57 ms·
Canadian Real Estate Prices Are Overvalued by Up to 91%: Moody’s
- moneywoes 5y agoMeanwhile single family homes continue rising year after year
- hourislate 5y agoIn 1990 the house next door (Bloor West Village, Toronto) sold for 500k. A year later it was worth somewhere between 250-275k. It took all the way to 2005 for it to sell again for 500k. It sold again a few months ago (after a shitty reno) for almost 2 million, It almost doubled in value from what I can recall over the last 2 years. The new owner is a holding company based out of Vancouver. It is sitting empty from what I can tell with the odd visitor every few of weeks. I have seen Condo's double in price over a period of about 6-8 months Between Oct 2019 to about May/June of 2020) and then go up another 50% after that. House prices are going up over $1k a week and even land that has a road allowance but no road or utilities in Northern Ontario (Muskoka) has gone up over 100 % in the first few months of 2020. My guess is Toronto real estate will easily double over the next 5 years. The Federal Government and BoC will never be able to raise interest rates meaningfully without collapsing the entire economy. Young Canadians will have nothing but the yoke of debt around their necks and live hand to mouth.
- foepys 5y agoAt some point it cannot continue this way. I wonder what will happen when those empty houses suddenly cannot sell for more than their purchase price. Will people start living there because now they aren't a burden to the new owner? Or will the market promply crash so even moderately wealthy people will lose their previously overvalued houses because they cannot pay their mortgages anymore due to rising interests?
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoWhy can't it continue this way? You can expand credit forever. Interest rates can go negative. It is NOT a free market. The Bank of Canada controls the price of debt. Debt is the majority of the economy. It will obviously lead to a sicker and sicker and more unequal (and unfair) economy. But the Bank of Canada isn't really accountable to anyone. It could continue its path for at least the rest of our lifetimes, in theory.
- refurb 5y agoBank of Canada has already signaled interest rates will be rising faster than expected. They will have no choice - if rates don’t go up they’ll have inflation problems compounded by a falling dollar.
- hourislate 5y agoInterest rates will not be over 5 % in our lifetime (50 years plus). Average home price in TO will be well over 2-3 million in the next decade. BoC understands that any meaningful rise will cause economic calamity that will leave everyone naked and hungry in the streets and a collapse of the financial system. Just saying...
- refurb 5y agoNope. If they don’t increase interest rates (and they are clearly moving faster than what they said a year ago) inflation will skyrocket and the Canadian dollar will be crushed, causing more price inflation due to imports. The BOC will have no choice. They’ve just painted themselves into a corner.
- Marsymars 5y agoIn such a collapse, are the houses just all going to be empty?
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoA low dollar (within reason) benefits central Canada, with our manufacturing exports. Ontario & Quebec suffered quite a bit when the price of oil (and thus the dollar) was high back about 10 years ago.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoWhen my wife's grandfather passed away (2008 I think?), her mom&uncle sold their neglected and sad old house in Bloor West Village for about $500k, in a pretty bad state. My wife and I had just bought our first home a couple years before, and we kinda pondered buying the grandparents' place off family, but figured we couldn't possibly swing the mortgage to get the renos done. What a missed opportunity, we'd be sitting on a goldmine now. The new owner just let it sit there for years; haven't been by to see what has been done to it.
- aborsy 5y agoWhat are the causes? The article doesn’t explain.
- ewalk153 5y agoSpeaking for Montreal here: there is a lot of demand chasing a limited supply. I’ve seen prices increase by ~30% in my neighborhood over the past 3 years.
- betaby 5y agoAnd neither of the mayoral candidates propose anything actionable. Current elections are disappointing even before results are known.
- Factorium 5y agoImmigration of 400,000 people annually. The Government has announced it will increase immigration levels: https://www.cicnews.com/2020/10/canada-to-release-2021-2023-immigration-levels-plan-1016133.html https://www.cicnews.com/2020/10/canada-to-release-2021-2023-... Drives down wages, drives up asset values. Great for the elite. Furthermore, the new arrivals (from 2nd/3rd world countries) don't complain: they're happy just to be there.
- msie 5y agoI don’t see how immigrants from 2nd/3rd world countries are directly affecting prices. You said yourself wages are down.
- newaccount2021 5y agoIts not just the valuation, its the % of the economy that is now derived from RE transactions - Canada relies more on RE transactions than...pretty much anywhere. Its no longer an exaggeration to say the Canadian economy is primarily a manifestation of domestic monetary policy and Chinese speculation. There is still resource extraction, but that is also under pressure as the world moves away from fossil fuels. All bubbles end, when this one ends, Canada will be demolished, and every Canadian social institution (healthcare, education, etc) will be gutted. The only way to avoid that fate is to effectively sell the nation to China, which appears to be what may happen. Canada as a Chinese client state...it may happen.
