-brainer, but was this the calculus? Blackmail/Mafioso-tactics would be a good one, maybe: You have to buy from us, or we will reveal/do such-and-such horrible thing. But if it's true this is economic, not security, and also that Huawei has superior value for money, then is it not just these countries accelerating their already decaying infrastructure, for the sake of pride? "The phones are down." "Yeah, whaddayagonnado? At least we're not paying the Chinese to make them work." Replace phones with other critical things China makes better for a better price, and the future of these countries may look like the past of the former-Soviet ones: a whole bunch of weird anachronistic tech resulting from an (in this case self-imposed) embargo. But at least it will be 100% built by subjects of approved countries. I suppose that is one strategy to fight back against the dominance of Chinese industry: just outlaw it. The hilarious thing is, probably all these "approved suppliers" will have to purchase significant inventory from what is essentially Huawei's supply chain anyway. Seems much more like the tail wagging the dog, with corporate dishonesty dictating so-called natsec policy. Could it really be so twisted?
- pessimizer 5y ago> Mass population is moved by fear, but is that how concordance is manufactured across the executives of a set of countries: a few terrifying top-secret presentations, and IC has successfully reputation-assassinated a foreign company? Why would these countries agree if there was no breach and a cheaper price? What offer or threat besides a more expensive but more secure infra? I suppose if you view telcoinfra as defense assets then it's a no-brainer, but was this the calculus? Blackmail/Mafioso-tactics would be a good one, maybe: You have to buy from us, or we will reveal/do such-and-such horrible thing. Governments don't operate exclusively through sticks. The US has plenty of carrots to give out.
- 5y ago
- tcbawo 5y agoI have first hand knowledge of IP theft by Huawei dating back more than 15 years. It's not surprising they can outclass competitors on price over the long term. Perhaps this behavior should not be rewarded?
- mountainb 5y agoWe don't have jurisdiction over China. There is no such thing as IP theft across state lines without both states agreeing to recognize it as such. Even among countries that do recognize it, it's an insane kludge of treaty and the independent operation of fundamentally incompatible legal systems which can only reach within states themselves and tend to bump into serious obstacles whenever they try to reach across state lines. Most major corporations deal with this by just registering IP in multiple jurisdictions simultaneously and litigating internationally, which can also be done in China just as you would do it in France or the UK. Redundancy is easier to manage than cross-border cooperation with foreign court orders.
- jaywalk 5y ago>There is no such thing as IP theft across state lines That may be true in the strictest legal sense when a Chinese company is the one doing the stealing from a Western corporation. But in reality, that's so laughably incorrect that it makes me question why you said it.
- BTCOG 5y agoExactly. And to put it in clearer terms, they have been continuously hacking into Western companies for 20 years and stealing design schematics and counterfeiting them. I'm sure you'd be cool with a Chinese APT rooting your servers and stealing all that you have in your company?
- mountainb 5y agoIt's a simple statement of fact that the United States has no jurisdictional authority over the actions Chinese citizens take in China against American citizens and vice versa. This is a serious problem for reasons such as this, but you cannot refute it as a basic statement of reality. Put simply, American courts have no authority over Chinese in China, Chinese courts have no authority over Americans in the US, and our courts do not cooperate reciprocally as they do in other countries with alternative diplomatic and legal relations.
- bobbybabylon 5y agoOne of the things I have never seen, is an original source that details the type of attack that was done on the African National Congress HQ in Ethiopia. The only original source I have ever seen is a short piece from (of course) Le Monde. I have never seen a CVE, much less writeup of the attack. We hear that the device was sending uploads to China in the middle of the night. But what type of uploads? And was it firmware based, or OS based? That whole Hussein(-Addis affair just seems very suspect to me.
- mtnGoat 5y agowhy would firmware or OS be UPloading? os and firmware updates come down. no need for a device to be pushing anything at all upstream, IMO.
- bobbybabylon 5y agoI meant a firmware or OS vulnerability. It was claimed that the hack (whatever it was) was send info to China in the middle of the night.
- pydry 5y agoAs I understood it China/Huawei offered to wire up the entire place for free and no other contractor was used. There are 1000 different ways they could have done it. I too would be interested in hearing more though.
- inglor_cz 5y agoFree stuff tends to end up rather expensive eventually... Free software might be an exception, but free hardware equipment really sounds suspicious.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _djo_ 5y agoAfrican Union, not African National Congress. Having spoken to someone involved in the investigation, it really did happen but like anything this politically sensitive it was quickly hushed up to avoid making it more of a diplomatic incident. The AU had tried to prevent the news from leaking in the first place. That's quite typical for espionage, where unless there's a desire to publicly burn a few bridges countries would rather have it handled quietly through regular diplomatic channels.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoI thought the point when America "flinched" was after Australia's intelligence agencies raised concerns that reached the US government.
- tata71 5y ago> Huawei had just recently proven that China can overtake western technological capabilities in a key industry. That's the point when America flinched. Here I was thinking it was because Tony Podesta et al were involved with keeping them clean in the first place!
- optimiz3 5y ago> At no point was any surveillance detected on any kit. All it takes is one firmware update.
