10 ms·
Nym Wars (Google+ "real name" rules)
- wccrawford 15y agoI had a feeling the policing of this was stupid, but I didn't think it would be downright incompetent. If you can't police a policy properly, don't have it in the first place! Especially one that serves no real purpose and incites so much anger. Jeez.
- yanw 15y agoAny anger here is manufactured. It's just a way for social-media types to publicize their social web theories.
- sixtofour 15y agoYes, my account is scheduled for suspension tomorrow, for attempting to use my real "wallet name," which happens to be a mononym. I'm angry. I'm particularly angry at their oily statement that I don't "comply" and that I'm free to leave. Google has manufactured that anger.
- alextp 15y agoAbout the McLovin ID thing, I don't think it's Google's responsability to police which ids are fake and which are not. As far as I know faking an ID is a misdemeanor or a felony in most US states [1] and some other countries (like Brazil), so if there is any complaint against a reporter and he is found to have submitted a fake ID he is in for a fine and maybe jail time. I'm personally ok with requiring a user to commit a crime to cause antisocial behavior, as this ensures that they can be prosecuted in some way (this is the same principle behind DMCA takedown notices, where the person sending the letter is liable for a number of crimes if they are not who they claim to be or if they do not in fact own the right to the media at hand). [1] http://www.celticfringe.net/teenlife/fakeid.html http://www.celticfringe.net/teenlife/fakeid.html ) and
- sp332 15y agoThis isn't about liability. They already have common carrier status, which means that they won't be held accountable for what users say. This is about the kind of community they want to have. Unfortunately, by putting restrictions on the kind of community they want, they have also restricted the number of people who will be able to participate. Google+ can never be universal if they limit the interactions people are allowed to have.
- shabble 15y ago"[x] I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the information in this notification is correct." From http://4.bp.blogspot.com/--qy3pZh_8qI/TkFAOdMMLvI/AAAAAAAABio/iuryzo6MPG0/s1600/Impersonation_report_form.png http://4.bp.blogspot.com/--qy3pZh_8qI/TkFAOdMMLvI/AAAAAAAABi... No idea how enforceable that is, from any legal standpoint, but you can't claim you didn't know about it, at least.
- Joakal 15y agoGoogle's handling is pretty cold. They encountered a critical issue with having a social [human] network, their support isn't human. They prefer automation over everything. And that aim will keep biting them in the ass.
- jrockway 15y agoI'm not so sure. Look at all the companies that have non-automated support: Best Buy, Comcast, Bank of America, and so on. Nobody likes those companies either. Ultimately, being nice to people doesn't scale. And making money requires scaling.
- yanw 15y agoIt's nowhere near the big issue that the self-described activists think it is. I'm certain the data suggests that using real names isn't a problem for the vast majority of people but merely the obsession of the very loud and self-righteous few, besides it's still a closed beta product and any such criticisms don't apply until they say that it's ready and open for all.
- sp332 15y agoHave you even looked at http://my.nameis.me/ http://my.nameis.me/ ? These aren't (just) activists, these are individuals who are directly affected by this issue and have many individual reasons for using pseudonyms. None of them are allowed to participate in Google+.
- yanw 15y agoI'm not saying that pseudonyms are without legitimate purpose, I'm saying that Google has decided to enforce certain rules to build their community and this response is deafening and unnecessary.
- MostAwesomeDude 15y agoYou're right. We should allow companies as big and potentially malicious as Google to build the biggest walled gardens they can afford to support.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- rimantas 15y agoIf people don't like walled gardens, they won't go there. If they do go, that means they are OK. I myself enjoy my real name and walled gardens.
- MostAwesomeDude 15y ago
- cookiecaper 15y agoThe proposition that "real names" significantly enhances a user experience is a bit silly, I think. It may contribute in some small way as far as what you're willing to admit, but generally it doesn't seem to change behavior a lot. The quality of commentary on a public comment platform has much more to do with a given community's moderation and social mechanisms than the username that appears above the comment. YouTube is a mess because it's a hit-and-run system, there is no social obligation, you just type what you think about the video and never look at it again. Additionally, YouTube has a short length limit on comments precluding in-depth discussions, and YouTube's audience is very varied and primarily non-specialized. There are many public messaging systems online that have flourished and maintain a high level of quality even though they allow pseudonyms. Hacker News, for instance. I can think of five or six high-quality messaging systems wherein I have actively participated off the top of my head that were not flooded with YouTube-esque idiocy -- the name policy really has very little to do with it, I think. Google+ is completely controlled by its users; you must explicitly accept any author's content that you wish to view and you can block and explicitly reject any author's content that rubs you the wrong way. It is a fundamentally different model than YouTube. In this case, people are generally only going to accept you into their circles if they know who you are at least vaguely, whether the displayed name is "cookiecaper" or "Jeff Cook". I just don't see the point in even having the argument regarding Google+ when it has to be explicitly regulated by the user anyway. Facebook likewise. I think the real motivation here on the part of both Google and Facebook is to discourage the use of multiple identities so that it's easier to target advertising. Pseudonymity is still possible, though, so I'm still not sure why this is such a major deal, because you can just go create a Google Account with whatever plausible name you can dream up. You can then reveal your identity to the persons you'd like and everyone else knows you as generic John Smith. In fact, I do this on Facebook, and I presume that many others with an interest in pseudonymity do so as well.