- m0zg 5y agoI feel like my own house here in the US is overvalued by roughly 4x. There's no way a glorified wooden box is worth $2M, especially considering I bought it at one third the price. And the way things are going, it'll probably tack on another million by the time I sell it next year after moving to a state with better climate and less onerous taxation. I bought my first house when I was in my mid-30s. I don't think I'd be able to do so with the price/income ratio as it exists today. Which, if you think about it, is a gaping, self-inflicted wound on society, and a completely unnecessary one. It's not like the US (or Canada) are lacking for land or building materials. It's the politicians getting in the way again.
- Waterluvian 5y agoI make considerably more than my parents combined when they bought our last family house in 1989. That house is now about twice what I can afford and about 600% what they paid for it. Having doubled in just the past few years. It’s ridiculous. My wife and I bought a house in rural Ontario. It appreciated by 25% in two years. It’s ridiculous. I don’t want property to be an investment asset. I want it to be a tool, as close to at-cost as reasonably possible. I want everyone to have secure homes. And not just by eternally paying rent.
- effingwewt 5y agoCompletely agreed, unfortunately we will never reverse this because every person using their house/property as an investment will cry foul. We need to offer tax breaks or something in lieu of appreciation of property. It's going to forever price out the younger generations, save those who make enough to absorb the costs or have credit/co-signers who do. What are the generations who don't own a house, have no retirement, supposed to do- work and pay rent( read- enriching the rich) until they drop dead? Ridiculous and sad.
- tata71 5y ago> credit/co-signers who do. It's how the new Feudal Lords will come about.
- listenallyall 5y agoMortgage rates in 1989 were over 10% (in USA, don't know about Canada) (http://www.freddiemac.com/pmms/pmms30.html http://www.freddiemac.com/pmms/pmms30.html). Obviously there are other factors in play as well -- income inequality, printing more dollars, international & corporate investment -- but low interest rates are likely the biggest influence, and the longer they stay artificially low, the more people assume they will never rise again.
- sjwalter 5y agoRates don't have much of an impact on affordability. If rates drop dramatically, then home prices rise in near lock-step, all those looser dollars flowing right back into the housing market. It means that with the same monthly payment, you're able to afford more (and people seem to shop based on what monthly payment they can afford, and are encouraged to do so by everyone from realtors to bankers). The inverse is true, too, with prices falling as rates increase (gee, remember way back in the day when that used to happen? 2018 was wild!).
- jleyank 5y agoCouple of things in contention. First, if work from home remains in place the need to be proximate to the office goes down. This will impact both commercial and residential prices “downtown”. Foreign money will continue to jack up Canadian prices, but Canadians might be less interested in doing so. Second, if a government makes an active effort to increase housing and decrease house prices they better be a majority. Otherwise they’ll lose to the party that “will defend people’s investments” and quickly stop subsidized construction. Finally, I have no feeling how mobile people are here. But it doesn’t seem to be high. Folks from Quebec tend to remain there. Folks from the prairies seem unwilling to move east. There’s not a lot of big cities and if the people won’t move demand will remain inelastic.
- brailsafe 5y agoIt's a bit of a guess, but it's my estimation that most people move west in Canada. People in the East move to either Toronto or the central prairies, and people in the central prairies tend to move to Alberta or BC. You can save money moving east if you're location is arbitrary, but I don't think it is for a lot of people.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI moved from Edmonton to Toronto in the late 90s and stayed. But I know very few people who did the same (though my wife's grandparents did the same exact migration.. just 50 years earlier). Most Albertans move west to BC if they leave the province.
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 5y agoThe price of housing is determined by the monthly payment that can be carried - after down payment helped by the bank of mom and dad. In a depressed interest rate environment, a larger mortgage can be carried. As rates go up, the mortgage you can qualify for goes down and people on variable rates or short terms (common in Canada where mortgages must be periodically renewed) can get in serious trouble.
- betaby 5y agoIf supply is very limited - yes. Price == max mortgage. So the solution is to build more and build up ... and that's not going to happen.
- mupuff1234 5y agoWhy aren't countries building new cities?
- missedthecue 5y agoThey are. https://news.cgtn.com/news/3d3d414d306b6a4d31457a6333566d54/img/7e33a80f00e9481aaf9f3302a44831fc/7e33a80f00e9481aaf9f3302a44831fc.jpg https://news.cgtn.com/news/3d3d414d306b6a4d31457a6333566d54/...
- brailsafe 5y agoAs an unemployed programmer in Vancouver, I've been thinking about the potential prospects of owning a place, and it seems like an inescapable conclusion that it's just for people who either got lucky with their career early on, or inherited it through some means. I don't think there's much of a controllable path to doing so at this point, it's somewhat all dependent on RNG, which isn't motivating. If I landed a very well-paying gig tomorrow, I'd need to luck into keeping it for at least 2-5 years, and then at best, if I could get a mortgage, I'd then be saddling myself with debt for the rest of my life. Kind of crazy to think about. Thankfully my landlords are cool. Of course, if I desperately needed to own a place, I could luck into a well-paying gig and afford a down-payment in the prairies after a few years, but then I'd be living there, and I'd rather rent here.