9 ms·
You should set a standard you can live with. If you're boycotting one company for something that you tolerate dozens of other companies doing, you should probab
by lmm 5y ago
You should set a standard you can live with. If you're boycotting one company for something that you tolerate dozens of other companies doing, you should probably reconsider.
- Hnrobert42 5y agoWhy?
- lmm 5y agoBecause it makes your boycott seem entirely arbitrary, and that's likely to make it ineffective.
- zem 5y agothe effect is that they, and hopefully their friends and family who come to them for advice, don't buy lenovo's products. that's independent of what else they happen to be boycotting.
- lmm 5y agoPresumably the goal is that Lenovo change their practices, institute better oversight, etc..
- playpause 5y agoRight. Where does boycotting Sony come into that? Do you think there’s no value in a positive action unless the person doing it also did some other, unrelated positive action? Why? I think you’re just playing gotcha.
- lmm 5y agoI think if Lenovo's CEO can tell the board "look, we can see x% of customers are anti-rootkitting and avoid companies that use rootkits, therefore we want to switch away from rootkits" that's going to be a lot more effective than "some guys are boycotting us; they say it's about the rootkits but really who knows".
- playpause 5y agoYou think that a Lenovo CEO will be completely unconcerned with a boycott of Lenovo products… because their competitors aren’t also being boycotted? Or just less concerned? If you mean just “less concerned”, then even then, that means the boycott still has some value, right? So what is wrong with someone just boycotting one of two “bad” companies? Just to transpose the logic to a different situation: say if someone gives $10 to a charity fundraiser, but they actually had $20 in their wallet, does that make their $10 donation less valuable? If this is not a fair comparison, please help me understand exactly what the relevant difference is.
- lmm 5y ago> You think that a Lenovo CEO will be completely unconcerned with a boycott of Lenovo products… because their competitors aren’t also being boycotted? Or just less concerned? I mean unlikely to take the actions you're trying to push for. If you're not consistent about when to boycott a company, how can they trust you to be consistent about when to stop boycotting a company?
- playpause 5y agoSo, completely unconcerned, or just less concerned? Which?
- lmm 5y agoOverwhelmingly less likely to take the desired actions. I wouldn't presume to judge the difference between say 0.1% as likely and not at all likely.
- CRConrad 5y ago> ...the difference between say 0.1% as likely and not at all likely. Heh, to think that this sub-thread began with someone (you? Can't recall) complaining about "arbitrary" boycotting... That's a mighty arbitrary number you've got there. What's to say the difference isn't actually between 80% and 99%?
- Hnrobert42 5y agoOk. That’s a good argument. I’ve never been on the seller side of a boycott. I wonder if they consider things like this when they respond to a boycott.
- CRConrad 5y agoEven if nobody boycotts all companies that would be deserving of it, other people probably (just as arbitrarily) pick others from the same set, so it evens out and they all get boycotted by at least some people.