- yanw 15y agoI don't think there has to be an ulterior motive to this sort of policy, they have decided upon a set of rules to build their community and that is it. And persons with theories about how socializing on the web should be, start chiming-in as they chose this pseudonym topic to publicize and unfold their theories and criticisms. They can go elsewhere to be as pseudo-anonymous as they like, I recognize that pseudonyms have legitimate purpose but all this self entitled rhetoric is just trolling.
- gambler 15y agoThe notion that using "real names" improves the quality of communication is not just wrong, it's utterly ridiculous. What it impels is that the (best? fastest? surest?) way get "better" conversations is to make sure that everyone is afraid of some sort of retribution for what they say. As far as I can see, that is the only thing "real names" achieve. After that, you can coat it any rhetoric you want, it still remain an ugly idea.
- protomyth 15y ago"When the rebuttal to your argument is The Federalist Papers, generally that means that you've lost the argument." That is one of the golden lines of the article and so true. This quest for better targeting of ads is painful. Also, I cannot wait until some of the folks on the reservations start getting flagged by Google. Many of the names people are know by violate Google's naming policy.
- sixtofour 15y agoTo solve the perceived "quality" problem (and that perception is itself a problem), Google has, true to form, relied on a technical barrier (must have one and only one first name, one and only one last name). They have then all but automated catching the ones that get through the barrier, by soliciting users to report fakes. Whether they review those reports before notice to suspend is an excellent question, one that Violet Blue has probably asked. https://plus.google.com/105822688186016123722/posts/LWySptwhW7g https://plus.google.com/105822688186016123722/posts/LWySptwh... Google's monolithic lack of customer service is well known, and I believe it starts with good intentions, trying to automate the management of the problem as much as possible. The problem comes from believing too much in their algorithms and automated solutions. They're all very smart, but their solutions are not as smart as they think. Or, maybe they're even smarter than I think, and they've gone the Pinto route and calculated that a certain amount of customer "disasters" is relatively tolerable.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- yuhong 15y agoPersonally, I am not for real name policies, but the problems with using real names needs to be fixed if possible.
- pasbesoin 15y agoSome of the best, most meaningful and informative "social" participation I've had online has been with pseudonyms. And those people would not have been there if not for the pseudonyms. (People shared their real names if and as there were ready, and one-to-one. I'm still in touch with many of them, a decade and more later.) I'm not terribly interested in Google's (and Facebook's, et al.) seemingly self-serving "speculation" on this topic. I'll base my opinion, and decisions, on real experience. Buzz. Wave. Get on the clue train, folks.
- Estragon 15y agoIt's a shame that Google hasn't chosen to address this in the empirical fashion they're famous for: why not have two google+'s for a while, one which enforces the "real names" policy, and one which is free for all. See which results in the better data.
- FaceKicker 15y agoBecause that wouldn't replicate a world in which either one existed as the sole Google+...like, at all.
- EGreg 15y agoYour site hurts my eyes
- gbog 15y agoI haven't seen anywhere noted that a significant part of humanity don't have surnames, eg many Indonesians. How to enforce a real name-like policy under these conditions?
- shabble 15y agoOr the massive variation in transliteration from non-latin alphabets. Not to mention, the vast majority of Chinese students I met at uni would pick an easily pronounceable "English" name. I bet that's not on their passport.
- gbog 15y agoChinese people with English names: a bit off-topic but the current trend for Chinese where I work and around (Beijing Web corps) is to avoid these English names and use the pinyin translitteration or abbreviations instead, but this also is a can of worms if one want to enforce real name policy. In the South of China some people's family name is just "Ng", some legitimate transliteration of a given name could be "nvzhi" where "i" is not a vowel but "v" is! I which a good time for the humans or the bots that will have to enforce real name policies there...