3 ms·
I have a different view of the situation: while the emotional rewards from pets are nonzero, animals are, objectively, filthy. Keeping them indoors (and in one'
by sneak 5y ago
I have a different view of the situation: while the emotional rewards from pets are nonzero, animals are, objectively, filthy. Keeping them indoors (and in one's bed/bedroom) means that even with the best cleaning regimen, your house is perpetually dirty.
Imagine if someone who only bathed a couple times per month rolled around in your bed every day.
Many people are fine with being dirty, so there isn't a moral argument against pets here, just a personal preference, but if you shower more than three times per week then your decision to have a cat or dog in your bed and on your sofa is inconsistent.
- NineStarPoint 5y agoA healthy cat spends a gigantic portion of their waking hours grooming themself. How clean this makes then is debatable (especially because of litter boxes), but overall they tend to be much cleaner than other pets.
- sneak 5y agoCats aren't clean after grooming, in the sense we mean by "clean laundry". In fact, cats are much more dirty after grooming, given that their saliva is a primary contributing factor to the contaminants that they spread everywhere they go.
- derstander 5y agoThere is a possibility that exposure to cats and dogs as a child or young adult is protective against the development of allergic sensitization [0]. This isn’t my field so I have no idea if or how this relates to something like the hygiene hypothesis. I guess it just suggests that maybe there is something to not being “too” clean. ;) [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2783630/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2783630/
- sneak 5y agoI had exposure to cats and dogs and a filthy house as a child, and I'm still allergic to cats, dogs, and dust.
- derstander 5y agoAlas, an anecdote is not data. But if it were — as a counterbalance — I had exposure to cats, dogs, and other farm animals and am not allergic to anything to my knowledge.