- pydry 5y agoHuawei couldn't push updates remotely and firmware updates were vetted.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoAs of March 2019 [1] this vetting was not going very well in the UK. Only one piece of Huawei firmware was even able to achieve "binary equivalence" where the agency could determine that verified source was actually the source for specific firmware running on the device. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/context/huawei-cybersecurity-report/?noteId=2fe1a139-99d8-4d69-b43f-70240792f7e8&questionId=ef4f9469-99e6-4ac0-8371-0d80ec118d3e&utm_term=.c56fb1b20ab3&itid=lk_inline_manual_1 https://www.washingtonpost.com/context/huawei-cybersecurity-...
- pydry 5y agoReproducible builds are incredibly hard to achieve and require a significant amount of resources. Debian has been on this path for ages in a fully open ecosystem and still hasn't fully achieved it. Nobody could doubt their resolve. All it takes is one tiny bit of proprietary software in the build chain that behaves non-deterministically (and they probably have several) and that's it. No equivalence until you rip it out and replace it. That's an expensive ask. I'd be surprised if any vendors have achieved this. Hell, Cisco source code is probably riddled with spyware that they could spot at a glance, but "American IP considerations" 100% trump UK national security so I doubt they'd even get to see the source code. I would love it if all of the vendors were made to have source code reviews and reproducible builds, but being realistic it's a standard that's only be demanded of Huawei. Even if they passed this high bar they'd only find some other excuse to rip them out. Even so, unless you're talking about firmware for complex devices attached to the internet (what BT calls "the core", e.g. routers that they ripped out without much protest) you can still develop reasonable confidence that the firmware isn't exfiltrating sensitive data. If it is simple and it is tightly scoped (e.g. firmware for an aerial) the spyware would have to be very clever and probably pretty obvious, assuming it was even possible. These kinds of devices are where the costs to rip out and replace every bit of hardware also became eye watering.
- bkandel 5y agoI'm not following here. If they bug high-stakes customers when given freedom to operate, why should any country trust anything they build to operate as described? "We'll behave as long as you're looking over our shoulder" doesn't inspire confidence.
- pwillia7 5y agoI mean the phone company bugged my neighbor's house but he let them set up his router so I guess that's fine.
- pydry 5y agoIt's not really a question of trust though is it? Did you really think we blindly trusted every piece of kit they sold us until the US government kicked up a stink? It's a question of eye watering costs of ripping out ALL of the very expensive hardware vs. simply vetting it & ripping out some of the more complex stuff that cant be vetted. Nope. Scorched earth. I have no doubt that they would have already bugged the west if they thought we wouldnt catch them in the act. Which we likely would have. Hence, probably economic, not national security (unless its about america wanting to install its own bugs in which case lord help us).
- larrik 5y agoCan you even vet it, really? All you need is one chip with secret logic inside it, in just a handful of boards, and you are hosed. You'd have to physically inspect every single board, in every single piece of equipment, and even then that's not 100%. Often these devices look completely different inside from lot to lot, due to the way component sourcing works. I think ripping them out is likely much cheaper.
- pydry 5y agoIf it's in the core, to a certain level of confidence, but it's arguably worth ripping it out because of how hard it is to have enough confidence. likewise anything that can address anything else on a network. If it's, say, a radio antenna? yeah, you can. The core was the cheapest and easiest thing to replace. It's the rest - the stuff it would be implausibly difficult to hack while we are watching which is eyewateringly expensive to rip out.
- R0b0t1 5y agoDumb components can still be backdoored.
- Natsu 5y ago> BT was explicitly pressured to remove "dumb" components that were thoroughly vetted after they'd started removing smart components where surveillance risk was higher. You say that as if there haven't been clever spy techniques using crazy things that took ages to detect: https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/584493/soviet-spies-bugged-united-states-seven-years https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/584493/soviet-spies-bugg...
- jcun4128 5y agoThat was a cool read/also wiki on it. No battery
- jimbobimbo 5y agoSurveillance not detected != it's not happening or not going to happen.
- tablespoon 5y ago> At no point was any surveillance detected on any kit. That's not proof of absence... > I suspect it's an attempt to wage "economic" warfare. Under WTO rules national security is a virtual get out of jail free card for protectionism. Huawei had just recently proven that China can overtake western technological capabilities in a key industry. That's the point when America flinched. That is a legitimate national security concern.
- freeflight 5y ago> I suspect it's an attempt to wage "economic" warfare. Under WTO rules national security is a virtual get out of jail free card for protectionism. It's not like the US has to care too much about the WTO as the WTO has effectively been out of business for these past years due to the US blocking the appointment of new appeal judges [0] So even if the WTO rules in favor of China, which it actually did on the steel tariffs [1], all the US needs to do is to appeal the decision and the WTO ruling will be stuck for all eternity in the appeals court, as that can't rule on the appeal without at least three judges. [0] https://www.dw.com/en/wto-judge-blockage-could-prove-the-beginning-of-the-end/a-51613082 https://www.dw.com/en/wto-judge-blockage-could-prove-the-beg... [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/09/15/wto-trump-china-trade/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/09/15/wto-trump...