3 ms·
> The metaverse will have unprecedented interoperability. > This means being able to bring a Fortnite skin into Minecraft and vice versa For the life of me,
by echelon 5y ago
> The metaverse will have unprecedented interoperability.
> This means being able to bring a Fortnite skin into Minecraft and vice versa
For the life of me, I can't understand why this is important. Nobody cares about this. I don't want to move skins around. Besides, if there's a digital marketplace, people will create their own duplicates of any 3D asset.
Just look at VRChat.
Zero value.
> The metaverse will have a fully functioning economy.
"You wouldn't download a car."
I can see pay to play, commissioned 3D asset work, etc., but ultimately most things digital can be replicated and copied cheaply.
> There will be no cap on concurrent users.
Even so, kids will still be telling each other to join their customized private Minecraft servers.
A system without rules and moderation allows communities to grow in their own ways.
The best metaverse platform will have a downloadable, moddable client and server that lets people spin up their own instances.
- rideontime 5y agoIt also isn't actually happening! I have yet to see anybody give a technical explanation of how the "metaverse" enables this.
- jerf 5y agoYou can read between the lines here, and then the value proposition becomes much more clear for Facebook. For this to work, they'd basically need to provide a common engine for everything using the Metaverse. Rather than Second Life, people should be thinking Roblox as the closest existing technical implementation. So, what's the value proposition in killing all existing 3D engines and completely replacing them? Obviously high if you can pull it off. But this "metaverse" thing is really easy to write whitepapers and even fiction about it when you don't have to actually implement it, but gets a lot trickier in the implementation. For instance, right now, 3D engines are undergoing some pretty major changes in every release. This is not generally the time someone can swoop in and stabilize everyone on a particular engine for long periods of time, because while the "metaverse" is being written on this gen, Unreal Engine is advancing to the next level, and stuff written on that engine is going to be easier to write and look a lot better than the "meta" engine. There's actually some deep and fundamental reasons Roblox looks and plays the way it does. There's other issues too; the "metaverse" envisions all this cross-platform avatar stuff, but are you going to play Call of Duty and its gritty "realistic" gameplay with 24 cartoony dufuses? No. Is Disney going to just happily license all of its characters to go into Call of Duty and get shot and bloodied? No. Are you going to be able to take your trademarked character everywhere with you? Exactly as well as you can stream whatever content you want from any content streamer today. Building the technical platform is already a multi-billion dollar problem. There's a good chance it won't work well when it's done, but even if they overcome that, then they've got abundant legal barriers to overcome, in an environment where other companies are going to have every incentive to sue for their chunks of flesh. I can also virtually guarantee that we're going to see very targeted demos, where the demos that Facebook puts out works well, because they were written in conjunction with the engine team, so the engine has exactly the features necessary to make the demo work, and nothing else. When EA goes to port Call of Duty into the metaverse, it's going to be a nightmare bug fest that looks like garbage compared to the real release. When you think about the tech necessary to accomplish their goals, and then consider the social and industry implications of that tech, it's hard to see how to reach their lofty goals. The metaverse simply implies a level of cooperation and voluntary power ceding and a lowest-common-denominator environment that can't hold up the fictional portrayals driving the hype. (I think ultimately it's a category error I've seen a lot. Fiction can be good at pointing the general direction the future may be, but taking fiction as a technical blueprint never works out well that I can see.)
- 4bQVhUkn8CEdNa 5y ago> You wouldn't download a car. I would if I could 3D print it at home, but that might end up serving an actual purpose, which runs counter to FB's ethos.
- johnday 5y ago> This means being able to bring a Fortnite skin into Minecraft and vice versa This is nothing. Fortnite and Minecraft are not built the same, so what this means is that someone built a Fortnite skin, and a Minecraft skin, and told Meta about both. It's not "interoperable" if it's just someone doing all the work twice. Besides, why would Epic and Microsoft both roll over for Facebook here? There's an intrinsic benefit to rival corps flatly ignoring Meta and waiting for it to go away.
- gunshai 5y agoNot to you or anyone in this room perhaps, but to a child who their entire life revolves around fortnite and minecraft it... May provide some value. My personal belief is that reality will probably represent your assessment.